Product Reviews Rated 4.26 out of 5 stars
785 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review They discontinued my favorite mascara of 12+ years This is literally the ONLY mascara I have used daily since finding it in 2005. I have worked as both a MUA and a beauty blogger, tried TONS of drugstore and high-end mascaras, and this is the only one that has ever worked for me. Now it appears its gone :( NO, the non-waterproof version is NOT the same. This mascara had a magical way of separate every lash, and maintaining a great CURL on my stick-straight, lack-lustre lashes. No smudging or flaking ever, and I am a contact-lense wearer with allergies! Nothing else will compare to this, PLEASE bring it back Maybelline! Never understood why it wasn't one of their more popular mascaras, so I guess this is what we get, it goes away...
Most Helpful Critical Review TERRRIBLE I use the water proof pink bottle and black top. Love it!!!
I went to purchase again and saw a whole wall full of new mascaras. It's crazy to have too many choices. I spent 20 minutes and this was the closest I could find to what I have been using and it is TERRIBLE!!! You can't even get the mascara to go on the lashes because the brush is like a spring. It's weird and I will not be buying again. Why fix something if it's not broken. Very disappointed!
Reviewed by 785 customers awesome for cool girl looks 5
indianajones from Crystal Skulls
separates lashes and tints them dark. no flakes!!!
Decent for price. 4
Heather from Pittsburgh
Works well as a cheaper alternative to fancier brands.
I've bought this product over and over. 4
A.M. from Morgantown , WV
I've bought this product many times. First of all the price is right! It goes on nice and looks very natural. I do have to do two or three applications to make it stand out more, but I don't mind that for the price. It lasts most of the day, needs reapplied in evening.
Beautiful long lashes! 5
Brianna from Florida
I love this! It's a separating and lengthening mascara that doesn't clump up! You might not like this is you prefer thick "clumpy" lashes.
Holy grail mascara for 10 years! 5
Tnk818 from Ohio
I've been using this mascara for about 10 years now (basically since I started using the stuff)!! I've wandered and tried about 10-15 other mascaras, both high end and drugstore. I ALWAYS come back to this and NOTHING else compares. It's jusy the perfect mix of easy to apply, no irritation, crazy length, good volume, extreme lift, long lasting, no smudging, and easy to remove. The wand is key. It really allows you to comb through the lashes and evenly apply the product. I have a friend who has been hooked on it for about 7 years now and another 2 friends who have just recently tried it and are also in love. I hope this mascara stays around forever!!!
define a lash maybelline 5
Trish from Utah
please do not discontinue this product it is better then high end mascara by far. I'm hearing rumors it could be so please reconsider not to take this one away from us, it doesn't clump it lifts lashes like crazy and it separates and does give good volume. I wanted to try the define a lash volume to see if there was any difference but its really hard to find. I love this product and I hope it stays on the market for life it is amazing! it's been difficult finding a really good mascara.
Favorite Mascara 5
Bacon does makeup from Alabama
This is my favorite mascara out of all the ones I've tried over the years (Dior, Tarte, Lancome, Benefit). It's cheaper and better than the luxury brands. I like trying new things but I always end up coming back to this mascara. It starts off being very thin and liquid-y so I apply one coat and then another once that one dries. The brush helps "comb" and separate my lashes.
I'd buy this again 5
Mz. Evie from Concord, Ca
I've been on a mission to find the best mascara. The one that can fan out my lashes and make them longer. I have tried several expensive mascaras and always end up with dark shade under my bottom lashes. I started using this mascara about a week ago. I did get a little smudgeness, but not like others which is why I gave it a 5. I recently paired this with Estee Lauder's Double Wear Mascara and no smudging under the eyes. I finally found my mascara!
Favorite mascara 5
Tash from Philadelphia, PA
I have tried the Too faced better than sex mascara which clumps up my eyelashes, I tried the Lancome which is nice but this is my favorite mascara hands down. After I use this mascara, it looks like I have false eyelashes on. Love this product!
Takes some getting used to 4
Marie from Corpus Christi, TX
I have been using this mascara for a year now and I'm happy to say I like it a lot. I gave it 4 stars because no product is perfect.
Cons:
-Needs to dry a bit in order to work
-Flakes if touched to much
-Clumps up eyelashes (in the beginning)
Pros:
pros:
-Lengthens lashes
-Long wearing (if not touched a lot)
I personally like the mascara despite it's flaws, it just depends if you're willing to work with it.
