Rated 4.51 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Love it
First off, just superficially, the color they chose for this flavor is beautiful. Second, the cucumber smells so refreshing!! Definitely not an ordinary lip balm scent but so so unique. The mint adds the nice tingle that I love from the original. I think this is the perfect lip balm to help me look forward to spring, with the cucumber, but the mint lets me still feel a little wintery. New favorite! I would love to see other creative flavors like this.
Most Helpful Critical Review Creamy but it's ok
Disclaimer: I received this product for free.
This eyeliner is definitely creamy. I got the 1455 Sapphire. The colour is very pretty, but it really deserves a 2 because it smudges quite bad, without water or any makeup remover. It takes a long time to dry. I give it a 3 for the colour. It really makes a difference from the typical black eyeliner.
Reviewed by 313 customers My New "Go To" eyeliner!
LyndaK from Southern Minnesota
Switched from the usual eyeliners you find at most stores. I use eyeliner everyday for both casual wear and during performances. Burt's Bees has become my new favorite, especially the Onyx. I can go lightly with it and have a casual defined look, or I can go heavier with it for that more dramatic performance look. It goes on easily and doesn't break when pressure is applied like some of the cheaper brands. It does not irritate my skin either! It also removes easily with the Burt's Bees make up remover pads. I also do not have any trouble with smudging, then again, I don't touch or rub my eyes during the day as nobody should these days! My only wish was that it was easier to find and pick up in stores that I normally go to.
Pretty color but doesn't last
disappearing eyes from Wisconsin
Love clean make-up. Wanted to love this. Nice color but doesn't stay on at all. Very sad!
Obsessed with Gilded Sage color
WILDEGURL from California
I absolutely LOVE this color! I have greenish hazel eyes and this color is perfect... brings out the green and gives my eyes a twinkling look. It gives a "smudge" look, not a defined line.
The bad news: it needs to be waterproof, needs frequent touch up. Initially, it did not want to go on my skin, but after a couple of times, it went on smooth.
Not Irritation but Not Long Lasting
Bella from New York
I used this on my waterline and I was surprised that it didn't irritate my sensitive eyes. But it also rubbed away after five minutes so.....definitely not worth the price tag.
It's not for me
Ann2 from Plano
I purchased this mascara after I decided to go with a more all natural make up brand. I love Burt's Bees lip products and decided to try the eye makeup. The eye liner is overall ok. I found it a little difficult to go on. But, I'm used to a liquid liner and maybe that's the issue. I didn't care for how it looked on. I went back to Maybelline.
So Moisturizing and Smells Amazing
rsdhytgj from undisclosed
I needed a chapstick for during the day (I use a lip mask at night). This smells incredibly good and goes on so smooth. It doesn't feel greasy or heavy and it stays on my lips all day.
Wasn't what i was expecting
Amy1999 from California, LA
When i got it i was so exited, when i tried it it was very hard to put on and it was very thick, also it irritated my eye's a lot.
Danielle207 from Portland, ME
This eyeliner drags against the skin and doesn't leave color evenly. It pulls and is very waxy. It also started to melt a little two hours in. I would not buy this one again.
Not like the original beeswax
Alex Rosenblatt from St. Louis, MO
The cucumber mint is pretty strong in it flavor. I was expecting a light refreshing feel when I put it on based on the reviews, but it was not like that. The chapstick is very fruity and doesn't have hardly any mint in it. I was expecting the same feeling as the original beeswax, that cooling peppermint feel. The chapstick does go on smooth, however the taste is pretty strong.
Love this eyeliner. Blue shade is a bonus!
Fatgreencat from Macon, Georgia
I have tried many different eyeliners, seeking one that glides easily on inside lid and that lasts but that doesn't irritate my eyes. Keep finding ones that fail in one or more of those qualities. This eyeliner satisfies all those needs. I can wear it all day at work. It fades slowly. Just bought a second shade and ready to try a third.
BEST LIP BALM EVER
Chaunnie from Atlanta
Smells perfect and so fresh. I love it and will continue to purchase. The application is also sooo smooth and nice.
