Rated 3.9 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review LOVE this liner
I'll be the first to admit - I often have difficulty applying liquid and gel-type liners. I can use a eyeliner pencil like nobody's business, but otherwise I tend to make a mess of it. I love this mousse liner! I can apply it perfectly every time. I use a short liner brush for more control and I find that it's super easy to get a beautiful line right along my lashes. It goes on super smooth and doesn't rub off on my brow bone like liquid liners usually do. It lasts all day with no smudging. Really, this is the perfect liner! Now if Nyx will release this formula in some additional colours I'll be set.
Most Helpful Critical Review Great For The Price
For the money, this is the best gel eyeliner you can buy. I prefer Bobbi Brown's, but this is pretty close for a drugstore price.
I found that it went on smoothly, but my brush was picking up a ton of clumps of product (mousse, of course). But a skilled hand can easily distribute it.
The product stayed all day, dried matte, and looked great. Great for someone who wants to try gel eyeliners for the first time.
Reviewed by 232 customers Not the best
ZZ from Houston, Tx
It was a great product at the first use, very good pigmentation, and it would glide on smoothly, but then after opening the package the product dried out. And it would clump making it hard to pick up product. My angled brush would be left with a lot of the product and I would have to wash it off just to get rid of it. You would say this liner could last a whole year or maybe more but It didn't last me more then 3 months. :(
My favorite eye liner
Momofmakeupartist from Portland, OR
I use this to line my upper lid. I'm not a very experimental or trendy make up user. This is easy to apply and works for me. I'm sure for a more creative makeup person would love it because it's so easy to apply and goes on so smooth.
Not the best
Liv from New Orleans
Flakes? Never had an eyeliner flake. Upside is very black but also transfers to my crease throughout the day and won't rub off
love it, but dries out in pot fast
Memento Mori from Louisiana
This is my favorite eye liner. I love that it comes in a pot so I can use whichever brush I want for fine details. It goes on smooth, if you work fast you can smudge it, and it lasts me all day. The issue with it, is that it dries out in the pot so so quickly, you don't get all the use out of it. Using a mixing medium and lots of working it in, you can bring it back to life, but it still doesn't compare to what it was before.
Waywardkitty from Houston, Tx
Honestly I was excited because people said it was a good gel liner but it was so dry that I could hardly make straight lines I had to keep dipping over and over. If you're a beginner when it comes to gel liner I would not recommend this, the only upside is that once it's on it stay on for a long time.
April W from Follansbee WV
Compared to most brands, it's a decent priced product. Love that you make it in waterproof & in matte. I wish it would last a little longer. It always dries out & gets clumpy way to fast. & you don't have to have it long for it to start messing up either.
Not for me.
Samantha29 from Juneau Alaska
I guess I must have gotten one from a bad batch, because this liner is extremely dry and it hard to apply. I have to go back to the pot several times to finish my every day winged liner. And when I remove it, it doesn't come off easily; I have to scrub which causes it to crumble and become scratchy.
A Good Mousse Eyeliner!
Attila the Shopper from Erlanger, Kentucky
A good eyeliner, at a terrific price. My only complaint is that it takes too long to dry. Will likely purchase this again. It stays on until I take it off.
Goes on smooth
Shellmore from Madison wi
Stayed on for quite awhile and doesn't flake or smear and glides on smoothly..was looking for one to replace my Clinique one that I loved but they discontinued...I think I've found it and it's much cheaper!
its pretty good
flumenis from orlando, fl.
the only complaint i have about this liner is that it needs multiple layers to really keep the bold look
Best Gel Liner
angie from los angeles
Its the most black drugstore liner ive seen. i wore it for 12 hours and had no smudging though i did notice if you make mistakes and layer over them then itll flake a little throughout the day but thats not a deal breaker. its amazing and theres a lot that comes with it
A must have
Janet from Bonita Springs, FL
This epic black mousse liner is a must have.
Easy to apply ~ Goes on like mousse.
The perfect finishing touch to your eye make-up.
I have received so many complaints since I've added this mousse liner to my daily make-up routine.
