Rated 3.42 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review My new go to!
I received this as a sample during the launch and thought, what the heck. I am a die hard the Balm mad lash girl and I have NEVER found anything that's as good as that mascara. I'd try other brands and always go back. This blows Mad Lash out of the water! I hate that Mad Lash has a very stiff brush and hurts my sensitive eyes. This brush is very soft and the formula is incredible! These are my lashes after a full 16 hour work day of sweating (crying) and no curling! I will 100% be going back to this time and time again.
Most Helpful Critical Review Great for long natural lashes
I received this product as a gift for a review, it is wonderful for a natural but enhanced lash! It really lengthens and accentuates curl. It is very light and easy to use! My only issue is it does not provide much volume and I like a chunky lash. However, it is perfect for natural days and has an incredible formula!
Reviewed by 74 customers Caviar is a perfect mascara
I.Love.Ulta from USA
The Laura Mercier caviar volume mascara was purchased as a part of the Ulta Beauty Finds, 9 piece mascara set. This mascara was one of the very best of that set.
The caviar mascara provided incredible volume, depth, and length to my eye lashes. My lashes look full, natural, and well-accentuated my eyes.
I.will buy this product again in the future.
Definitely would recommend
Liz from Malibu CA
I've been looking for a new mascara for about the last 2 years and I found it! Brush separates my lashes and doesn't pull too much product out
anonymous from undisclosed
Amazing eyelashes increase in intensity from the first week of use, the eyelashes remain wet for a long time
I would buy this again and have!
Retired from Bluffton SC
Love this mascara!
Best mascara ever!
anonymous from Hardinsburg, KY
This mascara is the bomb. It adds so much thickness and volume to your lashes.
anonymous from Dallas, tx
This mascara does not work at all- gives zero volume and doesn't really show up
Sad to find this mascara irritates my eyes
Sara91 from Cambridge
I bought this mascara pre-lockdown and have since worn makeup rarely but every time I have worn this mascara, the skin on my eyelids has been red and swollen the next day. I do not have overly sensitive skin so there must be something nasty in this mascara.
Best Mascara I've Tried
AB from FL
The formula is quite thin but it coats your lashes perfectly and leaves them looking full and voluminous but without all of the spider lashes. The brush is a nice size for me as it really helps separate and evenly coat the lashes. Overall I like this way better than Roller Lash. Definitely a new holy grail.
not for me
Ash from utah
I got this as a sample, tried it out and I loved how my lashes look but my eyes were killing me after about 10 minutes after I used it. I never have watery itchy eyes but after using it my eyes we're like a fountain and I had to wash it off after a couple of hours of trying to struggle through it.
angelica from ny
I received the mini version as an extra bonus in past order and have been using it ever since. I love the brush. works well for my lashes and really coats on the product. expensive but awesome
Not purchasing it again!
Hanna from undisclosed
I agree with all the poor reviews. I've been using the discontinued Laura Mercier mascaras (long lash and volume) for eight years. Just like many loyal customers, I've embraced new formulas in favorite products by giving them a try. Disappointment and confusion all around!!!! The new mascara is one big disappointment because it clumps and sticks lashes together. There is too much heavy mascara product on the brush. It reminds me of cheap, random mascaras that I used when I was a teenager.
Yvonne from Dallas
Gives natural appearance to eyelashes making them more noticeable by darkening and lengthening them while preserving their natural separation.
Julieta from NY
Natural enhance the eyelashes, color and length. I love it.
My new ride or die mascara
Heavymetalmama from Minneapolis
Smooth application without smudging the upper lids. Love the spoolie! Soft full fluffy lashes.
Jude57 from NL, Canada
I use LM foundation and love it, so decided to try this mascara. I do like the product but think the brush is just too big. It is difficult to get coverage on the fine lashes in the corner of your eye and too much product comes out with the brush.
Makeup mama from New Hampshire
The brush on this is different as it's spiraled, but I think that adds to the magic. I have never found a mascara that I love as much as this! This does not give me raccoon eyes and lasts all days beautifully. I am impressed with how this lengthens my lashes and also adds a bit of bulk. It layers nicely and doesn't get gloopy.
karen 7 from Richmond VA
I have been using Laura Mercier make up for years. I really like their regular mascara as it does not clump, and coats eyelashes evenly. I order this new "caviar" mascara and have used it several times...it is awful!!!! It clumps and stick lashes together. Do not buy this, it's a waste of money.
Bring back Long Lash
Quinn from Portland, Or
LMs Long Lash was my ALL TIME favorite mascara. Nothing compared...the new mascara is too thick and does nothing for my lashes. I keep trying to find something comparable to Long Lash but there is NOTHING! If I knew it was being discontinued I would have bought as many as I could...
I miss Long Lash
kirdi from Boston, MA
I used the Laura Mercier Long Lash Mascara for years and it was amazing (would rate it 10 out of 5 stars!!). Easy to make a natural look or a more dramatic look, no mess, no smearing, quick application. I was surprised to find out it was discontinued and tried a few other brands that had similar looking brushes, none were as good. So I decided to give this Caviar Volume Panoramic Mascara a try (because I figured the Long Lash by the same company had been so excellent so why not at least try it). Disappointed as it's very difficult to make a natural look. Very clumpy and smears easily. The brush is huge and I have to wipe off half the mascara on the brush with tissue to help prevent the smearing and clumps. I do use the Long Lash Mascara brush that I saved, which does help provide a more natural look when needed. I often end up wasting a lot of time applying this mascara (as I said before, I have to remove mascara from the brush, correct clumps and smudges, etc). I think it's designed more for those who want a dramatic look, which I don't want daily...going for a more natural look during the day and for work.
BRING BACK LONG LASH. I miss it dearly.
Glendeetz from CA
Nothing special. At first the wand was intriguing. When I first opened and used the mascara, I found the wand to be a little too big on the ends making it a little harder to work with in a rush. Usually, I like mascaras more a week in when the formula has dried a bit, but this was better the first 2 or 3 times, and then went downhill from there. The wand and tube got clumpier, and that clumpiness just transferred to my lashes. When you first apply it, the result is promising with some length. But it seems you need a 2nd application to get the volume it claims- beware, 2nd application makes it so much worse! It's almost like it makes the lashes heavy and they lose curl. You get more volume, but not in the cute kind of way. By the end of the day, my lashes were back to normal size, with what appears to be basic mascara. If I needed to I would use it, but I do not care to reach for it again.
Colorado Girl from Colorado
From the first use it was clumping and found the brush to be difficult to use
It is just ok.
Kjoe from Massachusetts
I was hoping for more based on recommendations. My lashes are an average length. This is good for everyday makeup wear but if you want a wow factor for an evening out, keep searching. I also experienced the design in the tube rubbing off.
hockeygal87 from WA
No flaking, no smudging, no clumping, no raccoon eyes at the end of the day! Finally found my holy grail! I've been using this for over a month now, and I really like the formula and the brush. It is volumizing, lengthening, and long lasting. It is also pretty easy to wash off, and does not irritate my eyes. I did not experience the packaging rubbing off as another reviewer stated, so it may just depend on how it is stored... I put mine in my makeup drawer and haven't had any issues. I will definitely be purchasing again!
Chloe86 from London
I bought this mascara a couple of weeks ago and the brush is a little big which makes it a very thick application and quite clumpy. May suit some but didn't work for me. Bring back the 'long lash mascara' it was perfect!
Brush too dense. Mascara goes on too thick and smu
Patti37 from Gladwin, MI
Brush too dense. Mascara goes on too heavy and smudges onto lids. Your previous product was awesome. Bring it back!