Product Reviews Rated 3.05 out of 5 stars
20 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Beautiful Liquid Eyeshadow I have a fair-medium skin tone. I have combination skin, leaning more towards the oily side.
These liquid eyeshadows are beautiful. I ordered all four colors. The green and purple are more transparent, the blue/teal and black/gray one are more opaque. The purple one can flake especially when you apply more to try to build up coverage. I found that the purple and green work great as a glitter liquid liner, they make a really pretty cat eye. The blue and black are gorgeous on the lid, it takes a little blending at the crease to make them work as part of a whole eye look. I just went back in with my transition shade/s to clean up the crease and it looked amazing.
I have never used a liquid eyeshadow before, and just like with any makeup techniques, I am sure practice makes perfect.
Overall I was really pleased with these shadows. I love Wet n Wild products as I feel you do get a good quality product for the price. I REALLY love mermaids and mermaid tones and these are beautiful!
Most Helpful Critical Review Looks scaley. I picked up the teal colored eyeshadow, and the color is definitely beautiful. Now I can't say I've had any real experience with cream eyeshadow, so this could be part of why it didn't work out for me...but it was just awful. I tried a couple times to use it and had to wipe it off both times. It just didn't quite blend out for me and once it dried down it just looked...scaley. It looked like it was going to all flake right off. When I wiped it off, it left behind glitter all over my eyes and face which was difficult to get off.
Again, I don't really use this type of eyeshadow so maybe I just don't know how to use it correctly, but I just couldn't make it look nice. I tried the maybelline cream eyeshadows that were in a tube packaging and had no luck with those either. I ended up returning this..
Reviewed by 20 customers Only sheer coverage possible 2
chickadee423 from Chicago
The formula is a black liquid with gray metallic glitter. The only possible way to use it is to swipe with the doe foot applicator, which shows primarily the black with the glitter just interspersed. If you want a true metallic look, you have to dab with the applicator to keep the glitter concentrated. However, if you do this, the formula will be too thick and when it dries will become scaly in appearance and start flaking off immediately. So, you can use this liquid for a sheer black-glitter look, but you cannot get any type of opaque metallic look out of it.
No 1
Rina from NC
This is terrible.
I love it! 5
Jody from undisclosed
It definitely compares to high end pricey liquid shadows! I've used mine multiple times! Its a great price, good quality and quantity
Not a fan 3
KR from Idaho
So no experience using liquid shadows with that being said this is not user friendly. I have all 4 colors and the purple one was the one o was excited about and tried couple times to work with it but it doesn't do well with blending. I have tried to work fast with one coat on my lids but when I go back and do another layer or try to blend it sucks 😕 I haven't the best of luck and by the end it really irritated my eyes for 2 days after I took the makeup off. I can't say anything about the other shades because I have been trying to experiment with the just the one. I'm not really happy with the products and I see they have new liquid eyeshadows that are more user friendly and I will defiantly be trying because wet n wild has some kinks to work out and I think this set just wasn't great and hopefully the next is 👍
Does not look like shown. 1
KC from VA
I picked up the only color they have left, Moonlight Majesty and it looks nothing like the photos. It's not purple with green flash. It's way, way darker and is a rusty brown color with almost no color change to it. Very disappointed.
Looks scaley. 2
Steph from OR
I picked up the teal colored eyeshadow, and the color is definitely beautiful. Now I can't say I've had any real experience with cream eyeshadow, so this could be part of why it didn't work out for me...but it was just awful. I tried a couple times to use it and had to wipe it off both times. It just didn't quite blend out for me and once it dried down it just looked...scaley. It looked like it was going to all flake right off. When I wiped it off, it left behind glitter all over my eyes and face which was difficult to get off.
Again, I don't really use this type of eyeshadow so maybe I just don't know how to use it correctly, but I just couldn't make it look nice. I tried the maybelline cream eyeshadows that were in a tube packaging and had no luck with those either. I ended up returning this..
Not for me 2
squirlmunk from Indian Head MD
I LOVE glitter eyeshadow but this was not good.
Tricky product! 4
Ashlee from Denver, CO
This product is tricky to work with. Once it is completely blended out it looks beautiful but it's hard to blend into a crease color and it can go from pretty to crazy looking real quick.
LOVE this! 5
Jenn from Cherry Hill, NJ
Only con to this product - when wiping off with a makeup wipe (Neutrogena), some glitter remained behind.
