Product Reviews Rated 3.93 out of 5 stars
43 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Great cool palette! Eyeshadow palettes don't often have very cool tones. You always see warm palettes, but not usually cool ones. This is a gorgeous smoky palette, and every color is quite cool toned. These are gorgeous, pigmented, long lasting shadows that are perfect for creating a cool toned look. Theres a shimmery silver-white shade (perfect highlight), a matte yellowy nude, a light brown with pink shimmer, a very cool taupe brown, a mid tone brown with pink shimmer, a neutral brown with pink and gold shimmer, a matte dark brown, a matte dark charcoal gray, a shimmery black and a matte black. These shades are great for creating a smoky cool look. Great palette!
Most Helpful Critical Review Nice shade selection, Poor quality. Out of the 10 shades, there is only one that I enjoy (the 5 in the palette) and 3 that are decent and can be worked with (4,6,7). The rest of the matte shades are patchy and not pigmented at all, whilst the rest of the shimmer shades have PLENTY of fallout and don adhere to the lid. Had high hopes for the product and became deeply disappointed. All the shades unless the ones I mentioned blend out to nothing.
As for the swatches, please bear in mind that some were swatched several times in order for the color to be visible (mainly the 1, 2, 8 and 10th shade).
Reviewed by 43 customers Very nice for the money! 5
Carol from S Carolina
Easy to apply, some colors don't stay on all day!
I will always have this in my every day makeup 5
Hope from Tampa, Fl
This product is amazing for the price. They are blendable and perfect for every day.
Great palette 5
DANNIEDEE from Dudley
Lovely colours, creates great looks. Would definitely recommend this, and it's such a good price too.
Very Pigmented 5
StarChyld67 from San Antonio, Texas
Once i finally received my package i opened it like it was Christmas Day because i wanted to get a close up view of what i purchased and i wasn't disappointed, I love this palette.
Awesome 5
Carmen5 from Omaha, NE
Super pleased with this, and all the similar palettes released around the same time. They are so great for every day use.
Surprisingly Good palette 4
Lisa003 from Bridgeport, CT
I have been testing out this palette for a few days now to do simple looks and the pigment is pretty good. There is a bit of fallout though but you pay a really good price for what you get. The colors are all really nice and blend quite alright. Good palette overall and I will most definitely try the other ones out as well.
Great cool-toned palette! 5
KEBH from Birmingham, AL
I've had a hard time finding a cool-toned eye shadow palette. This one is beautiful. The colors are pigmented and blend easily. It really complements my blue eyes and grey hair.
My go-to MUST 5
annabagel01 from Michigan
I don't go anywhere without this palette. It's extremely versatile-- stunning pigments, great eyeliner, does day to night like a dream.
Very impressed for the price! 4
Ashley from Bristol, TN
Very smooth application and good for dat or night looks.
Perfect 5
lauren24 from undisclosed
I love how this pallet has neutral colors but also glitter colors to add brightness to complete makeup looks.
Chalky 1
Lisa from Texas
This palette does look beautiful,but right when i applied it,it was super chalky and ALOT OF FALLOUT!My eyes were super irritated and i did not like the formula at all!
Love these neutrals! 5
Kelly from Suffolk, VA
Goes on great and last!
Finally gave this a shot 5
Smokedbiscuit from undisclosed
For ages I've been looking for a cool palette for everything from Smokey to just subtly contoured eye looks. I didn't think elf was bad quality but I kept shopping around for things before I finally scooped up this palette, and now I wish I'd just saved my time and money and started with this. I've loved everything in it, which never happens. Even the brown and slightly rosy shimner which I usually don't care for was so nice on me. I used primer and no primer and honestly, I kind of don't want to use anything else. I like a good cool toned contoured eye look or a nice old fashioned smokey, grungey eye. This can go natural or build up and I love it. I don't repurchase eyeshadow much or care for back ups, but I would for this palette. Now I want the others, possibly the mad mattes, but I'm going to relax and enjoy this palette for a while. It's definitely underrated, even at 4.5 stars.
It's easy to blend and a everyday smokey eye. 5
Ashley from Rockaway township mall
its easy to blend
Really nice, just need a few more matte choices 4
Sandie from Avenel NJ
I love the colors but there should be more matte colors than frosted glittery colors
MY FAVORITR 5
sydney3three from Indiana
all E.L.F. madd for matte eyeshadow palettes are my favorite formula I've ever used. Over all high end , even viseart lol. Seriously love. And this palette is my favorite of them all just because I love the colors.!
eh 2
tavita from 7389292
this is an okay pallette. there is way too much fallout and the colors seem very boring. but the colors do blend out well.
Really Great 5
MrsDuke from Utah
This is a great neutral palette that is great for day to night. If you're in a hurry, just grab this palette. You can definitely get a lighter, more natural look and then darken it up to go out.
Don't recommend 1
Chayse from Illinois
There is so much fallout! No pigment what so ever made a mess in my makeup bin and ended up throwing it out.
It's Pretty Good But....... 4
Lindsay Clifford from Twin Cities, MN
So I just bought this palette and I am pleasantly surprised. I have tried the dark brown as a smokey eye and it worked... until i started blending. I had to put a little more color even some black. When I added the color and blended it. It actually turned out pretty decent. Another issue is the fallout. Eyeshadow keeps ending up under my eye.
Elf Eyeshadow 1
Sissy from Winter Haven Florida
I think it would be OK but I don't know because I grabbed it to go somewhere and found out there is no Brush it should have a brush with it all of them do
Good color but bad fall-out 3
ShutUp from Rome, Ga
I have been using this eyeshadow for a month and I like it pretty well. There are a lot of colors, It has decent pigmentation and the shimmer is pretty but the fall-out is terrible. You have to dab the brush into the eyeshadow instead of swipe or a lot of dust/fall-out will be created and wasted as it falls off the palette.
Gift from a friend 3
kirstie from Chicago, IL
I recieved this palette as a holiday gift. I also own the mad for matte neutral palette, and honestly I prefer the mad for matte. The colors are similar even though this smoky palette has a shimmer/satin shade. The tones in the smoky palette are all quite similar to one another and it's hard to create contrast. Good quality, but not a lot of versatility in the looks you can create!
Loooove 5
Ace from Maine
Absolutely love this palette! I wasn't sure how I felt about it not coming with a brush. I apply and blend it with my finger and it is perfect! I have gotten so many compliments this week when I have it on! Thinking about ordering another to have as a backup!
I love this palette! 5
dlcgrmi1976 from Wyoming, MI
I got this palette free with my purchase. This is the first eyeshadow palette that I used from this brand, and I love it! The colors blend so wonderfully, and I'm surprised how long they last. I hour shift, which means I have them on between 11 to 12 hours, and they last. Thank-you, elf! I'll be looking at more of your eyeshadows!
