Product Reviews Rated 3.2 out of 5 stars
41 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Holy grail find. Rocky start but then works miracles I was skeptical because this is a stick. I love Peach and Lily for their clean skincare without fragrances or other nasties. I will say when i first used it I thought I would return it because it felt like it didnt distribute on the skin and tugged. But then gave it another chance using my fingers to warm it before applying to my eye area. That worked much better. I had to almost rub it off the stick tho to deposit onto my fingers.
But what is interesting is that i realized it gets softer on the inside of the stick. After a few uses it would melt onto my skin instantly and i started applying directly onto my eye area. And let me tell you I have genetically dark eye circles. Nothing worked. But after a month of use i am getting compliments about my eyes! They look so bright now even when i dont get enough sleep that i stopped using under eye concealer and see a visible difference! I even noticed my tiny crows feet (i am 28) are more filled in.
I think this product must not travel well and maybe dries on the edges which is why it is so hard to apply on first try. But now it is a definite rebuy for me. You pretty much just have to break it in a little. For the price and how long it lasts and its effect it is definitely worth a buy
Most Helpful Critical Review I really wish this worked I believe I will be returning this product as it does absolutely nothing for my dark circles, despite the amazing list of beneficial ingredients. It feels good, and it is easy to apply which I really like, and doesn't bother my sensitive eyes at all. I wouldn't use this if you have wrinkles or crow's feet from smiling because it will migrate over and you'll end up with shimmer lines filling in the wrinkles. Puffy eyes or bags is not really my concern, and neither is dry skin around my eyes, but due to a bunch of medical stuff I have very stubborn dark circles and all this product seems to be doing for that is trying to bounce the light off of them superficially. I have tried a lot of different ingredients and products but if really stubborn dark circles are your issue like it is for me I would try to look for ingredients that might be more medicinal or stronger.
Reviewed by 41 customers I would not recommend 2
Sassyfras from Carmel Indiana
I really like the peach and lily brand for their glass skin refining serum and their eye cream but this stick was very dry when I opened it. The stick also wasn't attached to anything and fell right out when I attempted to use it. Even trying to put it on my eyes after it fell out it was dry and pulled my skin. I ended up exchanging for the Tula brand eye stick for the same price and it was much more hydrating and packaged a lot more conveniently.
Doesn't do anything 2
Kathy from Colorado
This is the only Peach & Lily product that i will not repurchase. The stick tugs on your eye area, and doesn't seem to actually do anything. I even tried rubbing it with my fingers to apply it and barely any product came off the stick unless I reall dig in.
refreshing 4
Bondilina from Tucson, AZ
I use this with my morning routine to help with puffy tired eyes. Just the feeling of rolling the stick on your under eyes is relaxing and awakening.
Holy grail find. Rocky start but then works miracles 5
Cat from New york
I was skeptical because this is a stick. I love Peach and Lily for their clean skincare without fragrances or other nasties. I will say when i first used it I thought I would return it because it felt like it didnt distribute on the skin and tugged. But then gave it another chance using my fingers to warm it before applying to my eye area. That worked much better. I had to almost rub it off the stick tho to deposit onto my fingers.
But what is interesting is that i realized it gets softer on the inside of the stick. After a few uses it would melt onto my skin instantly and i started applying directly onto my eye area. And let me tell you I have genetically dark eye circles. Nothing worked. But after a month of use i am getting compliments about my eyes! They look so bright now even when i dont get enough sleep that i stopped using under eye concealer and see a visible difference! I even noticed my tiny crows feet (i am 28) are more filled in.
I think this product must not travel well and maybe dries on the edges which is why it is so hard to apply on first try. But now it is a definite rebuy for me. You pretty much just have to break it in a little. For the price and how long it lasts and its effect it is definitely worth a buy
Fail 1
SherryTX from Texas
The stick does feel cool when it touches the skin, but it tugs on it. The delicate skin under the eye should never be tugged so i don't know why they made an eye product that does. Then with a little heat it slicked on too much and left a dry white film on my skin that was no pretty. I never saw any brightening or improvement of any kind.
Complete miss 1
Angie from New York, NY
I love most of Peach and Lily's skincare line, but this product was a complete miss for me. First of all, it doesn't glide well around the eye area, which would actually cause more friction and possible wrinkling of the area. Also, the product is a bit chalky, applies in chunks, and doesn't absorb at all. After two uses, the stick fell out of its container. Complete mess.
Not for me, but maybe someone else 3
Tinx from Phoenix, AZ
I wanted to love this product because I really love all the other Peach & Lilly products I have but... I just can't. First off I should say I am in my early thirties just to give you an idea of the age of my skin. This product does help with dark circles but no hydration at all, in fact it does the opposite. It dried my under eyes out and made the fine lines I did have look even worse. I would recommend this product for late teens to twenty somethings. If you are looking to hide dark circles annnd hydrate your under eyes in the morning this product may not be for you. Also I just want to throw it out there that I did try to use this multiple ways for a couple weeks just to be sure.
Don't waste your money 1
SkinCareGuru from Milwaukee, WI
The product arrived defective (cracked and flew right out of the tube when I opened it). Called to get it exchanged and CS said I needed to go to the store to show the damage. Really disappointed with the product and CS response.
