Product Reviews Rated 4.33 out of 5 stars
104 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Pretty Sure I Will Own All Of These! I react to carmine and red 40 dyes in cosmetics, especially in the eye area. So I was hesitant to try this in Firedancer. So glad that I did! It led me to pretty much purchasing every other color. I have no reaction at all. No itchiness, puffing or redness. I have very oily eyelids and use the Original Urban Decay Primer. (Top Yacht I'm coming for you! It's sold out EVERYWHERE!!! LOL) I use these in multiple ways they are so versatile and blendable. I use it for my inner corner, outer corner, lower lashline, all over color and so on. They are really easy to use together or with other shadows. I do tend to like the application better with my finger or a dense brush (if I'm going for that Extra shine) or I'll use a fluffier brush for a light wash of color. I have learned that with your finger if you rub at it, you get a higher metallic/shine payoff (or a wet brush).
Most Helpful Critical Review Tarts changed the formula in 2019 The original formula was a soft, creamy, easy to apply cream shadow. I think the cream part of it made it pop more because you got almost a wet look from it. It was like a primer and shadow/pigment in one! It was absolutely stunning. I first bought mine in June 2019. It has been a year (now June 2020) and I wanted to repurchase. Whenever I received the new item, it came in a different and smaller packaging. The formula is entirely different. It is just like the Mac loose pigments. You HAVE to use a primer or it will go all over your face. It is NOTHING like the original formula. Has zero wet and metallic look that it used to give. I give this product one star. The previous formula- 10 stars. I will miss it always!
Reviewed by 104 customers Will buy again! 5
Texas girl from Tyler, TX
I put this eye shadow on my inner eye lid with dark brown on the outside. I use the sun drenched color and it brings out the brown. Love wearing this color when I wear a black or brown shirt. It goes with anything really!
It's a loose powder, not a cream. 5
Julie from Fort Wayne, IN
I was looking for a shiny cream eye shadow I thought this was what it was but it's actually loose glitter. I really like it though.. The wild at heart color looks good with brown eyes.
This is different than anything else! 5
Theismannfan from Sissonville, WV
This is a loose powder so don't breathe when you apply! Don't tip the container. Barely dip a finger in it and blend into the top of your eye makeup.
Disappointed 3
Neechie from Los Angeles
I got Top Yacht a while ago and it's fantastic. So I decided to get Park Ave Princess recently and sad to see they are now loose messy pigments. Hope they go back to the more creamy style, it stays all day and doesn't make a mess. I'll use it, but it won't be with me on travel, it would be too messy.
Would not purchase again, returning the one I purchased. 1
Kathy from Louisville
Didn't like anything about this shadow. Color not as pictured, messy to use from start to finish.
I'm a magical fairy princess 5
moostakeasey from Grand Rapids, MI
I absolutely love this stuff. I have it in two colors. I see a lot of ppl complaining about the change, but I never tried the original formula. It is definitely very loose. I almost always end up with a sparkly chest lol. But I get a ton of compliments when I wear it. It stays on so well. I had chemo almost three years ago and I still have a watery eye which will jack up most eyeshadows but this stuff stays put, is high-quality and gorgeous. Some ppl are saying they can barely see it? Girl, put more on!
Loose pigment?? 3
alex from Burnsville, Minnesota
I bought this because I've heard so many rave reviews, but I have to say I'm disappointed. The name lead me to believe this would be a cream shadow, but it's a loose pigment. It's beautiful, I love the color and it's fairly easy to use, and has good staying power. But, i would have bought a loose pigment if that's what I wanted. I hate the hassle of loose pigments, and was looking for something quick to apply and easy to work with.
Love this brand 1
Dolly from Gautier ms
Does not go on smoothly or evenly
The best color so beautiful 5
Dmq from New york
Best Products ever
Top off a Look! 5
AshR from New York
I have most of the shades and I love them! They color lasts all day without flaking off. They layer over shadows beautifully.
