Product Reviews Rated 4.29 out of 5 stars
14 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Love, love, love! I love this palette! I've never tried Sugarpill before and now I can't wait to try their other products! I really love the balance of neutrals and more bright/unconventional colors because you can create a subtle everyday look, or something a little more adventurous. I think this is the perfect palette to travel with because it's so versatile and compact. Depending on your skin tone, some of the shades need to be built up, but for the most part they're all very pigmented. Moon Shine is definitely my favorite shade! The only shade I'm a little disappointed in is Skyrise because it's a little rough and patchy, but if you wet it it works better.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not a fan surprisingly Let me start this off by saying I love sugarpill. I customized my own pro palette and have the funsize palette. But this palette gave me problems.
Mainly the shimmers. To the touch they felt soft and smooth. Very pigmented. On the eye they are difficult to lay down with a brush. The fallout on that beautiful blue is insane. Trying to blend a color next to the blue makes the color flake off onto my cheeks. It was not a great experience. This seems to be their foiled formula, not the shimmer formula I'm familiar with. I am not a fan. Had to return this because I know I never want to use it again. :(
Maybe I could have worked with it more, tried glitter glue, or foiled the shades, but I don't take extra measures for my other shadows. I don't want to have to work so hard to make a palette work!
Reviewed by 14 customers Not a fan surprisingly 2
Ella of frell from Elk Grove, ca
Let me start this off by saying I love sugarpill. I customized my own pro palette and have the funsize palette. But this palette gave me problems.
Mainly the shimmers. To the touch they felt soft and smooth. Very pigmented. On the eye they are difficult to lay down with a brush. The fallout on that beautiful blue is insane. Trying to blend a color next to the blue makes the color flake off onto my cheeks. It was not a great experience. This seems to be their foiled formula, not the shimmer formula I'm familiar with. I am not a fan. Had to return this because I know I never want to use it again. :(
Maybe I could have worked with it more, tried glitter glue, or foiled the shades, but I don't take extra measures for my other shadows. I don't want to have to work so hard to make a palette work!
Love, love, love! 4
makeup enthusiast from CA
I love this palette! I've never tried Sugarpill before and now I can't wait to try their other products! I really love the balance of neutrals and more bright/unconventional colors because you can create a subtle everyday look, or something a little more adventurous. I think this is the perfect palette to travel with because it's so versatile and compact. Depending on your skin tone, some of the shades need to be built up, but for the most part they're all very pigmented. Moon Shine is definitely my favorite shade! The only shade I'm a little disappointed in is Skyrise because it's a little rough and patchy, but if you wet it it works better.
First Sugar Pill Purchase!! 5
ChelseaS from RI
This was my first sugar pill purchase and i will definitely be keeping them on my radar for any new releases! The formula is buttery and the shimmers are creamy smooth. The blue shade is a bit more chunky but with a tacky base you'll be fine. The blush is very pretty and pigmented too. Before buying i watched plenty of reviews on YouTube and all of them were positive which encouraged me to purchase this palette.
Versatile 4
:) from California
I love this palette! I wanted something that was more neutral, but with a few pops of color so that I can travel with one palette. They blend smoothly and are pretty pigmented, although some of the shades need to be built up. Moon Shine is definitely my favorite. The packaging is super cute, sturdy, compact, and has a mirror. I can't wait to try what else this brand has to offer!
Get a mixing medium and you will be in love 4
Gothcake from Oregon
I tried these with a tacky base and didn't care for them, but when I used a mixing medium I absolutely fell in love with the depth of the colors. You won't be disappointed if you using a mixing medium!
blends like a dream 5
Saha from Atlanta
I ordered this palette because it looked amazing on Makeup by Krishna on Instagram and it did not disappoint. The color payoff was amazing and blended so easily. Now I want the other capsule.
favorite palette 5
Lina from New Jersey
I cannot express how beautiful this palette is. The theme is beautiful and the formula is amazing. Please get this palette if you are second guessing it (I don't know how)
Love love LOVE 5
Chappie's Mother from USA
I'm so happy Sugar pill made these capsules. They blend like a dream and the colors are to die for. If you're unsure, I say go for it 🥰
Gorgeous. 5
TattooAnnie from NY
I'm a Sugarpill liquid lipstick loyalist and this is my first purchase of their eyeshadows. They are gorgeous and so pigmented. I searched them all and they are so buttery and beautiful. Even the matte shades are soft and bold. Not sure about the reviewer that said there's no pigment. I don't see that at all.
Neutral Sugarpill Heaven 5
Sydneyboston from Layton, UT
For everyone who ever wanted a more neutral tone pallet from Sugarpill this one is for you!
This pallet has the same quality as every other Sugarpill shadow, which is one of the better quality shadows. The brand is known for bold and bright colors. This pallet packs the punch with just the right neutrals and a few pops of color to give you some variety.
The packaging is perfection. The case is sturdy, with a mirror included- perfect for travel. And honestly have you ever seen a pallet that looks like this!?? Sugarpill is a really creative brand and they put a lot of creativity into this pallet. Yes the shadows are different sizes, but that's what makes them fun; plus most of the transition shades or the "one & done" shades are in the bigger pans. And that's another thing I love about this pallet- all the "one & done" shades. So if you need a quick look you can put a single shade on and it looks flawless.
Bottom line: you need this pallet! If you've never tried Sugarpill try this first. If you love Sugarpill already here's the perfect neutral pallet to add to your collection.
First purchase from sugarpill, not my last! 4
Sophers from California
I got this on a whim, I wanted the first one(the pink palette) but got this one because it was in stock and I usually can only wear neutrals at work. I got it and I'm in love. I've used for about 2 weeks now and I'm absolutely in love with sugarpill quality. Definitely get it!
My only problem with it is the shade I'm gonna wear the most are super tiny, but, you need the smallest amount of product to make it powerful.
Beautiful palette 5
Tiffany from Stroudsburg, PA
I love the unique packaging and design. The quality of Sugarpill shadows are there. They always strive to be different but keep their products amazing quality. I love that I can do pops of color or do an everyday neutral look.
Love it! 5
lauren from bend OR
Love it. Colors blends well. Just like the first one. High quality. Would reccomend to a friend.
Severely disappointed 2
Marylandmaven from Maryland
I bought both capsules and neither had pigmentation. The ones that did have any, were in the smallest pans. Shadows blended out horribly into nothing and we're very patchy. The shimmery shades were matte texture wise which was really weird. I had to spray my brush with setting spray to get those to even work. I eventually gave up and had to use my fingers. some of the better colors in these are in the smaller pans and they are very tiny. The size of a dime? And the lessor impressive shades are larger. Waste of money for the quality.
