Rated 4.13 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review I really enjoyed this brow product!
This is a pretty dang good brow product. I love that you get both a brow powder and a brow pencil with this. It also comes with a spoolie brush on one side, which it great. It has everything you need to create an entire brow look, and that makes this perfect for traveling. The pencil has a precise tip that allows you to get in-between your brow hairs, and also to create small strokes that mimic hairs. The pencil is a bit more on the firm and waxy side, but it's decently pigmented, and it blends out nicely. The brow powder is pigmented as well, and also blends out easily. The powder has a sponge tip applicator that is pretty big, so it's kind of hard to be precise with it. I usually just used an angled brush to apply it because I'm not a fan of the applicator. My only other issue with the powder is that it has some shimmer or very fine micro glitter in it, which I found slightly odd. You don't really notice it unless you apply a ton of the powder, or if you're specifically looking for it, so it's not that bad. Other than that, I really enjoyed this. I can definitely see myself repurchasing this.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not my type of product
I haven't tried a marker style brow product before so I was excited to try this. It is a double ended product with a fine tip marker on one side and a highlighter powder tip on the other side. The marker side looked like it would work well. When I tried it on my hand, it had a nice fine line. The color looked like it would match my brows nicely (not too warm). However, I just don't think this style of marker was for me. There was nothing wrong with it, but I enjoy a faster application with a larger pencil. I have fairly full brows and this took too long to apply. The highlight side didn't do anything for me. Literally nothing came out. I think I may have gotten a defective product as most other reviews I've since read really enjoyed this side, but the marker side seemed nice but just wasn't my style. I received this item complementary for my honest review.
Reviewed by 221 customers Dries Out Fast, Applicator Too Flimsy
Ashley from Chicago
The tip seems to dry out after a few strokes. The applicator tip is so flimsy that you can't make a thin line easily, it bends to the thick part if that makes sense?
Mandapleasee from Denver, Colorado
This brow product is great compared to others! But my problem is that the blonde isn't as blonde for some lighter blondes. It did blend in great and stayed on all day. I love that it is curved so that I don't have to maneuver the pencil onto my brows.
Ajmich85 from Ann Arbor MI
I loved the concept of this product. It just didn't fulfil my expectations. The brow marker is okay it goes on easy but also wipes off just as easy. The highlight part was cool but wouldn't work after the first time. I wouldn't buy this again but it did work for what it's meant for.
Great for oily skin with sparse brows
Biscuit from Winter Park, Floirida
I have oily skin with very sparse brows. This marker product goes on smooth and lasts all day. I also live in humid Florida. I use a brow powder to fill in and help soften the look.
I would never buy this again
Courtney from Kansas City
This is the worst eyebrow pencil/ shaper I have ever bought. I never leave negative reviews but after using this once it is obvious the pencil is too small and dark for "soft brown" more like black and the "Glow" end worked the first use and has never worked or had enough product on the end.
Really Like It!
rachel801 from KS
I have really pale brows and have been interested in microblading but haven't done it yet. I really like the finished look I get with ColorStay Shape & Glow Brow Pencil. I don't always use the "glow" part but the actual brow product is great. It's easy to apply and I think it looks more natural than a regular pencil.
Pixiepro from Michigan
I loved this brow product. It kept the brow looking very natural while also defining it. I love the glow for after. It's easy to remove & put on, Lasts a long time and I would buy it again! I received complimentary for reviewing
I love this product
Snow from Savannah, Ga
I use this for my brows an i also use it as a light showd.
Samantha from Ona wv
Loved how easy to use and how hreat it works
Love this brow product!
Vanessa from Liberty Twp OH
Initially got a color that was a little too light, but bought a darker one and I use it every day!!!
Snowmoon from GA
I use this for my eye shadow an brow lighter
ADRIENNE from Royersford, PA
I tried it and it was ok. I would not use again because it made my brows look artificial
Its not for me
Dreamstar1666 from fl
this product ran a little flat with me. I don't have a lot of experience with brow products, so it might just be me.
I like the idea of the marker and highlight but the high light wasnt bold enough and the marker was very basic.
I have very pale skin and i couldn't even see the high light.
Jan from FL
I was surprised how much I love the brow pencil. Its a fine felt tip like pen that goes on smooth and looks natural. it never ran no matter how much i sweat.
Nice way to fill in brows
Kathi from Atlanta, GA
This is a nice product to fill in brows. It goes on precise and lasts most of the day. However, it didn't match perfectly with my brow color.
Doesn't work well
Alybugz from Bountiful, UT
The color doesn't transfer to hair well and it dries out too quickly. The highlight is too dark
Revlon ColorStay Brow Shape and Glow works!!
karahb from florida
Revlon ColorStay Brow Shape and Glow works! also is last a long time! my eyebrows looks the best they ever have !,,
Love this brow pencil!
Corvettegirl22 from GB, WI
Love this brow pencil. It is so quick and easy to use. It goes on smooth to create perfect brows. Lasts all day.
Not for me
Ashley from Oregon
I was excited to try this brow pen but I couldn't get the hang of it. Seemed to go on too thick and looked unnatural, the next time I tried I couldn't get any pigment at all. Overall, not a product for me.
Carolina from South Carolina
Nice concept however application was not very easy. The strokes look natural but I had a hard time getting it to come out. Had to go over areas several times but once applied looks good and stays put.
sbrew09 from Columbia, SC
This brow product is fantastic! It creates really nice hairlike strokes and lasts all day (and then some!). I wish there was a spoolie on the opposite end instead of the messy powder highlight, though!
Fake Eye Brows
MOMMYAW from MARENGO
Nor a pick fan of drawing on my own eye brows.
I'm a fan!
Em_R91 from Tallahassee, FL
I'm a definite fan of this brow product. The marker portion is phenomenal. It's super pigmented and easy to use. I was able to create beautiful, natural eyebrow strokes. I wasn't in love with the shadow side. The applicator was too thick and not enough product came out. I also wish the shadow was more of a champagne color. The gold is too dark for my light skin.
I'll Stick With My Gel and Brush
Audrey V. from Graham, WA
When I saw that this was a pen applicator I was looking forward to trying a new method for filling in my brows. Not impressed. Maybe it's just because I don't have the time or patience to "microblade" each individual hair. I much prefer my angled brush and gel pomade. I also feel like this wasn't very pigmented. The whole point of filling in brows is to add color where there's little to no coverage. The only thing I liked about this pen is the dual ended highlighting powder.
Tay from AR
I did not have high hopes for this product. I have tried brow products with similiar applicators and did not like it, but this one surprised me. It showed up nicely, matched my eyebrows, looked natural, and stayed on all night. My only complaint was that once your applicator gets foundation on it, it doesn't work until you clean it off or press firmly to get more product to cover the applicator. I recieved this product from Crowdtap and can assure that my review is honest and accurate based off of my opinion alone.