Rated 4.62 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Perfect purchase!
I have had a make up eraser for about 3 years now and just ordered a new one. I wash my big cloth make up eraser with my laundry weekly and hang mine in my shower and it keeps it damp throughout the day. I've never had an issue with it smelling but after using it for so long my make up has stained it which makes it harder for the wipe to remove all of my eye make up easily. I love how eco friendly the make up eraser has made my self care routine. I did buy a black make up eraser the second time around to prevent noticeable stains from appearing right away. My mini make up eraser is still almost perfect and I am still using it when I travel. I love the compact travel size!
Most Helpful Critical Review I don't love it, but I don't hate it
I was on the fence between buying this or the Halo reusable makeup remover pads. I wanted to try this one first because of the reviews and this is the OG product. It works pretty well at removing my makeup, but it kept leaving black lint on my face even though i washed it first. It got the majority of my makeup off but my face definitely wasn't clean and there were still traces of mascara left too. I also don't like the aspect of using it section by section each time you use it so you don't have to wash it as often. Maybe my expectations were a little high but it did get the majority of my makeup off before washing my face and I like that it's more environmentally friendly than makeup wipes that usually burn my skin.
Reviewed by 101 customers This is a great product!
Jeanie Beanie from WV
I couldn't believe how well this product worked. When I pulled it out of the package I did not think it was anything more than a towel, but when I used it - WOW - how easy it was to remove my makeup and just with water!
Almost too good to be true!
Rosie from Lancaster, CA
I have 3 and use one each night. It removes all makeup without scrubbing, and is so gentle on my sensitive skin. The MUE does get mascara and eyeliner markings on until it is washed in the washing machine, but you could just use it once, wash, and rotate with others if that bothers you. The ONLY negative thing I can say is that since using the MUE, my sink gets a dark ring around where the water level is after I drain it! I didn't have this issue when using soap and water to remove my makeup, so it has to have something to do with the MUE. But, I'm hooked. I am buying more so hopefully I can use a fresh one each night.
Great alternative to removing makeup!
Michele from Pittsburgh, pa
My daughter bought me this. It is so gentle and easily removed your makeup without makeup remover. All you need is water! I love the black cloth because it does not show your eye makeup like the pink cloth does
I didn't think it'd work... BUT it's the absolute best!
Maya from Glen Mills
First impression was: oh, well... it looks like a piece of fleece. Then I tried it and it removed every single bit of make up. Including mascara and 99% of concealer and foundation. After using it, I rinse my face the same way I've always done (I use Dermalogica products) and the face towel I use to dry myself had zero makeup stains, like it usually did when I used wipes (Neutrogena). Cherry on top, my eyelid skin doesn't hurt / burn as it used to due to the wipes friction. I'm 45, have mixed skin and this is by far the best makeup remover I've found in the market, and I tried everything: Lancôme, Neutrogena, Dermalogica, Estée Lauder, etc. I absolutely recommend this product.
HOW DOES THIS WORK SO WELL
Julie from USA
I picked this up when it was on sale for those nights where I'm too lazy to do my whole skincare routine, but at least want to remove my makeup, and... holy cow, this makeup eraser makes it so easy for me to be lazy! Hahaha!
I can't understand the magic behind this, but it removes all of my makeup so easy with just water!
I legit have nothing to complain about this product! Works like it says it will! Love it!
Didn't work for me
CC from Phillipsburg, NJ
I tried this with just water a few times and then with face wash cleanser a few times as well and didn't feel like it was cleaning. With just water I felt like it was only moving and smearing product around my face but not really taking much off and with face wash it needed a ton to get even a little bit of a lather going. I hate to return something that I used so I thought I could just use it to wash my body and that didn't really work for me either. I know a lot of people love it and if it's working for you that's great but sadly it did not work for me.
Demon Drea from Houston, TX
A friend recommended it to me and I was a bit skeptical at first (considering I usually wear heavy waterproof makeup and do not so natural eye looks) but this thing is insane!!! I almost couldnt believe how well it worked- it took off ALL my makeup!! Only thing I will say it that my eyelashes feel a bit rough ? after but that could just be me lol Also it's way better for the environment than makeup wipes! So glad I switched to this and will never buy makeup wipes again. 🖤
Love Makeup Erasers💜💜💜💜
Tinny F from La Conner, WA
I now have 2 makeup erasers and I love them. I don't have to use anything but water to remove all my makeup and my skin looks better when I use it because i don't have to use harsh chemicals to wash my face.
