Product Reviews Rated 3.88 out of 5 stars
41 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Love these! I particularly love sparkle and shine, and these guys did not disappoint. I was seeking a wet glitter type of product to top the eyeshadow I place on my inner half of the lids, when I heard Mac was about to release this product. So far, I've used Diamond Crumbles and Blinking Brilliant and I have been very happy with the results. I enjoy these wet eye shadows because they apply quickly, so it's how I achieve a sparkly eye look in a short period of time. They glide on easily and stay put for hours. I applied my current look twelve hours ago and it is still intact and just as beautiful as it was when I applied it! I enjoy them as much as their Stila counterparts, but mostly enjoy their variance in colors/textures within the two brands. Each brand offers a selection different enough from each other, that I have a wide selection from both! I always get lots of compliments with these Mac liquid eyeshadows, the sparkle is eye catching and fabulous. Love love love them.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not very good at all This has no pigment. It is basically expensive body glitter. I used this over eyeshadow color as well as alone. Yet again a disappointment. It removed the eyeshadow from underneath. Smearing my look and causing me to start all over again. I love a lot of Mac products just not this one. I have been using Mac for over 20 years. To me it was an epic fail. I am sticking with stila. To me this doesn't have the quality that Mac products are known for. I really wanted to love this but it was a huge let down.
Reviewed by 41 customers Disappointed 2
Kailey from Long Island
For the price and how this performs it is not worth it. Wanted to love this, but it removed whatever eyeshadow I had underneath and was too shear without a base. Will stick to my stilla glitter and glows
Patchy and shear 2
Jojo from Los Angeles
I love the color Everyday Is Sunshine because it's a lovely nude for my fair skin. However I have tried this shadow so many times and so many ways and it always looks patchy. It doesn't spread evenly on the lid, it likes to stick to itself and get gloopy in some places while disappearing in other places. It works ok if just tapped on the lid as a topper over another shadow but even then I have drugstore liquid shadows that work better.
Way too Glittery 1
KayJay from Ashburn, VA
Thought I was ordering an everyday neutral shade and it's is very glittery and no color at all.
Ove the spark 4
Sehrah from Rex GA
It looks good but doesn't last long
Sparkling Eyes 5
SetteSells from NJ
Goes on easy and stays all day. Bright and vibrant. Easy daily application for low maintenances makeup. One of my favorite makeup products
Flakes and fades 1
CarriD from Hiram, GA
Flakes and faded before i even finished my make up
Not good 1
CarriD from Hiram, GA
I'm going to send this back. It flakes off and the color faded before I even got done with the rest of my makeup
Happy to find 5
Yma975 from Rochester, MI
Bought two colors and love them both (rose metallic and silver metallic). So easy to use.
Best ones yet! 5
Nar from Florida
These are the best liquid shadows I've tried! I wish they came out with more colors. I do prefer the more glittery ones over metallic ones too. They last long and there's never any fall out! Love love love. Hope they never get rid of these!
Well hello! 5
Sacri from Pooler GA
This gave my eyes the POP I was looking for. I'm not the best at applying make-up so this did take me a few tries to get right but once I did it made a striking difference to my look. I tend to wear very neutral make up so I wanted to add to my look but nothing that would over-power or look like I completely changed my face. This was able to do exactly that! I received compliments without people being able to tell exactly what I had done differently. LOVE
Empty 3
Empty from SC
I accidentally bought love yourself and exchanged it for beam time. The love yourself bottle did not look half empty but when I exchanged it for beam time that bottle is half empty. See attached picture, this is straight out of the box!I don't want to go through the trouble of exchanging it again so I will keep it. But disappointed with the third purchase in a row from Mac.
Disappointed:( 3
Beautybelle from NY
I instantly fell in love with the colors however,the bottles were half empty and there was too little product to justify the price. Sadly will return.
This stuff is amazing! 5
Chelseapug from Sciotoville, OH
I use it as a shadow and a liner.
Love these 5
LA929 from Raleigh, NC
Very pigmented and a great choice for those of us with hooded eyes.
LOVE 5
shelby from new york
I get many compliments EVERY TIME I wear!
Upgrade 5
Nina from Israel
I love this product, i bought it in two colors and really feel it upgrades eyeshadow. I thought I'd wear it for special occasions but honestly, i can't help but wear it all the time!!
Needs improvement! 2
Mia Kitty from Marana , AZ
The only positive is the color ...I got blinking brilliant.....It is not pigmented enough at all! A total disappointment. I even tried using it over an eyeshadow....it didn't help..it just seems like its all glitter and no color. I would not recommend this and I love Mac...this was an epic fail. I suggest swatching on your hand in person to see if it works for you.
Bottles half empty 1
Iuliia from Bradenton
I bought this eyeshadow online in color Everyday is sunshine. When I received product it was obviously half empty. I exchanged it at MAC store to different in color Love yourself. Product seems to be ok. But after several weeks after it looks like it just flows down in the bottle. And it's half empty too! I didn't use it so often to be such empty.
It's so disappointing. Especially from MAC and for such price.
Dazzling 5
Jess from Portland
This
Product is amazing!!
Just Okay! 3
chatwoman from Houston
It did not sparkle like I expected.
Just two flaws 4
Amrena from Savannah, Georgia
Firstly, I love this color, I wear it everywhere. I feel a slight cooling effect when I put it in my lids or my cheeks and the color doesn't disappoint, I feel that I'm the definition of an ethereal being! That being said, there's just two things that I think MAC needs to address when it comes to this product. I'm not a layer heavy person, I only put on 2 to make sure I can land an airplane. But the problem is that when I'm done putting it on, I already see a build up of glitter on my lids. Even when I do one layer, it's almost like the pigments or the glitter isn't small enough so that they could be undetectable, which is what I'd assume coming from a more high scale makeup venue. To add on to what I'm saying before, when the glitter builds up, you know, the glitter is almost a stark white color and when it's not in the sun it looks like you barely tried.
Also, I really wish this was formulated for hooded eye people. I don't have as much hood as some people do, but it's there and you notice creasing. I try to blend it out whenever I get the opportunity but so much of it comes off onto my fingertips that it's a little disappointing.
Maybe in later formulations they will get these two things right!
Love the sparkels 5
syd from Kansas
Easy application, lasts all day long and looks really nice over the regular eyeshadow to make it 💥pop!
Love love love! 5
Amanda from Lansing
I absolutely love this product! I have four different colors in this eyeshadow and I can not stay away from it! This color is perfect for going out. Will buy again for sure!
Not very good at all 1
Enhancing1 from NC
This has no pigment. It is basically expensive body glitter. I used this over eyeshadow color as well as alone. Yet again a disappointment. It removed the eyeshadow from underneath. Smearing my look and causing me to start all over again. I love a lot of Mac products just not this one. I have been using Mac for over 20 years. To me it was an epic fail. I am sticking with stila. To me this doesn't have the quality that Mac products are known for. I really wanted to love this but it was a huge let down.
Love it! 5
Vet student from Washington
I use this product for an everyday look, work, or you can dress it up for evening.
