Product Reviews Rated 4.69 out of 5 stars
54 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Pretty decent At first I wasn't very impressed by the quality but after giving it a few more chances, I really like it. A few shades (the two lightest) are less pigmented than others but they are all above average drugstore quality. I would also like to add these are very high quality especially when comparing them to other "natural/clean" cosmetics a the same price point. The mattes are creamy and smooth and remind me of the one of Becca's Ombre Nude 5 pan palettes. The darker shimmers are lovely and pigmented.
I think this palette is best suited for someone with minimal needs. (Like, not looking for a full instaglam look.) It is versatile day to night for a casual user.
Most Helpful Critical Review Disappointed I am not normally very picky with eyeshadows, but I cannot use this palette anymore. The fallout was dramatic, the light shades took three tries to even seem like they were on my eyelids at all, and anything darker than the base shades looked so muddy. It seems that most other people do not have these issues so I don't know if I got a weird one, but this is the first eye shadow palette I've ever just given up using.
Reviewed by 54 customers Great everyday palette (but don't drop it!) 5
Sue from Corvallis OR
I love this palette. Applies well, great everyday neutrals with some sparkly evening options, and it lasts. This is my second time purchasing this eye shadow—I dropped it the first time and the large palettes crumbled into powder, and I had to toss the whole thing. :(
a little hard to see pigments but amazing 4
Xitlalli from Oakland,CA
I have very sensitive eyes and I couldn't find a palette that didn't irritate my eyes but this palette did not irritate my eyes at all. It is a hypoallergenic palette which was super hard to find in other brands. The colors definitely come through after a while. Definitely will be buying the warm palette soon!!
easy to use - made me feel like a pro! 5
Katie from Philadelphia, PA
I don't normally wear eye shadow because I am terrible at applying it! This palette was easy to use, the simple suggestions on how and where on each part of eye were amazing - I feel like I know what I am doing! I love that I can add more color for a night time look.
Perfect Palette! 5
Kenzie from Los Angeles, CA
A combination of matte and shimmer, neutral and extra, I can literally use these colors for every occasion. I'm not one to go all out on my eyes but using these colors adds a little (or a lot) extra, while looking effortless. Never buying a different brand ever again.
Perfect for every day 5
Jill from Palm Springs, CA
I just tried the eye shadow for a zoom meeting - and was so happy with how it brightened my eyes. I just used one of the pale, neutral shades and it went on well and made my eyes look like a better version of natural me.
love this! 5
Tash from Texas
the Day-to-Night eye shadow is simply amazing, plus it will transition you from a daytime look to a sultry evening look. the high pigment eye shadows make application a breeze so you can have a dramatic look if needed without weighing your eyelid down with a lot of product. The staying power of this eyeshadow is pretty remarkable for a non-toxic brand too. Love the option to have a "no make up" makeup look or a sultry dramatic look all in one palette- perfect for traveling too!
Excellent quality 5
Kelly from Brownwood Texas
I love the quality for the price. You can't beat it. Pigment and texture are excellent
Excellent eye makeup palette 5
Ann from Apopka fl
I highly recommend the eyeshadow palette it great pigmentation long-wearing. I've never been able to order makeup offline I get the perfect match to my skin tone like I have PYT makeup
Great Natural Colors 5
Meeta from Sausalito
I love these colors. Great for day or night. Also, great to know that the product is all clean.
Great mix of colors 4
aed013 from Texas
Love this palette. So versatile with matte and shimmer shades.
Love this! 5
Holly S from undisclosed
Great eyeshadow. Great price and awesome customer service.
Love! 5
Cam W from Corte Madera, CA
This eyeshadow is amazing! The colors really pop and it lasts so long.
Good complimentary palette 4
Jordan from undisclosed
I got this palette because I LOVED the dark gold color and light shimmery pink. I definitely use those as the most dominant colors in my looks but love the other colors as compliments to other palettes that I own. It definitely is long-lasting though, which is crucial for any look.
Everyday Palette 5
Lucy from Ia
Great everyday palette. Quick easy looks for work are a breeze. I do usually bring in my bronzer to deepen it slightly but that doesn't bother me. The shimmers are nice and the darkest shade is great for a subtle eyeliner. Absolutely love the packaging and the layout of the shades. Highly recommend and can't wait to try the new warmer palette as well!
No pigment 2
Lala from Houston, TX
I really wanted to like this! The colors were perfect but the color payout was terrible. I have fair skin and the colors didn't show well on my skin.
Disappointed 1
Brittany from undisclosed
I am not normally very picky with eyeshadows, but I cannot use this palette anymore. The fallout was dramatic, the light shades took three tries to even seem like they were on my eyelids at all, and anything darker than the base shades looked so muddy. It seems that most other people do not have these issues so I don't know if I got a weird one, but this is the first eye shadow palette I've ever just given up using.
HOLY GRAIL OF CLEAN MAKEUP 5
Shelby Lahey from undisclosed
I cannot say enough positive things about the p/y/t brand to my friends and family interested in the clean makeup movement. I have been searching for clean makeup products made with care that are affordable for me. Many consumers do not understand that clean makeup is NOT going to be similar to the mainstream drug store or "prestige" brands sold by major beauty companies that contain terrible metals & other toxins. These have been the standard norm for far too long. p/y/t beauty is setting new standards.
This palette is yet another example of the consistency of p/y/t products...all made with care + quality! I have been looking for an eye shadow palette with subtle, shimmery, nude colors that will brighten my eyes and are great for everyday wear. I finally found it with this product and can happily say these colors are so incredible. The way they appear on the palette is the same as they appear when applied to my eyelids. So many times certain eye shadows look great on the palette but fail to transfer over to your eye. These colors apply evenly and stay on all day WITHOUT a heavy, sticky, slimy eye shadow primer. These colors are perfect for the office or for a night out on the town. I'm in love!
Great pallet for a no-makeup makeup look 4
clean beauty lover from California
I love that this is a clean pallet! the colors are pigmented and natural; perfect for a no-makeup makeup look. the shimmers are beautiful and the packaging is high quality! My only complaint is that a couple shades are kind of the same and it's a little pricey. I would recommend this pallet but I wouldn't buy it if it's not on sale
Perfect palette for everyday! 5
Dilara Atkins from undisclosed
Lovely palette to travel with and have I. The top drawer of your collection. It has all the shades you need to create looks that are subtle or Smokey!
Gorgeous 5
Mjn81 from Kansas City
I love this palette from the great packaging to the shadows inside. Perfect for everyday looks!
So classy, userfriendly! 5
Mary Houtsma from undisclosed
I love the simplicity of the eye shadow and I love that it is safe! Thank you for honoring my desire to be natural and Earth friendly but beautiful too!!
I won't be purchasing this product again 3
Makeitso from undisclosed
This product throws a lot of particles in the air. It got in my eyes, and I wear contacts. I had to stop using it, even though I liked the colors.
Super Silky 5
Lewis from undisclosed
This eyeshadow palette is fantastic. The shadows go on silky smooth and last all day/all night. Th colors are perfect for every day or for a dramatic eye in the evening. I feel good about using the products as well since there is no bad stuff.
Great day/night variety 5
Robyn J. Wilkinson from undisclosed
Another great product from PYT - feeling especially good about how it's made and what it's made of. Aside from that, there's great variety in the colors for day to night wear. A great product at a very affordable price!
Impressive 5
Anita Fedor from undisclosed
I adore this palette! It's versatile for day or night, the colors are very blendable and long-lasting too. I prefer to use makeup that is good for my skin and this one delivers on price as well. Highly recommended!
