Product Reviews Rated 4.05 out of 5 stars
670 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review This eyeliner is... This eyeliner is honestly one of the best eyeliner's I've ever used, if not the best. The line is so thin and sleek! I come out with a perfect winged liner every time. I have yet to mess up my eyeliner using this. It looks intimidating but is really easy to use, I would recommend practicing on paper so you get the hang of it before applying it to your face. The wheel makes sure the color does not fade, so the color is bold and black throughout the line. It is also very long lasting. I wore it for 13 hours and it did not smudge or fade out at all. I will definitely be recommending this to all of my friends and be repurchasing this!
Most Helpful Critical Review I was so excited to... I was so excited to get approved to sample the Revlon colorstay exactify liquid liner, but I have to say it was a big let down. Perhaps its me, that I just don't have a steady enough hand or need more practice with the roller wheel bit I'm not %100 certain that I'm the issue here. While the roller wheel is a cute idea in theory, it really doesn't seem practical. The wheel spins yes, but that is the only movement you get. A straight line is all you will get. I don't know anyone who's eyelid is a perfect straight line. Eyelids are curved. At this point the only thing this is good for is dipping an eyeliner brush in there and scrap the roller wheel applicator.
Reviewed by 670 customers Nope 1
Atty Tude from Boise, ID
This helps me make a wing on my very deep set eyes. But I HATE the shiny, vinyl look. I know Revlon makes a matte version, but I can't find it for love or money. Ulta, please help!
Amazing!!! 5
Jes K from San Jose ca
This liner is bomb!!!! So amazing I bought it in every color! So easy to use! You can do amazing yet effortless eye looks that make you look very advanced.
Never buy agail 1
Shel from Brandywine MD
Awful! Plastic on my eyelids!
amazing and easy to use 5
Britt from Illinois
Ive been using this product for like 5 years and I love it! I love how easy it is to put on as well as the color choices. I have light skin and eyes so I love the mulberry, mermaid blue and sparkling black.
Worst eyeliner EVER 1
Elaine from Melbourne , Australia
I bought this by accident. I just grabbed any liquid eyeliner from Revlon because in the past, they have been a reliable fall back and I'm quite confident with any liner liquid tip. However, upon opening and seeing the wheel design I immediately knew this was going to be a huge flop. it denies the law of physics. How on earth is the pigment supposed to go on smooth when the wheel is going through it? How do you even manoeuver it for curved lines to make defined lines around the eye? We don't have square eyes ?!! Not only that but the product itself is not pigmented. It is watery, runs out of product before 1 line is made and flakes when dry. It's also shiny. Shiny and transparent and flakey... I did better looking eyeliner in highschool with much less. This is rubbish. For sure there was one person on the Revlon team who advised against this poor product. Whoever gave it the green light for purely money making gimicky dupe Mac version needs to be fired because I now have trust issues with Revlon and won't be buying anything from this brand again.
I love it! 5
Sher from Pleasanton, CA
The roller helps a lot to go straight and do not lose my track of eyeline.
Innovative 5
elle9o from Elk Grove, CA
I feel more impressed and intrigued by the formula within this eyeliner other than just the wheel tip itself—being that it's similar to a fine tip applicator from my personal standpoint. The formula is the best I've used so far compared to previous eyeliner brands. It's very pigmented, doesn't smudge, doesn't blot, dries quickly, and lasts long. At the end of the day, however, it takes a bit of effort to remove because the ingredients seem similar to that of waterproof eyeliner, even though the product doesn't state that it is waterproof on the box. Seems expensive, but with its formula quality, I would say that it's well worth the price.
Absolutely worst eyeliner I have ever tried 1
TT from Phoenix, AZ
This is the most difficult eyeliner I have ever used. People say there is a learning curve to using the applicator, but to be honest, I threw it away before ever getting good at using it because the product started to thin out and get watery/oily. Since the black eyeliner was no longer opaque, application looked horrible.