Pretty but more of a champagne color than gold 2
Cat mom from Saginaw, MI
This eyeshadow is applied best with my finger. And on my pale skin tone it barely shows up.
Eh, just ok 3
sjm3 from NJ
It really wasn't impressive. The color wasn't as bold as it claims. It didn't last.
I found the sparkly eyeshadows in the too faced palette I bought was much better. I wouldn't buy this product again
Yaass 5
Sadiekay from Fresno
So pigmented! Absolutely Looove!
Tarts changed the formula in 2019 1
Nothing like the last formula from Fort Worth, Texas
The original formula was a soft, creamy, easy to apply cream shadow. I think the cream part of it made it pop more because you got almost a wet look from it. It was like a primer and shadow/pigment in one! It was absolutely stunning. I first bought mine in June 2019. It has been a year (now June 2020) and I wanted to repurchase. Whenever I received the new item, it came in a different and smaller packaging. The formula is entirely different. It is just like the Mac loose pigments. You HAVE to use a primer or it will go all over your face. It is NOTHING like the original formula. Has zero wet and metallic look that it used to give. I give this product one star. The previous formula- 10 stars. I will miss it always!
Totally bummed 3
Elsewhere33 from Winston-Salem, NC
So the Frosé chrome paint was my absolute favorite eyeshadow, which is saying a lot because I've got a LOT of makeup. Sadly, I lost my pot yesterday. Bought a new one today...and it's loose powder now? It used to be a creamy pressed paint type deal, which was SO easy and amazing. Super bummed about the change, I'm desperately searching the depths of the internet for an unopened package of the old formula.
Not what i expected 3
Krystal from Buffalo
When i saw paint pot i thought it would be more of cream but it for sure is not im kinda disappointed because i wanted a cream and i bought 2 but none the less its pretty but just not what i wanted or was looking for my collection
Yesss!! 5
ADStone from CA
Score with these. Beautiful colors. Stand out. Stunning.
Love this shadow 5
Taylor from Statesboro Georgia
Love how shiny the shadow is. If you want to stand out in a crowd, I would highly recommend a shadow. I bought it to wear in a wedding and got compliments all night.
Absolutely gorgeous! 5
Needa7205 from Vancouver, WA
This is so foiled and pigmented! I got Park Ave Princess and its such a beautiful color. Very nice and bronze. I plan to buy more shades. There is so much product in these pots too, its a great deal!
Love Frose! 5
4seasonbeauty from Utah
I purchased the Frose Paint Pot a few months ago and absolutely love it! It applies easily with a finger or brush. I love to pair it with the Urban Decay Naked Cherry palette! It compliments the palette so well! The paint pot came with a little plastic stamper thing to press the loose powder down if you prefer it more solid than loose. I keep the stamper in the pot and it contains all the product so it doesn't get all over when I open it. Just my two cents of advice for those that complain about the paint pots being messy. They're supposed to be loose.
Why fix what isn't broke 1
Pickle72 from Peoria Illinois
I have always loved the Chrome Paint but what happened to them? The package has changed and the product is different. It use to be a creamy metallic buttery dream and now it's some kind of fluffy weird loose powder that is a mess and difficult to apply. I don't like it and I will be returning. Heading out to buy Ciate foils. I added a photo of the older version and the new in Frose. No thank you
I would recommend this product 5
Maria from Georgia
I love this eye shadow and the color is flattering to different colors.
Meh 3
Jen from Upland
I feel like tarte changed the formula of this. I have top yacht and it doesn't come loose or make a mess applying. Returned
AMAZING!!!!!!!! 5
makeuplover from New York, N.Y
Color is amazing, not messy looks gorgeous.
Pigmented and glittery 5
Kay from Texas
I don't wear a whole lot of makeup on my eyes so a touch of this chrome paint shadow pot makes my eyes pop! Very smooth and it doesn't flake. This was a gift and I would consider buying again when I run out (probably will last me five years at this rate)
