Product Reviews Rated 4.03 out of 5 stars
558 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review From Scraggly to Perfection My eyebrows are always a big mess and no matter how often I trim they grow so fast. This product is great. I can fill in the random bald patches and tame the beast! Attaching my before and after. Not the best pic but you get the idea.
Most Helpful Critical Review Wish I could give this a -5 I purchased this a few weeks ago with high hopes this would work well. I had dark yet little eybrows so I fill them in and this literally just makes a mess. I draw out the tail of my brow which is fine. I go over with the gel and it puts clumps in my eyebrows. I use an eyebrow brush lightly and somehow not only does the gel smudge but the pencil smudges and i have to draw over again. Having to take out the clumps relinemy brow and keep cleaning around it to define is not worth this. When I first opened the product the pencil was thicker then i hoped so i have to keep sharpening plus its small and the wand part was extremly clumpy and thick. Would not suggest to anyone.
Reviewed by 558 customers Great product 4
Sarah from Indiana
The blonde color actually matches unlike similar products. The brow gel isn't my favorite, but does the job!
Good Product, Great Formula, Awesome Price! 5
Adorable Beauty Lover from Traverse City, MI
Title says it all really.
It's got a great color ( blonde) & it has a good formula 5
Sarah from Utah
It works great
I buy this over and over! 5
Crepusculo from Michigan
I use this pencil every day. It is quick and easy to use and looks so natural! Love!!!
Love this product! 4
haley from easton, Ct
love this product!!
I continue to buy - 5
Glamour wannabe from WI
Great color selection - I have difficulty with most shades (blonde but wish definition) - this fills the bill.
Same reliable product I expect......
I keep buying- as good as the more expensive brands
Brunette 5
beautyjunkie from Los Angeles, CA
I love this pencil, I've been using this one for 7 years. I used to use MAC Spiked and switched to this one because the color was a perfect match that I still haven't seen anywhere else. The size of the pencil allows for ease when filling in the eyebrows. No goofs or mistakes either. I have fair, oily skin and I get about a good 10 hours of wear before my eyebrows need a touch-up. The pencil isn't creamy it has a texture that gives great staying power. I hoard these pencils and have about 10 at home on any given day. Give it a try and if it doesn't work for you, then there's more for me!
Love this product. The best brow pencil I've ever used 5
Jo from Plattsburgh NY
Stays on all day
Great brow pencil 5
ExtremeT from Modesto, Ca
I've used this brow pencil for years & I absolutely love it. I don't use the gel on a daily basis but I do use it if I'm doing full blown makeup. I like the color varieties, I use dark blonde when my hair is lighter & Med brown when I go dark. This is my go to eyebrows!!!!
No 1
Rose from Lansing MI
It took the product back. It was dry, did not go on smoothly. I exchanged it for Benefit Gimme Brow which is a far superior product.
Not the worst but don't waste your money 2
Alia from Hanover, PA
This product was fine until the pencil needed sharpened and then the wood broke and splintered repeatedly. The color payoff in the gel isn't worth the limited use you'll receive from the pencil and both products are incredibly small.
Easy to apply. Looks natural. 5
Crepusculo from Michigan
Use every day. Looks natural. Easy to apply.
Convenient 5
GA Newbie from Atlanta GA
My brows need a filler and coverup. My brows are starting to thin out, so I need a pencil for those spots and my gray hairs need a touch up. Brow Fantasy is super convenient because I don't have to go digging for two products. Plus, it is part of the Colorstay family, so that means it stays on. I have other brow products, but I reach for this one most of the time.
I love this product! 5
Crpusculo from Michigan
Looks so natual, not "painted." Soft and natural color.
I buy this over and over again 5
Alex from Geneva Il
Eye brow liner, filler
Wasn't thrilled by it. 1
BLAKE from California
Wouldnt buy again. Maybe if they sold the gel separate but the pencil was garbage.
The pencil side 4
Melissa from Florida
I wish Revlon would make this without the gel. I run out of the pencil way too fast, and because you can't sharpen it all the way, you have even less product to use. I never empty out the gel tube, because I'm not that big of a fan. I keep buying it because I really love the pencil side. So, if they were make just the brow pencil and sell it separately, it would be awesome.
Love this color!!!! 5
Crepusculo from MI
Goes on easily and looks natural
Very good 4
Jeanne from The Villages FL
Works best for my eyebrow especially with wand but pencil is difficult to sharpen and doesn't last long.
Tames those brows 4
clrandbwr from Ft Myers, FL
The pencil fills in sparse areas and the gel tames unruly hairs. Works very well.
Nice for mature women. 3
El from Alabama
Not bold like many brow colors are. Soft and neutral, more appropriate for mature brows.
LOVE THIS PRODUCT EASY TO USE 5
Sammi from Biloxi, MS
EASY APPLICATION
Love This Brow Pencil 4
Bigbandss from Webster, NY
I love this brow pencil. I use the dark blonde color. The best thing about this pencil is that it is soft and glides on my brows very easily. I don't need to use the gel, so I feel that I'm paying for something I don't use to get the pencil part I like. I wish they would make a full size pencil with the same consistency without the gel. I hope they don't ever discontinue this product because it is the only brow pencil that is gentle enough to use on my sensitive 67 year old brows.
Great Brow Pencil 5
Virgo18 from Westerville, OH
Use every day!
Best Pencil I've Ever Used 5
makeupqueeen from New York
Im a blonde so filling in eye brows are tough because you never want them to be too dark and unatural, or too light and not noticeable....This eye pencil is amazing. You can apply as much coverage to your brow as you want. The best part about this product though, is the gel side. Once youve filled in your brows with the pencil, you can then go over it with the gel, which smooths out your brows and keeps them in place. I go all day without a single strand of eye brow hair our of place. Its definitely better than the other brands I have used such as Benefit and L'Oreal. LOVE LOVE LOVE this pencil.
