Product Reviews Rated 4.51 out of 5 stars
698 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Hooded Eyelid WIN! Cake Pencil Eyeliner is the ONLY pencil liner I've ever used that did not transfer onto my hooded eyelids! Women with hooded eyelids, follow these tips: 1) skincare free eyelids, 2) nude eyeshadow covered eyelids, 3) wait to open eyes fully for a few minutes after applying liner. A few more reasons this eyeliner has quickly reached my Holy Grail status: a) It is so extremely versatile. I drew a precise yet soft upper lash line & wing, easily filled my upper & lower waterlines AND achieved a smudgy lower lash line all with this one pencil! b) zero irritation to my sensitive eyes EVEN when using on waterlines! c) didn't collect in my tear duct after a few hours like most eyeliners. d) removes easily with my Garnier Micellar Water All-in-1 Normal & Sensitive Skin Waterproof on a cotton round. ( FYI: Bioderma Sensibio H2O Micelle Solution Sensitive has a very hard time removing. Softymo Speedy Oil Cleanser removed the swatch off my inner arm easily, but I can't use oil cleanser around my sensitive eyes. ). A few other things to note: Only when wearing my eye cream, it traveled into my under eye creases and did not set. It will flake if it's applied into lashes and rubbed. Cake liner in the shade Trooper is less shiny & not as dark black as the same shade in Tattoo liquid liner. I received this eyeliner free from Influenster for my honest review.
Most Helpful Critical Review Flakey but pigmented I wanted to love this so much but sadly it wasn't to be. The end broke off with a little pressure, it was difficult to apply and flakey too. I had to smoothen with a small precision brush and apply a couple of coats of shadow under my lower lid to get it to work. Sadly I don't believe this is worth the price tag. It lasted throughout the day without touch ups and I love that the color was so intense even on my darker skin. They are also Vegan and Cruelty Free so I'd feel good spending my coins on them. I received this product free from Influenster in exchange for an honest review. All opinions above are mine.
Reviewed by 698 customers Absolute garbage 1
Peachy from Las Vegas
I like KVD tattoo liner and though I'd give this a try but it tugged, pulled, and the color payoff was inconsistent. It also broke off... I've never had that happen before with ANY eyeliner before.. avoid at all cost if you can.
I would not buy this again. 1
Cake pencils from Cartersville,ga
When I use this eye liner it breaks apart, so about half of it has broken off. The first time I used this, it had caked upand little pieces have kept getting in my eyes. It is not water proof and had disappeared in a few minutes.
Its okay 3
Pezu from undisclosed
I dont hate it but its a really soft so the tip breaks easily if you roll the stick too much but you can work with it
Eyeliner 5
Lilyest from Ranch Cucamonga CA
Best eyeliner ever. This is the only eyeliner that lasts all day on me I can honestly say this is my forever eyeliner!
Highly recommended 5
Lynnanne01234 from Science hill ky
One of the smoothest eyeliners I have ever used. I highly recommend this product
Would recommend 5
Kimmberly from undisclosed
I really loved it. Stayed in my water line all day!
love it and would probably buy it again 5
Jjonee from undisclosed
Goes on smooth and stays on for most of the day which is nice
My go to 5
Jenny31 from Philadelphia, PA
It is the perfect color and it lasts all day. Definitely recommend.
Wow! 5
LadyVenia from Brighton, CO
This product is amazing, deep, rich, long lasting, waterline approved color.
Wow! 5
LadyVenia from Denver, CO
This product is amazing, deep, rich, long lasting, waterline approved color.
Not worth the calories 1
Angmoon from Jacksonville
Flakes off in eyes. Definitely not long wearing. It also smudges after only having on a couple hours. Very unhappy
Great eyeliner! 5
Laura Pierson from West Virginia
I ordered the white pencil. The color pigmented and stays well without having to reapply.
Pretty good 5
Taytertot from Az
Creamy texture led to a smooth application. Still firm enough not to break or smear too
very pigmented 4
April P from Georgis
Very pigmented,good quality for the price! It works out well and is good with detail. Wish there was a sharpener in the end to keep a good point.
Favorite eyeliner for my water line!!! 5
StephieSN from Vallejo ca
So easy to apply and durable!! It's also blend-able if you're doing a smudged grungy look. Aside from my anti precision liner this is my favorite!
White Cake Eyeliner Pencil 5
Tifftiff from Arizona
Glides on like magic! I got a black one too, haven't used it. The white lasts longer than my Mac pencil in my waterline so this is a great replacement and budget friendly. And it's vegan so I'd say yes to the pencil guys!
Review 2
Chelsie wright from Indiana
Made my eyes water and burn when putting on my lower lash line.
Amazing 5
Snoopy from The Netherlands
It is super easy to apply. And it's beautifully white
Best eye pencil! 5
Jessyka from Las Vegas
I have tried a lot of pencils. So far.. this is the best one! It doesn't come off!
Best soft liner. 5
Clorae from Seattle WA
I rarely use a whole eyeliner before it dries up or breaks/ I lose it! But this one I use so often I actually finished it in a few months. Love this liner for bottom lashes.
I use this daily. It stays on the whole day which I love. 5
Stacy B from Concord, California
This is one of my favorite items. I love this eyeliner.
Stays 5
Angie_ from Montréal
I'm really happy. I heard great things about the durability of KVD products and I wasn't disappointed. Stayed all day
Goes on smooth and high color pigment 5
Rachel Ingrid from Allenwood, NJ
This is my go to eyeliner now. It lasts all day/all night. It glides on so smoothly. I love how easily I can smudge it with a brush to soften the line, or even create a smokey eye without having to use eye shadow. It has just enough playtime, and when it sets, it stays. I can also very easily create a sharp line if I'm looking for it. I don't like liquid eyeliner so I always use pencils. This has become my favorite one. So impressed with it.
Raccoon Eyes 1
Heather N from Los Angeles, CA
I had high hopes for this pencil. The eye liner doesn't last. It smudges and made me look like a raccoon. Which is a look a lot of people like, so if that's your aesthetic, go for it! If instead you need something that is cleaner and lasts, I do not recommend.
Amazing! 5
Grung3yChix from Cincinnari
My new favorite pencil eyeliner! It doesn't smear (unless I want it to) and it will stay on. Almost too well. I have to scrub it sometimes to get it to come off but it's a good problem to have!
