Product Reviews Rated 4.51 out of 5 stars
718 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Hooded Eyelid WIN! Cake Pencil Eyeliner is the ONLY pencil liner I've ever used that did not transfer onto my hooded eyelids! Women with hooded eyelids, follow these tips: 1) skincare free eyelids, 2) nude eyeshadow covered eyelids, 3) wait to open eyes fully for a few minutes after applying liner. A few more reasons this eyeliner has quickly reached my Holy Grail status: a) It is so extremely versatile. I drew a precise yet soft upper lash line & wing, easily filled my upper & lower waterlines AND achieved a smudgy lower lash line all with this one pencil! b) zero irritation to my sensitive eyes EVEN when using on waterlines! c) didn't collect in my tear duct after a few hours like most eyeliners. d) removes easily with my Garnier Micellar Water All-in-1 Normal & Sensitive Skin Waterproof on a cotton round. ( FYI: Bioderma Sensibio H2O Micelle Solution Sensitive has a very hard time removing. Softymo Speedy Oil Cleanser removed the swatch off my inner arm easily, but I can't use oil cleanser around my sensitive eyes. ). A few other things to note: Only when wearing my eye cream, it traveled into my under eye creases and did not set. It will flake if it's applied into lashes and rubbed. Cake liner in the shade Trooper is less shiny & not as dark black as the same shade in Tattoo liquid liner. I received this eyeliner free from Influenster for my honest review.
Most Helpful Critical Review Flakey but pigmented I wanted to love this so much but sadly it wasn't to be. The end broke off with a little pressure, it was difficult to apply and flakey too. I had to smoothen with a small precision brush and apply a couple of coats of shadow under my lower lid to get it to work. Sadly I don't believe this is worth the price tag. It lasted throughout the day without touch ups and I love that the color was so intense even on my darker skin. They are also Vegan and Cruelty Free so I'd feel good spending my coins on them. I received this product free from Influenster in exchange for an honest review. All opinions above are mine.
Reviewed by 718 customers Irritated my eyes 2
Nancy from Milwaukee, WI
I was hoping this wouldn't irritate my eyes... it did. I've been looking for a new eyeliner and mascara, I would like to stick to a more organic/natural/cruelty free product, I guess I'll keep searching.
Loved it 5
Smilefairy from undisclosed
I love this eyeliner. It's probably one of the few that does not leave me with raccoon eyes. It's so creamy and dark black.
FABULOUS 5
Mel E from Texas
LOVE this eyeliner!! Goes on smoothly, didnt smudge and it's waterproof which I love - cuz you just never know!!
I love how easy it is to apply it and it's so smooth. 5
Belle from Chicago, Illinois
It works great. I really like it. I will definitely buy this product again.
LOVE this eyeliner! 5
Maria from Wixom MI
FINALLY found the creamy soft eyeliner I've been looking for. And bonus it stays on!
Cake Pencil Eyeliner black and brown both 5
Sclev from West Virginia
Absolutely love the way it glides on the eyes and stays all day.
Super Pigmented! 4
Kelsey B from Las Vegas, NV
Definitely is very thick and opaque. I used the white shade for wings and set with a white shadow because it didn't stick perfect— only reason for 4 stars instead of 5. For less dramatic looks I'm sure it would be perfect.
Cake liner 5
Trees from Washington DC
It stays longer than other products (always fade).
Cake pencil eyeliner 5
Alyaa from Bahrain
Easy to apply highly pigment nice texture long lasting
It's okay 3
Bets from Illinois
Very creamy and glides easily, but when used in my water line it didn't last had very high hopes.
Cake pencil Eyeliner 5
Nour shaw from undisclosed
I did love the pencil liner it go on smooth and long lasting i will buy it again and i really do recommend it simply it dose what it supposed to and stays all day
Convenient 5
pnw blackbird from Portland, OR
A good, standard staple eyeliner. Consider it if you don't have a pencil liner already.
New holy grail! 5
Kd from Georgia
Long lasting and super black. Glides easily!
Would buy again 4
Emily from OH
This is a pretty good eyeliner. It wasn't dry like some of the reviews said. It's possible those people got a "bad batch", which the Ulta employee said they would replace if so. It glides on smooth, but could be a little better. I'm happy with it, I would buy again
Yassss 5
Morticia from Plano, TX
Finally, a great product that does what it says
So...So...Liner 3
Alyssa from Apple Valley, MN
Gave this liner a try. The color is super pigmented and beautiful. The pencil is small and awkward to hold while applying. The liner itself is a little flaky and transferred onto my lid too easily (after I applied it and opened my eyes, there was a thin line on my upper lid from the liner. I did wait for a little before opening my eyes and I applied setting powder). This liner would work well if you're not looking for a smooth, perfect liner and don't mind a slightly messy look.
Cake Pencil Eyeliner is the Best! 5
Adi18 from Pasadena, CA
I love this Cake Pencil Eyeliner. I love how it makes my green eyes pop.
Will be buying again 5
Trace from NC
I was looking for an eyeliner that would not smear throughout the day this one is the winner hands down!
#1 eyeliner I love it 5
AmandaB2626 from Tuscaloosa Alabama
It stays on 24 hours best results ever! Love the product
Absolute garbage 1
Peachy from Las Vegas
I like KVD tattoo liner and though I'd give this a try but it tugged, pulled, and the color payoff was inconsistent. It also broke off... I've never had that happen before with ANY eyeliner before.. avoid at all cost if you can.
I would not buy this again. 1
Cake pencils from Cartersville,ga
When I use this eye liner it breaks apart, so about half of it has broken off. The first time I used this, it had caked upand little pieces have kept getting in my eyes. It is not water proof and had disappeared in a few minutes.
Its okay 3
Pezu from undisclosed
I dont hate it but its a really soft so the tip breaks easily if you roll the stick too much but you can work with it
Eyeliner 5
Lilyest from Ranch Cucamonga CA
Best eyeliner ever. This is the only eyeliner that lasts all day on me I can honestly say this is my forever eyeliner!
Highly recommended 5
Lynnanne01234 from Science hill ky
One of the smoothest eyeliners I have ever used. I highly recommend this product
Would recommend 5
Kimmberly from undisclosed
I really loved it. Stayed in my water line all day!