My Favorite (:
Paigeeee from Los Angeles, California
Wow, I really love this lip balm. When I bought it, I was really surprised. I wasn't expecting it to be exactly how they explain it. Minty, but perfect. It is very refreshing and is overall my favorite lip balm from Burt's Bees so far. I don't regret buying this. Giving it a solid 5.
Just wish it was waterproof
Curly21 from Kansas
It's a little hard to put on at first, especially if you're a waterline kinda person like I am. It doesn't burn your eyes like most other brands I've tried, and that makes me happy, I just wish it was waterproof or smudge proof... otherwise one accidental swipe during allergy season and you look like you've been punched in the eye.
Really comfortable and long lasting
Qing from Columbia SC
It glides so smoothly and doesn't break. It lasts pretty long for me. It doesn't bother my eyes.
Nice color smooth glide
Ginabeana1980 from Alexandria, Va
I like retractable liners for some reason better than liquid liners. It's a pretty color, glides on smoothly, doesn't smudge. It's a great product. I would like to see more colors and variety from burts bees
D in Texas from Fort Worth
I tried the Defining Retractable Eyeliner by Burt's Bees. I felt like it went on very smooth and creamy. It had great color payout and lasted all day! I likes that I didn't need to have a sharpener on hand and the amount of product for the price was also a bonus!!
Creamy, Easy To Use
Red19 from Pennsylvania
I got this eyeliner in the brown quartz shade, which is a nice deep brown. I was excited to see that this product comes in a good variety of colors! I hope to try out some of the other shades. I don't use eyeliner very often, so I have only worn this one a handful of times, but it is super easy to use. It is creamy and glides on easily. Its durability is decent, but I don't know how it would hold up wearing it all day. All in all, I am quite pleased with the eyeliner and would definitely buy it again!
AmandaJ22 from Bradford, PA
Formula glides on smooth. Easy application. I accidentally got a bit in my eye while multitasking & winced, waiting for the watery eye but it didn't irritate my eye at all! I can't wait to purchase it in black but the brown looks great. I use it to create my natural makeup look.
Lizet7 from Passaic, NJ, USA
I like the fact that the eyeliner is skinny giving me freedom to do either a tight line mark or a thicker dramatic line. I also like it continues to be made good ingredients. I would love to gift this eyeliner to a friend when I get a chance.
Stays and slays
ADDragalzew123 from Fort Worth, TX
I love this eye liner! The color was perfect for my green eyes. I put it on in the morning and it stayed all day. Also this product went on super smooth and did not cause irritation to my eyes like most eyeliners do.
Kirichap from Concord, NH
This is a fantastic product. Everything about it is is absolutely perfect!
It feels so smooth and and light on my skin, but give just the right amount of eyeliner as I apply. My eyeliner looks so gorgeous and smooth!
It has a beautiful texture, not stiff or artificial.
This product is excellent! I will never use anything else!
EdithV0903 from Garland, Tx
I loves using this Eyeliner.! It went on so smoothly and stayed on too with out smudges around my eye, it didn't do what others do leaving me like a raccoon. Whatever formula is being used it works great for me.
Easy to apply
mom2boys51 from Wisconsin
I like how easily this product goes on. There is no tugging on my eyelid and the line looks smooth. I have both this color and the green color. I prefer the purple because it shows up easier without multiple applications. Overall, this is one of my favorite eyeliners!
Goes on smoothly
mom2boys51 from Wisconsin
I like how easily this product goes on. There is no tugging on my eyelid and the line looks smooth. The only thing I would change is for the color to be a bit darker. I feel like I have to trace the line several times before it shows very well. I still use this daily because I love it, I just have to apply it a couple times to make the line darker.
Great addition to my wife's collection
DudeThatUsesBurts from Minnesota, USA
This is a great addition to my wife's collection. She said she loved it and it worked really well. It went on smoothly and she loved the color! Plus Burts is a great brand with a great reputation so we know it is legit!