Product Reviews Rated 4.52 out of 5 stars
52 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review New favorite eyeliner! Urban Decay 24/7 was my favorite eyeliner, until now....this pencil caught my eye and I thought I'd give it a whirl, boy am I glad I did. I liked the UD eyeliner, but hated having to sharpen it so often, it felt like I was wasting so much product. I saw this on at my recent trip to Ulta, the first thing that grabbed my attention was it looked like a regular pencil but was a twist up requiring no sharpening, immediately I was intrigued. I tested it on my hand and fell in love with how it glided on and how precise it was, that sealed the deal and now I have found my new favorite! The only drawback, (but its so minor it doesn't really matter), is you can't tell how much of it is used, so I will have to buy another to have on hand so I don't run out. Hands down, an AMAZING eyeliner!
Most Helpful Critical Review If you don't wear contacts and tightline, it's good. Good dark and creamy pigment that does actually seem to last without smudging or fading on my apparently oily eyes. I'm also thrilled to have a brown vegan eyeliner, when I was looking they were surprisingly difficult to come by.
Unfortunately I can't use it when wearing contacts, because it drops pigment chunks into my eyes and it's super irritating. You can feel that you have stuff in your eye but trying to take it out just smears it onto the contact lens— my husband is constantly pointing out that my eyes look like they have dirt in them.
The bits that drop aren't nearly as irritating with just glasses, but typically if I'm wearing glasses I probably won't be putting on makeup. I also only tightline in the top lashes and throw on some mascara, so maybe someone who likes a thick eyeliner line above the lashes won't have the same problem.
Reviewed by 52 customers Love this liner! 5
Lauren from Pennsylvania
I love this eyeliner! I was looking for a liner that doesn't run and come off after two hours of putting it on. This definitely stays put and the color is very intense which I love. Love that it is vegan and cruelty free! Will definitely be buying this again.
My NEW favorite eyeliner! 5
Sandy from Pennsylvania
I've used Mally Lucky Penny eyeliner for years and all of a sudden it's discontinued...I've tried many eyeliners to replace that one and this one is the closest - even better in color and texture! I've found my new daily eyeliner - gorgeous deep bronze color...perfect for my blue eyes!
Burns eyes severely 1
Esty from Pueblo Co
As soon as I put this eyeliner on my waterline 5 seconds later my eyes are burning extremely badly and watery and red I don't like it at all 😞
If you don't wear contacts and tightline, it's good. 3
Sky from Bay Area, CA
Good dark and creamy pigment that does actually seem to last without smudging or fading on my apparently oily eyes. I'm also thrilled to have a brown vegan eyeliner, when I was looking they were surprisingly difficult to come by.
Unfortunately I can't use it when wearing contacts, because it drops pigment chunks into my eyes and it's super irritating. You can feel that you have stuff in your eye but trying to take it out just smears it onto the contact lens— my husband is constantly pointing out that my eyes look like they have dirt in them.
The bits that drop aren't nearly as irritating with just glasses, but typically if I'm wearing glasses I probably won't be putting on makeup. I also only tightline in the top lashes and throw on some mascara, so maybe someone who likes a thick eyeliner line above the lashes won't have the same problem.
Great eyeliner 5
maui from SD
I used to use the Mally eyeliner in Lucky Penny but it was discontinued. For me above all, it is the color I was looking for and the bronze fit the bill. it is self-sharpening which I love and lasts and doesn't transfer.I have already repurchased.
Sadly, not what I was hoping for... 2
MCT from Louisiana
I had high hopes after reading the reviews, but sadly it is not what I expected! The line goes on super think and it's messy. It kept getting on the bottom while I was doing the top line, it also makes my eyes burn a little and my contacts blurry even though I don't get it on my contacts. I've had this happen with another smooth and creamy eyeliner before, it was rubbing onto my contacts from my eye lid. The tip is really soft and kept breaking despite being extra gentle. I ended up having to remove my eye makeup and start all over then use my old liner. I even had to replace the pair of contacts I was using. Disappointed since it is the beautiful dark black I was looking for, also bc I feel that I wasted my money on this product.
Great product 5
Crystal from NC
Been using about 3 months now. I have eye sensitivity and this product doesn't cause any problems. My eyes do not water with this liner.
Bronze 5
gagirl from Georgia
It glides on easily and stays put. The bronze has a unique golden shift that I haven't been able to find in any other eyeliner. Please do not discontinue this one!
Stays put on water line!! 4
Mollie from Illinois
This is the only eyeliner I have found that stays put on my waterline all day! It's also super black. My only con which isn't a huge deal is it is harder to remove. I always feel like I scrub enough but end up with raccoon eyes still after my shower. Just make sure you scrub a little extra and you should be happy with your purchase:)
Waterproof 4
Emk from Wi
I like it but wish the crayon was sharper
Easy on my eyes and the color is beautiful. 5
T from Idaho
Loved the color choses with the tart brand. The eye liner color made my blue eyes standout.
great stocking stuffer 5
Greatgranny from colorado springs, Colorado
I bought for my daughter who prefers pencil over liquid. I dont know if she will like it, but it is a great stocking stuffer.
Love the color and texture 5
Runner girl from Brownsville, Texas
I use this as my day to evening liner. I love how smooth and easily it glides on. The liner stays on too.
I Love It!!!!! 5
Laura from New Jersey
This eyeliner goes on so easy, it just glides. Great for the upper and lower lid, colors are beautiful and I am definitely a big Tarte fan. I have this liner in several colors.
Stays where put!! 5
Makeup Diva from North Carolina
I have tried a lot of different liners, love this one! Stays where it is put.
I would buy this eyeliner over and over 5
Lisa80128 from Colorado
I ❤️ the burgundy color, great staying power. I have bought this eyeliner a couple of times.
Perfect 5
Sandy from Michign
I love this eyeliner. It goes on smooth and lasts all day. I can do a thin soft line for a natural look or draw dramatic cat eye.
Great for water line! 5
Lisa from Pennsylvania
I like to wear liner on my waterline and usually Tarte's Sex kitten clay liner was the only one that seemed to work. After I wasn't able to find any in stock at the store, the rep recommended me this. After several hours of wearing this liner it stayed put! I'm so happy I took her word for it and gave this a try. I will definitely be purchasing this again!
THIS IS BOMB 5
jdlf from Aurora, IL
This is only eyeliner that stays in place, I usually have problems with it wearing off on the corners of my eyes. Thank you tarte
Love the color! 5
Nat from Chicago
Easy application and the color is great! Comes off easily with eye make up remover
Smokey Bronze 5
MUYvette from Orange County, CA
Love this eyeliner. It is highly pigmented, easy to blend or apply in a sharp line. Doesn't smudge. I like to apply if over a liquid liner to soften the line and give a smoky effect. This color is very complimentary to all eye color.
love it 5
me007 from indio
my new favorite eyeliner love it it Glides on smooth stays on of course using eye primer. I definitely recommend
love it! 5
me007 from Indio
I got this pencil on sale I was hesitant to buy but I am so glad I did it's amazing Glides on nicely and dust a on of course with eye primer. I definitely recommend
New favorite 5
Shanna from Omaha, NE
My new favorite and go to eyeliner. Glides on really smooth.
Best eyeliner ever! Stays put and does not fade. 5
Shelly from Texas
It is the perfect eyeliner, especially if you have watery eyes. It does not come off and stays put for hours.
