Rated 4.27 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Excellent!
I adore this Estee Lauder eyeliner...I have several colors and they never fail me...I had gotten away from make up for awhile, too much of a bother since I retired....but went back to it when I took a parttime job and I found these eyeliners and love them....I had said I would never wear eyeliner again, but Estee Lauder changed my mind...I am 68 years old and I can apply this with no trouble whatsoever, goes on well, stays all day and until I take it off and gives me the classic look I want. Will buy others...just keep them coming! Thank you for this excellent product!
Most Helpful Critical Review Not for some
Great pigmentation, rich black color. Unfortunately, smudged and smeared all over my lower lid. Sometimes I can get less smudging to occur if I add lots of powder to my base, but not worth the money in comparison to other brands. If you have dry eyelids, you probably will have much better results. Color keeps rich where I do apply, and stays all day ( just tends to bleed...)
Reviewed by 51 customers Best eyeliner
Jo from Nebraska
This is the best eyeliner I have found. Doesn't smudge and the color doesn't fade. I have had women ask me what eyeliner I use.
Use it a few years
Ann from MA
I have been using this pencil a few years . I like it.
MELLY from Nashville, TN
Smudges off and transfers. I can't have weird raccoon eyeliner at the office. Does not Stay-in-Place and there are way better eyeliners out there at this price point.
My favorite pencil ever
Jean from FL
First I got this in a gift set. Lost it as I was helping people with their makeup for my friends wedding. Was so upset no one returned it. Had to buy another one, glides on like butter
Fades and smudges within 3 hours
Jen from Dallas, Texas
Giving this a 2 for ease of use but it was NOT long wear on my skin at all. I tried it several times (both on top of foundation and on clean skin, with and without primer, with and without setting spray) and every time, it faded, smudged or transferred within 3 hours. I've gotten better results with drug-store brands. Very disappointed.
Crystal C from Grand Rapids, MI
I really need a stay in place, no transfer eye liner and unfortunately this one did not live up to its name. Worked no better for me than less expensive brands. Also very little product for the price.
I buy this again and again.
Busy Mom from Chicago
Smooth, long lasting, rich color. Perfect.
Minker from Milltown nj
Used it for a couple of years. Love it. I had an account with ulta but it wouldn't let me in. Called n I was told I don't did have an account but had to buy new products as a guest. Lost my rewards! Is there a problem with the website? I even had my account # and couldn't get in
Love this product
Danie from Maryland
Used it for years
This Eye Pencil smudges just like the rest!
Lacy from Summerville, SC
Will not will be purchasing again.
Mizz Tam from Cleveland, Ohio
My normal, everyday eyeliner is L'oreal's Extra Intense Liquid Pencil Eyeliner, and this is the department store equivalent. I was originally hesitant to try this eyeliner because of the price but decided to give it a try when it was on sale. I'm glad that I did! It is now officially my backup to L'oreal. The one thing I will say about this eyeliner is that it sharpens BETTER and SMOOTHER than L'oreal's.
Andrea R. from Richmond, VA
This is now my holy grail eyeliner. Has a cool rubber smudger! Love it!
GKR from TX
I used to used Urban Decay's eyeliner, so that was what I was comparing this product to. Hands down,
Estee Lauder's eyeliner is better. It goes on easy, but isn't so soft that you're constantly having to sharpen it. Also, it doesn't run or smudge. Bonus: I haven't had to do the "wipe under the eye" move since I started using this. Bottom line: this is now my go-to eyeliner.
Best Every Day Eye Liner
mzmom from Rochester Hills, MI
I have tried many eye liners and always come back to this one! It glides on smoothly, stays in place, doesn't run and is perfect every day for my hazel eyes. I often have problems with my eye liner smearing throughout the course of the day and this one never does. It's my go to!
rockyroad from OH
I have it in the "coffee" color and it is pretty easy to apply and lasts all day. Only con is I can't sharpen it to a fine point.
Tree from AZ
Bought on sale to try. Don't recommend for tightlining unless you like bottom waterline transfer. Pretty good eyeliner on sale.
Pippa from Lexington, Ky
Creamy, smooth application. Easy application.
Heatha03109 from Manchester NH
I was hoping for something that would last longer on my water line. This is not it! But it glides on easy, good color. Nice quality.
Love this pencil
Esteelauderfreak from Orlando, FL
Nothing bad to say about this eyeliner. Best long lasting pencil I have tried.
would buy again!
lac from York, pa
I have very oily skin and have trouble w/ liners bleeding, but this liner lives up to its claims! I've tried a lot of high end liners, but this one is great. plus I really like the color I choose for my blue eyes. burgundy suede
I would buy again and again
Tere from Walnut, ca
My eyes look great
Does what it says! Stay in place!
Cc from Durham, NC
I use this an an in liner. Wear it every day and it stays all day!
love this eye liner
eyeliner from Lake Jackson TX
I use it for everyday use
Color + application ease
Karen from Birmingham, Al
Good eyeliner for night and day
Estée Lauder eye pencil
Mona from Plainsboro, NJ
I use it on a daily basis. While this eye pencil is easy to glide, but it tends to run and fade after sometime. Still better than most eyeliners that I have used in the past.