I wish I could give this more than 5 stars!
cab2476 from Virginia
I was skeptical at first. "Wet the Makeup Eraser with warm water and your makeup comes right off." After one use, I was a believer. I ended up purchasing 4 more! I didn't realize it but the two sides have different length of fibers. The longer side is more for exfoliating skin. I like to now use this with micellar water but just plain water removes even the toughest (waterproof products) without feeling like you're scrubbing your skin off!
etonline from San Jose, CA
I wasn't sure if this would make me feel comfortable relying on only this for makeup removal, but it totally works. Love that I can save on makeup wipes/pads and makeup remover, and help the environment at the same time. Haven't tried removing a full going out face of makeup yet, COVID, but I definitely recommend for an average makeup user.
Not sure how I feel about it
Peyton from Chicago, IL
It says it is supposed to remove all of your makeup. I followed the instructions and it removes a good amount of it but not all. It wouldn't remove all of my concealer and mascara which is not waterproof. I felt I needed to go in with my usual makeup remover after and when I did, I noticed there was still makeup on my face. Also I feel like I'm order to get a good amount of the makeup off, you need to harshly rub your skin which I try not to do. I don't know if I'll replace my usual makeup remover with this.
I would totally buy this item again.
Sunny.D from Fresno, CA
Takes off all my makeup without having to add any product to it.
Black is best!
Egoodan from Olive Hill, Ky.
I use a makeup eraser every night, or something similar. This one is my favorite because it's black and I don't have to worry about stains and it looking awful from mascara. This works well, but the price is crazy! I bought mine 1/2 price and that's the price it's worth. The unknown brands work just as well, but I do enjoy this makeup eraser.
Saving my wallet and the landfills
Gardenlove from Colorado Springs, CO
Love the black because it does not show all the makeup. Easy to wash with all your laundry loads. Saves a lot of money down the road and all the towels don't end up in the landfill each day.
Ciabatta from Los Angeles CA
I might be biased, as I've been using the mini (wash a freebie) for about a year and think it is the perfect size! I bought the full size one when it was 50% off, which is a great deal, but I didn't realize just how much larger it is than the mini. I still love it, but I just prefer the mini size instead. I'll definitely be getting the multi pack of minis soon.
Not sure how it works - but it does!
Ginger from Florida
Bought two of these during the 21 days of beauty sale and gave one to my roommate. It really does work well!
TT from Pittsburgh PA
I couldn't wash my face without one. They get the makeup off thoroughly and gently. I own 3 now so I always have one in rotation. Way better than any disposable wipe and far better for the environment
Reyna from Jerome
I like the black. It doesn't show the make up. I would buy
Mein TX from Dallas, TX
I like the black. It doesn't show the make up. I would buy it again.
Onnaroll from Ohio
This takes off my makeup, no problem. It even takes off my waterproof mascara.
Julia from Las Vegas
I received a "travel size" for free and like it. I just wished it was a little bigger. The travel size is the size of the palm of your hand. When I saw this was on sale for 10 dollars I thought why not! First off the full size is huge! It's the size of my forearm! Massive difference also the material is a little softer. However, it work the same manic this cloth takes my eye makeup off without taking my eyelashes out! It's gentle works fast and does it all with just water! No more make remover pluse face wash! What a money saver! And at half off such a deal!!
absolutely love the makeup eraser
vicki from phila
not only does it remove stubborn make up, it also removes paint! im an iron worker and always have a hard time removing paint from my hands. this actually works great for that also!! highly recommend
Best. Cleansing. Product. Ever.
Kelsey from Billings, MT
This is hands down a game changer! I love it to remove my make before washing my face. It does such a good job I don't have to double cleanse anymore! This is sooooo much better than makeup wipes, which I've never been a fan of, and way more economical. I cannot recommend enough!!!
Chris from Washington, D.C.
It's cute and works super well
Buy a wash cloth Instead
Nikki from Chicago
This is basically a glorified face wash cloth, didn't find that it took my makeup off seamlessly and I would probably be better off using a wash cloth and face wash!