Product Reviews Rated 4.44 out of 5 stars
299 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Highly recommend! I have this in 2 colors - Sorry Sweetie and Darling. I first received Sorry Sweetie as a promotion and fell in love. Then I purchased Darling for myself. I love to use these as a base (although colors like Sorry Sweetie look great as a "one and done" eye color). I used to use the Mary Kay cream eye color as my base, but that has been discontinued. Similar to the MK, this product is a great primer for other eyeshadows. It layers well, lengthens the wear of anything else I put on with it, does not crease or smudge or fade. It easily comes off when I remove my makeup (oil cleanser or micellar water both work great!). I have oily lids and have trouble with products staying on. This stays better than Urban Decay primer and other primers I've tried, and is better than eyeshadow sticks like NudeStix (which even though recommended for oily lids, still did not stay on mine). I highly recommend! You can't beat the price, it has an EWG rating of 1, and it lasts for a long time even with everyday use.
Most Helpful Critical Review The pros to this... The pros to this product is the color is so beautiful and very pigmented, Cons is the formula is a bit clumpy and it does dry down super fast which could be a pro but since its clumpy makes it a bit hard to smoothly spread over the lid. All in all i do like this cream shadow and would recommend giving it a try if your looking for a liquid shadow with lots of color and sparkle!
Reviewed by 299 customers Love this product! It's exactly as promised. Matte and stays 5
BC from Western Massachusetts
Love this because it's exactly as promised.
Sorry Sweetie and Coco Nuts 5
Lvaltte from Portland
Coco nuts covers really well. It is a neutral color and helps to cover my kid veins and redness. Almost a hint of purple. Sorry sweetie is all glitter. It feels good uti wasn't expecting that much glitter. Pretty much no color just champagne glitter and Very nice for layering. It did not crease and was not tacky. Some complain it has little product and that is true but I used a very small amount and was please with the results. I am half Korean/German, light warm/neutral complexion
Love it! 5
Ambypop from New Mexico
This product is great! It goes on smoothly and the color is great, very shimmery.
Lovely 5
CD from Marlette, Michigan
Excellent color,goes on smoothly and can be built up for more intense color
Good 4
Steph from Alabama
This is such a beautiful line of shadows.... but.... it's way too expensive for drugstore makeup, especially in such a tiny tube.
Nice product but small 4
Beauty Guru Over 50 from Arizona
I'm always looking for crease proof, waterproof, eye shadow. This product met those needs. I bought a neutral color and felt all the colors were very similar and neutral, not too exciting. I would've liked to see a grey/silver/charcoal choice. Most of all the tube is tiny and for the price not a great deal. I'll be out of it quickly if used daily. Maybe that's the idea.
Highly recommend! 5
MoC from North Carolina
I have this in 2 colors - Sorry Sweetie and Darling. I first received Sorry Sweetie as a promotion and fell in love. Then I purchased Darling for myself. I love to use these as a base (although colors like Sorry Sweetie look great as a "one and done" eye color). I used to use the Mary Kay cream eye color as my base, but that has been discontinued. Similar to the MK, this product is a great primer for other eyeshadows. It layers well, lengthens the wear of anything else I put on with it, does not crease or smudge or fade. It easily comes off when I remove my makeup (oil cleanser or micellar water both work great!). I have oily lids and have trouble with products staying on. This stays better than Urban Decay primer and other primers I've tried, and is better than eyeshadow sticks like NudeStix (which even though recommended for oily lids, still did not stay on mine). I highly recommend! You can't beat the price, it has an EWG rating of 1, and it lasts for a long time even with everyday use.
I will buy this again. 5
Genie from Kentucky
This product has two uses. As a base for eyeshadow and all alone for a nice natural look.
The best eyeshadow I've ever used 5
KateB from Pennsylvania
I bought the colors Cocoa Nuts and Sorry Sweetie. Cocoa Nuts is a matte, taupe-like color that is subtle but gives the lids some dimension. Sorry Sweetie is a lovely shimmery gold color that looks amazing layered on top of Cocoa Nuts. This is the fist eyeshadow I've worn in my whole life that doesn't crease or fade throughout the day and I'm absolutely thrilled with them! The tubes look small, but a tiny dot goes a long way so they'll last a while. I'm definitely going to repurchase!