Best mascara on the market hands down 5
Maria from Denver, CO
I briefly read through a few other reviews before writing this and am happy to say that I've had the same experience as many others. I've worn this for years, at least a decade, and it consistently beats out both other drugstore and extremely expensive mascaras. I do have longer than normal lashes, but people ask what kind of mascara I use all the time. I think it has to do with the rubber wand. It might take some getting used to, but it just works so well for me. I'm normally not a review person, but I'm such a believer in this mascara. If you're debating it, do it!
Better than every expensive brand out there! 5
Angie from New York
Over the past 40 years I've tried every mascara out there including all the super expensive brands. This product is by far the best! Don't be fooled by a fancy price. The waterproof version tends to clump so stuck to the straight up.
Great Mascara 5
Alice from Florida
This is very good mascara, it lengthens and separates your lashes, it doesn't clump, I have tried many , including the expensive ones, I recently tried the It roller mascara, and returned it, this one is by far better that the It Roller lash mascara. Define-A-Lash Lengthening Mascara does not flake, the brush is very nice and it does keep the lash separated!
Define a lash mascara 5
Hunt for good mascara from Utah
This is an awesome mascara it lengthens better than any other drug store mascara I have used. It is all about lengthening not volume so what I did was put this on first one coat is all it took to get my desired length then I separate any lashes they may stick together a little, then I take Maybelline's illegal lengths fiber mascara and apply that for volume and a little more length too it's way awesome if you want to create longer looking voluminous lashes. You gotta try this combo it looked like I had lash extensions and not spider eyes. My lashes were not hard either they were just right.
Define a lash by Maybelline 5
Shop girl from Utah
This is definitely a 5 star mascara it lengthens very well it really pulls your lashes up and separates them. It is more for length not volume, so a trick I tried is I put this on to lengthen and then I use maybelline the rocket mascara for volume and it really volumizes very well! And if you feel it messed with any length add a little more define a lash mascara lightly on the tips and boom there ya go! Length and volume and no clumps. Use L'Oréal primer mascara first too and it makes a lot of difference and go light with all the applications to avoid clumping and I like to use my eyelash comb for any lashes that may stick together.
My favorite 5
Jayne from Tucson
Great for fast application with no clumps
Great for getting a clumpy look 1
Frustrated with Bad Mascaras from Oklahoma
Any lengthening this product does, which is minimal, is ruined by the amount of clumps it causes. I've tried this multiple times but can't seem to apply it without my lashes being clumped together while still looking incredibly short. I will be buying a different product next time I go to the store.
My Favorite! Never clumps, only lengthens. 5
wccmarathon from Olympia, WA
Great mascara for a great price. It is better than the expensive mascara's that I have tried because it never clumps up and lengthens lashes perfectly.
Been using this mascara for years! 5
northern belle from Huntsville, AL
I have been using this mascara for years and am not thinking of changing anytime soon! Helps lengthen my lashes. Doesn't feel heavy, thick, or clumpy. Definitely prefer this one over the waterproof version, which feels sticky to me.
Great Length 5
Alyssa from Corpus Christi,TX
I like the mascara. I was on the hunt for a new one since my old Ulta brand one was discontinued and I like it so far. I was sceptical of the rubber wand but it actually works pretty well. It does not flake like my previous one, I rub my eyes a lot. Doesn't come off when I get teary eyed. Easy application and great results!
One of my GO 2's 5
Kayy from Ny
I love this mascara... this gives great length AND volume without clumping... the brush design allows you to reallyyyy get every lash and to go over multiple times... this one and Too faced "better than sex" are two of my top 5...
My fav mabbeline!! 5
Tiki from Norcal
I've been using mabbeline for 40 years and this is best one yet...one coat usually does the trick
Looooooovvveeee ittttt 5
mia from US
I've been using this mascara for over 2 years. It costs my natural lashes and makes them look long and defined (like the name's legit). I love it for everyday, it separates and just makes my lashes look fluttery. (but if you are looking for more volume or like more clumsiness, not the way to go :)).
Tried this on a whim... 4
michellepropstbennet from undisclosed
Tried this on a whim and was surprised at how well it works. Doesn't clump and definitely makes me lashes look longer and more defined. Love that it is waterproof so no smearing or raccoon eyes when working out or playing in the snow.
Tried this on a whim and was surprised at how well 4
michellepropstbennet from undisclosed
Tried this on a whim and was surprised at how well it works. Doesn't clump and definitely makes me lashes look longer and more defined. Love that it is waterproof so no smearing or raccoon eyes when working out or playing in the snow.