Not Exactify at all 1
Suz3033 from Sydney Australia
I've been wearing liquid eyeliner for over 15 years and thought I'd give it a go as I liked the precision wheel. However found this product very difficult to use and disappointing. I've used a number of times and my lines are just messy each time. Wouldn't recommend this product at all.
Boo 1
Chrissy from Quesnel bc
I Vought these not happy the roller hurts my eyes and I find it hard and nessy
Smooth line 3
CyndiWLPN from Birmingham, AL
I found this amazing eyeliner wheel and it goes on super smooth, very precise! The only thing is it says 24 hour. My eyes began to water about 20 minutes after applying and there was no coverage at all where they watered. Totally flushed all the color away. So upset because I love the colors and the wheel but I needed it to stay. SAD!!!
Never 1
Anonymous from Hanover, MD
Awful product. Its watery and can't even apply properly. Worst product ever.
Straight Line! 5
mama1523 from DC
Liquid liner never comes out right the first time on my eyes. The roller tip gives me a straight line that I can either have fine or make bigger and always comes out perfect the first time! I'll never use another kind again.
Perfect lines everytime! 4
Trisha from Texas
I bought this liner a couple weeks ago, I absolutely love it! I am someone who always struggled to do my eyeliner but with this I get the perfect look everytime. The only reason I didnt give this 5 stars is because I wish It had even more colors, this has me wanting to experiment with all sorts of colors, neons, bright colors, metallics, bold colors..... please consider extending into more colors. I would buy them all! I recommend this for everyone.
NO! 1
Alex from Austin, Tx
If you blink, it gets everywhere. If you want more than a very thin line it is difficult to make it thicker without there being gaps.
Can I give this 10 stars?!! 5
Gina Marie from Ohio
I purchased this today and couldn't wait to try it. I normally use Revlon skinny liquid liner but wanted more precision. This goes on like magic and it gives you control to make the perfect shape. It was very easy to apply and didn't take practice. I love it!!
AMAZING PRODUCT 5
CC1105 from Kansas City, MISSOURI
Undoubtedly the most precise eyeliner I have ever used, and I've tried a lot. I'm completely satisfied with this product and I STRONGLY recommend if you want that fine precise love for a big impact. Looking soon to purchase additional colors.
My favorite liner so easy to use 5
Deidre from Tacoma, Wa
This product is so easy to use goes on easy and last all day!
Mulberry is the best color EVER 5
Mela Lugosi from Phoenix, AZ
I have been looking for a burgundy liquid liner since my go-to professional brand discontinued theirs, and Mulberry is the best color. I actually PREFER this color over my old expensive brand's burgundy shade. I only wish this was made with a felt tip style apicator. I don't like the wheel applicator, I've tried and tried but I just use my own eyeliner brush. Mulberry is the perfect color for my fair freckled skin, green eyes, and Auburn hair.
I would buy this again 5
Mom of3 from Wichita ks
Yes I've used this I love it fast liner and perfect wings every time
What is this? A miniature pizza cutter?! 4
Tyedyed78 from Hilo, Hawai'i
Bought this today and when I opened it I was like "what that heck is this?!
A pizza cutter.
Who the heck invented this?! I'm returning this"
Then I'm like well I'll at least try it
Five seconds later "omg this is the best thing ever!"
I goes on so easy and perfect.
Best wing ever 5
Stevienie from Indiana
Love it! Rolls on in crisp lines, this makes the quickest easiest wings every time
Difficult to use!!! Do not like this product at all. 2
Lillian from Upland
Looks lumpy
Terrible 1
Vanessaramirez27 from Paris
Just horrible, worst eyeliner ever! Its just a bad idea.
Amazing Staying Power 4
Bryony from United Kingdom
I have been using this product as my daily eyeliner for about a month now. I've tried so many different liquid eyeliners from Revolution to KVD and everywhere in between. The applicator is funky - it did take a bit of getting used to but works well. The product itself STAYS. I have had no issues with it smudging under my eyes, which I've had with high end products - it literally doesn't budge unless I attack it with make up remover.
The only tiny downside is that I'm yet to get a precise point to my wing. Otherwise, a fab product worth the price.