It's truly a must have.
I've been waiting for something like this...
Rachel from PA
I have been waiting for a product like this all my life, and I just discovered it. Mousse liner. Wow, it's a game changer. Goes on so smooth, stays on all day with very little smudge throughout the day. Can be a little more difficult to get off than pencil liner, but I use a pretty good makeup remover.
Jessijm from Baltimore
Great dark pigment but doesnt stay put, smears after a few hours.
niad1 from New Castle
Like this eyeliner. it is my go-to eyeliner, especially when I want to do winged eyeliner. it is super black.
First Mousse Liner
MakeupLover from Tennessee
This is the first time I've ever really tried a gel/mousse liner and I love it! It is so smooth and creamy and easy to apply.
Great formula but irritated eyes
Ty from Atlanta
I have really oily lids, this was the first time I'd bought an eyeliner that wasn't a pencil and I really wanted to love it. It goes on really creamy, dries quickly, and most importantly didn't run. My eyeliner tends to clump in the outer corner in an oily mess by midday but this did not budge. However, I've noticed my eye lid is really irritated the next day, even puffy. The first time it happened I thought maybe I hadn't done a good job removing my makeup but it's happened more than once now and this liner is the only constant. I don't think there is anything wrong with the product it just may not be the best option for more sensitive eyes which sucks because I really loved it.
Also: I did notice it started drying rather quickly in the jar. I agree with the other commenters that I probably wouldn't have gotten halfway through it before it was unusable.
good but dries quickly
Young Grammar from Orange County cali
I actually really like this eyeliner but my biggest issue with it is that I have bought it like 3 times and I am yet to get thru a jar. I don't use it every time I do my makeup and I find that no matter what I do it dries out quickly. there is a small foam piece that comes with it under the lid when you first get it. I have removed that and threw it out and it dried. So the next time I left that on every time I resealed the jar and it still dried up. I would say it lasts maybe 2 months before drying out. there is no way I could use it up that quickly. otherwise it is a great line. It is really black and stays put. I find it hard to get a really good line with it but I think that is more the brush than the liner. some are better than others at this and as they get older and are washed many times they break down quickly. Also they are out of it at the store often.
Super black liner
Aaisha6095 from Washington DC
I like this product. I can get a super black wing line, or use less product to make it soft like Eyeshadow wing. It dries almost instantly after applying it and dries matte. It comes easily with a cleansing solution (face wash) and it stays in place and doesn't smudge on me. I'm not sure if it's waterproof though.
Used it twice and it is a no go
CareyLDD from Maine
I bought this at the recommendation of a sales clerk. I usually use MAC in a black/brown putty for years but it seems to run and fade by mid afternoon. I was looking for something with real staying power.
I applied this new one before going out to dinner and by the time I got home a few hours later is looked horrible. Raccoon eyes for sure. Even after trying to clean it up with a q-tip is still looked bag. Used it twice with the same results.
El mejor liner
Jelissa from Puerto Rico
Me encanta es a prueba de agua y dura mucho tiempo
KanKan from Baltimore, Maryland
I wore this liner yesterday to work. I guess I must have sneezed or squinted my eyes at some point but all I know is that I have black ink all over my eyes! It had smudged everywhere!! and of course no one said anything so who knows how long I was waking around looking like a Gothic princess.......
love hate relationship
AlyG from McAllen, Texas
I gave it 3 stars because if i could actually make it through the entire pot itd be 5. when first purchased its black goes on smooth and lasts all day. But this is the second time i buy this and it becomes hard to work with gets clumpy and it even hurts my eye as im trying to use it. I use eyeliner everyday and am by no means an expert but i got to the point where im pretty good at doing a wing or cat eye and for the same price i can just by the maybeline gel eyeliner which i actually make it through the pot. I only prefer your because it doesnt transfer and its super black and matte
Sylv1203 from National City, CA
The first couple of times I used this product it glided on with ease. By the second week it became dry and clumpy making it difficult to use.
schoi from Seattle, Wa
I bought this many times, works well and stays well.