Rated 3.88 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review New Favorite!
I have used 17 different brow pencils in the last 6 years and nothing compares to this one! I've spent $.99 up to $20. My last favorite I could only find in beauty supply stores for black women. It was discontinued two years ago and I've been on the hunt ever since. This pencil compliments my jet black hair and my Tan (straight from the crayon box) complexion. The color is natural yet buildable if you like a more dramatic brow. This pencil is the new staple in my makeup bag.
Most Helpful Critical Review Too soft
Grabbed this because I couldn't remember what my other (better) pencil brand was as I've used it down to the nub (later looked up online; it's the Palladio pencil). I thought the color would be great, as it's a nice, dark brown that's not too warm nor too ashy. That was about as good as offered from this pencil.
It's far too soft to draw any decent lines; I have thin brows, and need a sharp pencil to fill things in without looking like I painted them on. It doesn't deposit as much pigment as the color suggests, either, and having to press down - on a soft pencil - makes the whole application even worse.
I've used this maybe three times, each time re-sharpening as much as possible (again, such a soft pencil, and you know that soft pencils can be difficult to sharpen without the tip crumbling off). It's about a third of the way gone already!
The last negative is the comb at the other end - it, also, is way too soft, and too large for me to use practically.
Maybe if you have bigger brows and don't mind the softer look this would be a viable option, but I tossed this one.
Reviewed by 124 customers I have been using this product for years...
Gray110588 from Santa Fe,NM
Super nice, love the color.. 😍
I would buy this again
Azi from Charlotte, NC
I used the brunette one and I love it.
I love this eyebrow pencil. I've used it for years!
LeslieS. from San Jose, Ca
I've been using this eyebrow pencil for years. I love the application and the brush. The color brunette works for my skin tone. It lasts long!
Great brow pencil
Michelle from MA
My brows are patchy and I dont like the dark marker looking brow and this gives me a natural look that not to dark and yet not to light, it matches perfectly.
Great Crayon Pencil
Folio from Houston, Tx
I've used them all and am sticking with this one as it is the perfect blonde and is a soft crayon but not too soft. Of course, L'Oréal and Lancôme are both Cosmair products - you pay for the name and packaging for Lancôme
I would but this product again.
Ade from Lincoln CA
Have sparse eyebrows...this fills in well.
Love this pencil
Sarah from Atlanta, GA
I like how natural this pencil looks. Sometimes it's a little tough to apply and you need to press down hard but it lasts a long time and I love the color
Very happy with this product. Will continue to purchase.
New Girl from Cedarburg, WI
I use the brow pencil daily. I just bought it and love it. I used to use Estee Lauder at 3 times the price. I find the quality to be very good.
I would buy this again.
Kim from Brevard,NC
Easy to apply.
Great eyebrow pencil
Margie from Detroit, Mi
Great for eyebrows and as an eyeliner!
Not crazy about it
Harley gal from chester, ny
It's hard to say I wouldn't recommend...it just doesn't work for me. Perhaps a slightly darker shade would be better? (even though my hair color is very blonde)
Iris from Moreno Valley, Ca
This is the only product I will put on my eyebrows! It's great & affordable.. I tried using high end products and always made my way back to this one!
I'm excited it covered my gray
Mm from San Antonio
My eyebrows are getting gray so pencil and brush is easy to use to cover and blend
Meg from NC
I have pretty light skin and light brown hair. This was supposed to be brunette, but the true color is for someone maybe strawberry blonde. Not good
Easy to use!
Janie from Palm Beach, FL
Easy to apply and remove. I love the Blonde color which gives my eyebrows just enough color to Naturally frame my eyes.
Great basic eyebrow pencil
B from Indiana
I have been using this product daily for several years and recommend it for anyone that wants to spend minimal time applying cosmetics.
Right color but wrong color
Jenny from Rancho Cucamonga
So I saw that L'Oreal came out with a new brow pencil and one of my favorite is the L'Oreal brow stylist definer and I use the shade dark brunette I bought the same shade in this new pencil however the shade was so off considering it was the same shade of the brow stylist definer so I had to return it and I don't think I'll be buying this again
As good as expensive brands
Smitten with the Mitten from Michigan
I've been using this for a couple years now. I like it as well if not better than the pricey brand names. Also, the brow brush is awesome.
Jane from Riverside California
FInally a wooden brow pencil I like!
Katiemom from St. Louis MO
I use this as both a brow pencil as well as something to give contrast to my eyelids when I don't feel like using eye shadow.
More product than most newer pencils
CJ from San Diego, CA
I use this pencil to fill in my brows. The dark brunette color isn't too dark.
Would not buy again
Na from Louisville KY
It will pass but prefer BENEFIT which I couldn't find and no one was there to ask
Anne from Tucson AZ
Easiest fine line pencil I have found in MANY years. Good quality and price.
Have used this product for several years!
Jan from Elk Grove, Illinois
A great eyebrow brush and pencil
JoJo from Louisville, KY
This was the best purchase. The brush shapes the eyebrow well, and the color blends in terrific.