Rated 3.22 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Feeling like an expert
I usually don't write reviews on products, but I do on services. I have tried every kind of brow pencil out there and have failed miserably at making them work for me. Either they wipe off easily, are not the right color, are too cakey, or are a mess to use. There are even times when with other products, I use the brush and it practically takes off the brow product. I found this is be amazing and I'm really impressed. It goes on well, and really does stay for the day. It's pretty easy to apply and the brush smooths it out but does not undo the work put into getting my eyebrows on.
Most Helpful Critical Review Pulled six of my brow hairs out!
I went to the store to try this brow on in shade honey, and it was so dry! It pulled six of my hairs out. I am so furious! It's not soft enough to glide without damaging. I am glad I don't have to return. I can't buy this product and will never try it again. I have the hairs on a tissue that stuck to the pencil as evidence. This item should be discontinued. I am so angry! If you own this use a moisturizer first! Everything in the photo is bareMinerals. Dahlia barePro vegan on lips.
Reviewed by 97 customers Love!
Lyndzi from UT
I absolutely love it! I was on the hunt for an eyebrow color that matched my hair a little better & this delivered! It's easy to apply & stays all day! I am excited to try their other eyebrow products! It's a little more expensive, but definitely worth it!
I love this!! I've used this pencil for many months!
Abby from Kansas
It stays on all day, sometimes next day as well
Best brow pencil
Dana from New England
Love the texture and density of this pencil , it lasts all day on me even when I went swimming . Doesn't smudge and I love the spoolie on the end. Please don't stop selling this!
I Will Be Repurchasing This Forever!
Ele from New York
This is probably the best brow pencil I have ever used. Its too bad there are so many negative reviews due to a formal change. I love that it is mechanical so you not have to sharpen it, its always sharp. The tip is an oval shape so it fills in the brows quickly, but you can still be precise. My favorite thing about this pencil is how much of a natural and soft look it gives. even though there are only 4 shades your bound to find a color that suits you.
robin from Battleground, Indiana
I use it every day!
If brown hair, get brown eyebrows, Not red
FaithM from Scottsdale, AZ
It's the only pencil I have found that if your hair is brown, it is brown, not red. I dont have any brows due to chemo. I wear brown wigs and have tried a lot of different bow pencils. This one is the only one that gives me brown eyebrows. You might not have thought about it, but that is very important. Look in the mirror. If you are wanting brown eyebrows and using a different product on your them, I can almost bet they are reddish brown.
Beaching blonde hair matches perfectly
Danu7777 from Detroit, mi
I have tired so many brow liners. I have medium to thin brows and this pencil blends so naturally. The harder you press the thicker it goes. I lightly brush it on and it lasts for months on end. Many others brush off throughout the day, or they don't match naturally. This one is a great color match and the consistency gives the look of real brows.
The Powder Was Better
DesertChick from undisclosed
I've used this pencil for 4 months while having kept the powder version aside. There's a learning curve, if you will, to the pencil. I wanted to like this and if I have no other choice I'll buy it. But the powder is far superior, gives greater coverage, and is much easier and quicker to use.
I will definitely buy this eyebrow pencil again and again.
Laurie from Porterville, CA
I have sparce and very light eyebrows. This pencil is the right shade to coordinate with my skin and hair color, and to fill-in the brow area without making the brows look like they were drawn-in. This pencil is not hard, it has a firm, smooth and creamy texture that goes on evenly without leaving leaving those tiny flakes on the skin that other pencils often leave. I hardly ever participate in this kind of survey, but for this pencil I wanted to share how much I value it. This really is a great product. Buy it. You won't be disappointed.
I would buy again but this color is too light I need slightl
Janet from Florida
I like the product, the color is too light.
I purchase this on a regular basis
Shive from Indiana
I use this daily to fill in and cover the gray in my brows. I use a light hand when applying to get the natural look that I like. With the brush on the end it is easy to blend!
Eunice from Naples, FL
Like the product but can't use this one.
Ang from Michigan
I love this pencil, goes on smooth and it stays on all day long
Not a brow powder replacement at all
Jen S from undisclosed
Why take away the brow powder?! It's so much better than this pencil! Please bring it back. I'm a loyal bare minerals gal, and don't want to have to get something else from a different company.
Please bring back the brow powder
emupdog from Houston, TX
Like many of the others, I tried this pencil because they discontinued the brow powder I've been using since around 2006. It was horrible and in no way compared to the powder. The color was uneven and took many passes to apply. I get so many compliments on my eyebrows when I use the brow powder. I would always tell them where they could get eyebrows like mine.... until now. Please, please listen to your customers and bring back the eyebrow powder. I will have to shop elsewhere, since what you have to offer will not do.
Kim from Great Falls, VA
Use it everyday and love it!
Bring back the brow powder
Babs917 from Upland, CA
I bought this because the powder was discontinued. Knowing how good BE products are, I figured it was a safe bet. I was wrong. The pencil doesn't apply evenly and the color is definitely not the right one for me (I purchased Chestnut and have med brown brows).
Bring back the powder
SO279 from Des Plaines, IL
Every time you discontinue the powder, someone says "try this new product, you'll love it". Wrong wrong wrong. If we're only left with one brow product to choose from, at least make it a good one. No amount of video watching will create a brow that looks as natural as the powder. If this is my only choice, I choose to go elsewhere instead of wasting my money.
Best Brow Pencil
KS84 from undisclosed
I'm surprised at the amount of negative reviews, but to each their own. For me, this has been the best brow pencil, and I've tried a ton! It checks all the boxes. the formula is just right, with the perfect amount of wax and powder consistency. I never have to drag against my skin, yet it never wipes away or disappears until I use my makeup remover. It blends perfectly into my I brow hairs. It looks completely natural in my sparse/"bald" spots. And the best part of all for me is the color. I have dark brown almost black hair with light/medium skin. Many brown shades of pencils are too red, even the "neutral" tones. However the shade "Cocoa" is exactly what works for my brows and against my skin (where I want zero redness)!
Does not stay on eyebrows.Easily rubs off.
Beauty from Chicago IL
Goes on ok but does not stay on.
Bring back the Brow Powder!!!!!!!!
MelBean from Beaverton
I am so angry that you keep discontinuing the Brow Powder! It is the only thing that works for my brows and still looks natural. And why do you keep doing it without warning. I would have tried to stock up. Bring it back, please. Pencils never work for me. Now I have to change to another company. I have been using Bare Minerals for twenty years. This infuriates me.
Where is the brow powder?!?!
Pezhead from Virginia
Not natural looking at all. Dry and very awkward to apply. I love bare minerals, and am very disappointed in this product.
JJLMT from Ohio
I went out on a whim
And tried the brow pencil in Honey. I am
Blonde and I'm beyond disappointed. The color is terrible, it's more of a shade for those with red hair. It's dry, doesn't glide and over all looks terrible. I won't be buying this again, and would greatly appreciate a refund!!
I need more brow powder
suga from columbia mo
how do I find more brow powder? I have been using it since 2008!
Bring back the brow powder
Drogie from Louisiana
The ONLY one that is great and works for me is the brow powder. Why why why do you keep discontinuing the powder and without any warning do I could have at least stocked up on it.