Product Reviews Rated 3.28 out of 5 stars
18 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review new fav for me Bought this without thinking because I needed a new mascara and I'm so glad I did! Mascara is really personal to everyone and I found that most mascara is very drying on me to the point where a number of them just straight up fall off every night when I remove it with the gentlest cleansing oils. I've been using this one for a month now and have noticed significantly less fall out as well as just better lash health over all. My eyelashes feel like they can stand a chance now with tugging and curling instead of just falling off and landing on my eyeball from a single blink (ouch!). When it comes to the formula, it is very creamy and can be a little too much if you don't blot before application. It does dry a bit faster than some covergirl máscaras I'm used to so careful when applying more than one coat since I'm sure that was what caused some complaints on here with the flaking. I only apply one coat since I prefer the minimalist look and have absolutely no flaking. There is a bit of a learning curl as all mascaras have and it al depends on what you prefer. I've noticed this brand overall celebrates a more natural look (think of a more leveled up glossier with a bit of coverage) so less is always more when it comes to application. If you're the type that likes to apply coat after coat, this may not be for you.
Most Helpful Critical Review Glory Review: Lacks volume, fragrance gives me a headache The Too Faced Waterproof BTS mascara has been the best mascara I have tried. However, I'm currently in search for a replacement that is not waterproof as to not continue damaging my lashes. My lashes have pretty good length and stay curled ....... until I apply mascara. I need volume and a mascara that doesn't weigh my lashes down.
First of all, this mascara is strongly fragranced, smells like amplified hotel bar soap. The smell lingers for about an hour and gives me a headache. It didn't give me volume and although it didn't weigh my lashes as much as other high end mascaras it wasn't great either. The brush is very similar to the BTS mascara. I tried it over the Milani lash primer, this helped with the volume but I won't keep it because of the fragrance.
Reviewed by 18 customers Glory Review: Lacks volume, fragrance gives me a headache 1
Glory from California
The Too Faced Waterproof BTS mascara has been the best mascara I have tried. However, I'm currently in search for a replacement that is not waterproof as to not continue damaging my lashes. My lashes have pretty good length and stay curled ....... until I apply mascara. I need volume and a mascara that doesn't weigh my lashes down.
First of all, this mascara is strongly fragranced, smells like amplified hotel bar soap. The smell lingers for about an hour and gives me a headache. It didn't give me volume and although it didn't weigh my lashes as much as other high end mascaras it wasn't great either. The brush is very similar to the BTS mascara. I tried it over the Milani lash primer, this helped with the volume but I won't keep it because of the fragrance.
new fav for me 5
ricebean from USA
Bought this without thinking because I needed a new mascara and I'm so glad I did! Mascara is really personal to everyone and I found that most mascara is very drying on me to the point where a number of them just straight up fall off every night when I remove it with the gentlest cleansing oils. I've been using this one for a month now and have noticed significantly less fall out as well as just better lash health over all. My eyelashes feel like they can stand a chance now with tugging and curling instead of just falling off and landing on my eyeball from a single blink (ouch!). When it comes to the formula, it is very creamy and can be a little too much if you don't blot before application. It does dry a bit faster than some covergirl máscaras I'm used to so careful when applying more than one coat since I'm sure that was what caused some complaints on here with the flaking. I only apply one coat since I prefer the minimalist look and have absolutely no flaking. There is a bit of a learning curl as all mascaras have and it al depends on what you prefer. I've noticed this brand overall celebrates a more natural look (think of a more leveled up glossier with a bit of coverage) so less is always more when it comes to application. If you're the type that likes to apply coat after coat, this may not be for you.
Decent Mascara 3
Ant B from TX
It adds great volume, however, it doesn't hold a curl. It's worth purchasing on sale.
Another empty promise! 1
Micki from Jackson,MS
I am looking for a great mascara that doesn't clump, flake, smear ,looks natural but better. The 1st try of this mascara I thought it was great. The 2nd use I noticed large clumps. The 3rd try was worse, clumps, smears, tarantula lashes!!! I am frustrated, you can't fix lashes that are plastered together when you don't have time to redo your makeup!! I don't know what to believe .I've thrown out 20 mascaras in the last 2 years ,I really don't know what to buy. I need volume, length and absolutely no clumps, smears or smudging. HELP!
Would be a great mascara if it didn't transfer... 2
Jes from Chicago, IL
I loved this mascara the moment I applied it. It's very lengthening and volumizing, as indicated. Unfortunately, less than 2 hours after application, I have mascara transferred and flaked below my eyes. Granted, I have bad allergies and my eyes do tend to water, but I wonder if this formula never fully dries down. On the flip side, it does wash off very easily. I will stick with my other brands that I know won't transfer.
Raccoon Eyes 1
Trixie from Atlanta
I have short, straight lashes and was excited to try this new formula. I purchased the smaller size as a trial. I loved the application and how my lashes looked! Unfortunately, several hours later I found I had raccoon eyes. Sadly, I just am not impressed.
Love It 5
Tinajoi from Ohio
Everything is great about it
Works As Well As Some High End Mascaras 5
Jann from St Louis
I got this mascara in the mini size to try out. I LOVE it! It gives my non-existent lashes life! I get volume, length and definition. Funny, but I didn't notice the fragrance so it must not be overwhelming. This is definitely as good as Better Than Sex mascara and BTS has always been my go-to. I will be buying the regular size very soon.
Glides 5
Audrey from Austin
I use this almost daily. Glides on so smoothly.
Great Length 5
Chrissy from NJ
Longlasting, doesn't flakes, and gives great length, it's comparable to too faced BTS mascara, I enjoyed the scent, if you like Fenty scented powders/products you'll probably enjoy this scent.
new favorite mascara!!!! 5
lauren from virginia, usa
i bought the smaller one but im definitely going to purchase the bigger size when i use up my current one!! it makes your lashes look soo long and voluminous and it actually LASTS all day! also one of my favorite parts about this mascara is it doesn't smudge during the day! i LOVE supporting black owned businesses and i especially LOVE it when their products come out on top!! what a wonderful product and company!
not drying at all 5
booberries from Arizona
I love how easily I was able to apply. Usually mascara is very drying to me, but this one really felt nourishing. This was my first time buying a mascara that isn't a drug store brand so I'm glad I splurged on this one. I really hope they add a brown soon.
Added fragrance 1
Tiny_Athena from TX
I really wanted to support this brand! The formula is ok. It feels thick but lashes look dramatic so I would say that it does what it claims. However there is added fragrance, which I did not realize when I purchased. The scent isn't bad - but fragrance does not belong in cosmetics. It's irritating. I will have to return this unfortunately.
Great 4
SSmith from Chicago
Like it! Not messy but coats lashes- curl and volume.
Strong Scent! 2
Breeze from Charleston SC
Why did have to be perfume on my eyes. I could smell all day and gave me a headache. Will have to return this one.
New fav 💕 5
NML from Houston, TX
I really love this mascara! I have tiny, curly lashes and this mascara really helped to separate and elongate my lashes.
good for lower lashes 3
a.c from illinois
didnt notice a difference with my upper lashes but definitely noticed lengthening on lower lashes. has stronf sent as well
Don't waste your money 1
Titi from Marlton
I wanted to try this mascara because of the description but all it did was clump and didn't do anything like volume or length