Beautiful Liquid Eyeshadow 4
Tiffany from Interlachen, FL
I have a fair-medium skin tone. I have combination skin, leaning more towards the oily side.
These liquid eyeshadows are beautiful. I ordered all four colors. The green and purple are more transparent, the blue/teal and black/gray one are more opaque. The purple one can flake especially when you apply more to try to build up coverage. I found that the purple and green work great as a glitter liquid liner, they make a really pretty cat eye. The blue and black are gorgeous on the lid, it takes a little blending at the crease to make them work as part of a whole eye look. I just went back in with my transition shade/s to clean up the crease and it looked amazing.
I have never used a liquid eyeshadow before, and just like with any makeup techniques, I am sure practice makes perfect.
Overall I was really pleased with these shadows. I love Wet n Wild products as I feel you do get a good quality product for the price. I REALLY love mermaids and mermaid tones and these are beautiful!
its ok 3
Jen from sarasota, fl
This makeup is very hard to take off. Used make-up remover, soap, warm water, and I had to scrub my skin raw until it came off. Would not use very often. Would not buy again. It also does not apply well. would have to keep eyes closed until dry so it did not smudge.
It's okay. 3
Jessica from Ninety Six, SC
I like the color and I still wear it, but it is hard to apply and it's not as shiny and bright as I wanted. Not bad for the price at all though.
Fantastic smudge-proof sparkles! 5
alp_pkc from Seattle, WA
I love this stuff! Great for a mermaid look. It's intensely sparkly and has a duochrome, but unlike a powder eyeshadow, there's no glitter fallout or mess. Once it dries, it's set and doesn't budge all day long. It was really easy to remove with waterproof makeup remover too- just hold the pad in place for 10 seconds, then swipe off. I bought all three shades and don't regret it one bit.
Good for the price. 3
MiaOfMassachusetts from Queens, NY
I love glittery eyeshadow, and had been using stila's liquid glitter eyeshadow until I found this product. So, the pros first- it's cheap, the colors are fun and interesting, and looks great when freshly applied (especially if used on top of eyeshadows, like a topper/ for halo looks). Now the cons - some shades look patchy when trying to apply a second layer, after about 2 hours the shadow clumps up and flakes off, and it loses most of its effect when dry (ie it doesn't look as smooth or intense, or flawless). Overall, I don't mind them, because I use them mostly over smoky eye looks to add a little sparkle, so the patchiness isn't very obvious. But, I will say that I haven't been reaching for them much since I got them, because of how bad the flaking is. My advice is, try one, pick it up on sale, and see how you like it, before you get more.
Pretty but don't like the fallout 3
Courtney M from Palm Desert, CA
This is so gorgeous as long as you apply to the lid with the wand applicator. I have issues with the product blending away when I try to blend the edges. And when it blends away, the sparkles and glitter fall out. Overall, I am a little disappointed with this product.
Flaky and dry 1
Ketti from Alabama
It was completely dry and flaked off throughout the day. My eyelids felt dry and itchy all day. By the time the day was over I had little flakes of it all over my face. It didn't blend well. I was very disappointed because the color is gorgeous.
So much better than loose glitter 5
Mantis from DC
I got Aquatic Prism and Moonlight Majesty and I LOVE THEM. It is hard for me to deal with loose glitter because it gets absolutely everywhere so this is a great alternative. I put Aquatic Prism on Saturday night and it didn't wear off, and I used Moonlight Majesty Sunday all day and it didn't budge. Once you let it dry with a few waves of your hand it stays on until you remove it. I hope they add more colors.
Horrible Formula 1
Elyzium from Upstate NY
I bought the color Lara's Necklace, after I saw all the YouTube reviews..
Mine was nothing like what I saw. The formula was sheer and patchy. I am going to have to use it over a green eyeshadow to get it to really work. I am glad the other colors I wanted where out of stock.
Bummer 3
KrazyKatLady from Pittsburgh
very disappointed. cracks when dry and looks awful!
I LOVE these! 5
Samantha from Fort Wayne, IN
I'm obsessed with these! They are a perfect addition to add to a smoky eye to give it that pop of color! My favorite is Aquatic Prism, it is very pigmented! The others are lovely as well, just a little more on the sheer side. I would recommend using a glitter primer under it to prevent glitter fall out!