Product kept falling out of tube 3
NG from Columbus
I love P&L, but this is a miss. I only used it three times, and two of the times the stick flew out into my sink. I also didn't really notice any benefit from the product for my skin, so I will be exchanging for a different P&L product that I know works (and that I'm out of :) )
Whyyyyyyyyy me 😠3
Rochelle from pa
I have been loving so many of the peach and lily products, that I decided to add another one to the mix but unfortunately my order was delivered today and I immediately opened the product and the stick fell out of the tube before I even got to use it. I put it back in and used the product but now I will need to worry about that each and every time I use the recovery stick now
I use this on top of their retinoic eye cream! 5
Hmhmielewski from Los Angeles CA
This does what it says. It brightens the under eyes and is cooling. It's not an eye cream but Peach and Lily just came out with another eye product which is sooo perfect. I use that one first and then layer this on top and my under eyes are brighter and glowy! It's the perfect mix for me.
save your money 3
Corinne from MA
I'd give a review on the product but I couldn't use it long enough before it broke. just save your money for something better ( and without glitter/irredesint.
Accentuates lines- not good under makeup 1
Melissa from Modesto, CA
Was recommended this product by associate after telling her I have super dry under eyes and wanted a product I could wear under makeup. This product was drying not moisturizing. It definitely does not glide on- it tugs the skin. It seemed like it aged me instead of moisturizing. It held on to all the makeup and created creasing
Exactly what I wanted 5
Mish from Huntington Beach
I had a similar stick years ago and could never find it. This is exactly what I wanted. IMO it's translucent enough that I don't have to blend with make up but could if I was going out. I have more puffy ness than dark circles.
Would buy again 4
AM from Seattle
Glides on smoothly and feels cool when you apply it. Make sure you keep it upright! When I'm not careful the stick falls out of the tube... more annoying than anything else. Will likely purchase again.
Not worth it 1
Melissa from Saint louis
I've been using it for a couple weeks and didn't really see a difference. This morning I wake up and use it and the product comes out of the container and drops down into my sink. Poorly made.
Not smooth 2
Justine from Santa Fe
I wanted to love this. But sadly, I do not. The glide on concept is great but it leaves a residue and is NOT good under makeup. Makes fine lines more obvious and dries out undereye area majorly.
No. Just no. 1
Amethyst from United States
I'm sorry, I never write reviews but I have to say, this product is horrible. As you'd expect from an under eye stick, it sometimes gets in your eyes. Now what you don't expect is the absolute hellfire that's goes with it. It felt like I was going blind. Also, the stick BROKE OFF and fell out after one use. And after all that.... it's useless. No cooling. No skin benefits. Horrible product.
Cooling...that's all. 2
Rikki from Illinois
At this price, I expected so much more. Love their other products. This one is a dud.
... was SHOOK with the results 5
Tired mom from Orange County
I hesitated so bad with this purchase. Had been in my cart for a while because of all the mixed reviews. Once I finally decided to get and used it for myself.. my jaw literally dropped. It really does have a cooling factor to it that changed the game for me. I instantly saw my eyes de-puff, brighten, and conceal themselves. I have a newborn right now so I was desperate to stop looking tired all the time. I am extremely happy I went with my gut. I really do trust Peach and Lily and regret doubting this product.
Cute packaging, not worth the price tag 3
yourgirlH from Chicago
you don't get enough product for such a high price tag with P & L brand. I have several items now and there is just such a high competition in skincare business, that this just doesn't impress me. Cheaper, better products out there. Check the size vs the price tag and research ingredients for yourself and so many of the same ones in bigger bottles (maybe not as pretty packaging) but you will see that expensive does not always mean better.
NO MORE PUFFINESS!!! 5
PuffyPuff from San Francisco
I bought this because I have chronic puffiness under my eyes (lack of sleep and stress). I put this on and in 20 minutes my eyes looked better then the cold tea bag treatment I give them when I'm really in trouble! Not only that but it instantly lightens up my dark circles! I put it on one eye and got distracted by the phone and before I realized I hadn't applied it to my other eye my boyfriend said something about how 1 eye looked weird and dark. It's amazing! Perfect daytime eye cream under makeup and for that morning puffiness. I use a thicker product for night.
Yes I love this 5
Kirsten from Boston, MA
This does everything it says it does, but side note, I didn't have puffy eyes to begin with. I did have darker circles and dryer skin.
This is so cooling upon applying. Just like applying any product, you've got to be gentle, but this does not drag your skin. After 2 days of use this has brightened by under eyes. The product sinks into my skin. When I apply it in the evening and I wake up 8 hours later, my under eyes are looking rested. It's amazing.
Eye Refresh 5
KatieDID from Seattle, WA
Because of some of the other reviews, I was a little hesitant to order this. But I love and trust Peach & Lily so far, so I figured I'd give it a go. It's cooling and hydrating, so it did reduce puffiness. I personally felt like it brightened my dark circles—key word: brightened (not made them disappear!). As far as fine lines and wrinkles (I'm 36 and have them), I don't see an immediate difference, but I've only been using it about two weeks. Overall, I enjoy this product and I enjoy reapplying it because it feels really good!
uh...this ain't it chief 3
kiwi from lee's summit, mo
i have been using this product for a month. upon application no cooling effect in fact the first applications were rough and pulled the skin. now the product is gliding on but i noticed a grayness on my skin where the product was applied which made me look sickly and many people told me i looked tired or sick (the day i applied it without makeup)..i have a deeper skin tone and this product is not for you without makeup if you have one too. furthermore, i did not see a difference in under eye moisture in fact i tried patting the product in and it did not sink in...wish i could return it but it's too late