Wasn't Aware of Sparkle 3
SST from Burleson, TX
I am older and prefer not to have sparkles in eye shadow. I like that it was a cream, but wasn't aware that it had sparkle/glitter?
woooow one of my... 5
yilic from undisclosed
woooow one of my makeup things that I love the most and use without this I could not live I recommend them
Great Cream Eye Shadow 5
JosieR from Sonoma County
Most cream eye shadows I've purchased in the past have dried so quickly, I haven't been able to apply them satisfactorily. This one seems to be fine. I have applied it with both my fingertips and with a flat brush and it's gone on smoothly, before getting too dry. I bought the Cocoa-Nuts shade, which appears to be matte. I wanted to avoid any of the shades with glitter. They're very pretty but I always prefer matte for myself. I always use an eyelid primer, no matter what shadow I'm using, and this cream shadow stays in place all day with the primer. I'm not sure how it would be without using the primer. I'm definitely happy with this purchase!
I wasnt happy about... 1
monicaw23 from undisclosed
I wasnt happy about this product at all! It was very sticky on my eyelid even once it dried. I didnt like the look let alone the stickyness . I took it right off because my eyelid was sticking and it was hard to blink.
Awesome! 5
Amandalynn from Missouri
I love this stuff, I don't wear eye shadows much but I could wear this every day. It goes on nice and creamy, easy to blend and dries very nice.
lid paint 5
keilac22 from undisclosed
Love using this when cutting crease after my concealer makes my eyeshadow color pop out so perfect does not need improvement its easy to use and apply definitely recommend and Id definitely buy it again
These are incredible! 5
KloeC from GA
This is an amazing cream eyeshadow! It starts out very creamy and easy to blend but then it sets in place and doesn't budge! I have cocoanuts and it is a nice taupey gray ... perfect transition shade. I used my fingers and a brush and both work great!
I don't use an eyeshadow primer anymore because it's not budging!
The eye shodow 5
memberdd4b81 from undisclosed
I love all of these brands i love it and i love the colors to i really like it it is supper easy to put it on and suppee comftebull
This product is so... 5
millisab29 from undisclosed
This product is so amazing its soaking on my skin property on yours too and its just so smooth and its the best color you could have nothing better than this this is a good lipstick I love it its amazing
I quite like them and... 5
marilua5 from undisclosed
I quite like them and tried these and I loved them very good Very necessary excellent #Amazing #MakeUp
I love this stuff! I... 5
jenniferm70f5 from undisclosed
I love this stuff! I got it in a Voxbox and tried it out several different days varying application method. I found that the best way to use this product is to start with an eyelid primer and then put the lid paint on (I use my fingers) and then set it with a powder eyeshadow! A little goes a long way with this product too!
I honestly love liquid... 5
mmmesic from undisclosed
I honestly love liquid eye shadow more than powder. My eyes are always extremely dry even with skin care but this doesnt make it look like it and the color is really pretty and natural.
small but enough 4
carmenarroyo_ from undisclosed
This color is soooooo great! Perfect for when you just want to add a bit of sparkle to you eyes! Wish the packaging wasnt so small I feel like Im going to loose it. But with it being small its great for traveling
covergirl did not come to play! 5
debbieofficial from undisclosed
Covergirl did not come to play honey!! Currently loving these new covergirl Summer Shades!
Although im not much of a glitter girl, But the lid paint is definitely my favorite! It will make you go from basic to fancy in a sec ! A little goes a long way
great! 5
sangeetrawr from undisclosed
Ok so this product is kind of like a more pigmented version of Glossiers lid star. I found this to be buildable without getting clumpy or hard to work with the color pay off is lovely. This plus mascara is such a great minimal eye look!
GREAT PIGMENT 5
sudzz13 from undisclosed
I love this lid paint! The colors are really pigmented and go on so smooth, usually with lid paints Id have to use a glue or primer this one worked well with out one! Also it stayed on through out the day and didnt smudge or move, I will be purchasing the rest of the shades !