Product Reviews Rated 4.2 out of 5 stars
64 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I really love this stuff! My normal brow product has always been Benefit's Gimme Brow. Right as a decided it was time for repurchase, I noticed that they had stopped producing it. In need of a new brow product ASAP, I found this guy with pretty good reviews. I absolutely love this stuff! It truly sets my brows all day and is cheaper than my used-to-bo go to product! Now Benefit has brought back the Gimme Brow, but honestly, I live this so much, I haven't even considered buying it again. I bought the shade "light" for my medium Ash brown hair, for colour reference. Something worth mentioning, the colour is the tube is a shade lighter than than the actual product. Keep that in mind when purchasing a color. My one minor draw back with the product would be the spoily. The brush is nice and thin, which I love; but, it's a touch too long and a bit flimsy. So, if you do push on the wand while applying, it will slightly bend the brush. It can be bent back into shape with no issues, though.
Most Helpful Critical Review Wand bends easily The formula is pigmented and leaves your brows kinda stiff, which I like. However the wand isn't stiff enough and bends rather easy however while applying it. My eyebrow hairs aren't short so I have to be extremely careful when applying it so I don't get any product on my foundation. Since the wand bends easily, I can't comb the product through my eyebrows as much as I'd like so I end up having to use another brow gel to comb everything through.
Reviewed by 64 customers loved it! 5
btsgurl11 from arizona
it's been so long that this has been out of stock.. pls restock this!! it's my favorite ðŸ˜
BEST drugstore brow gel 5
Syl from Boston,MA
literally the BEST drugstore brow gel there is. I hope elf never discontinues or changes it. I tell anyone who will listen that had sparse brows to purchase this. No cons at all
Great product! 5
Sarina from Houston
I was very surprised to find a product that worked so great at that price. Stays on and really gives my brows that feathered look.
I love this. 4
Fizzy from Indianapolis
I agree that the wand could be better, however I love how small the bristles are and the formula is fantastic. I've tried a few different clear brow gels and the best was Givenchy Mister Brow Groom, and that stuff is pricey. This is less than a third of the cost of Givenchy with a formula that holds up well in comparison. New holy grail.
Save you $$ 1
JRRMPAMO from Queens, NY
Bent the second time I used it. What?! How?! Flimsy and doesn't do anything. Will not repurchase.
Wand bends easily 3
Rose from Victorville, CA
The formula is pigmented and leaves your brows kinda stiff, which I like. However the wand isn't stiff enough and bends rather easy however while applying it. My eyebrow hairs aren't short so I have to be extremely careful when applying it so I don't get any product on my foundation. Since the wand bends easily, I can't comb the product through my eyebrows as much as I'd like so I end up having to use another brow gel to comb everything through.
Exactly what I wanted!! 5
Allie from Kent, Ohio
I use this brow setter either with or without any brow products. It's really good for those days when I wanna be more natural! They make my brows look fuller and they stay in place with the gel!
Favorite brow gel 5
Masen from Virginia
I don't like to wear heavy, glam, or super visible makeup. This stuff is perfect for making my light brown/dark blonde brows a bit darker, to match my hair color! It doesn't make them feel too crunchy, and lasts all day even through heavy sweating from working out. I highly recommend this brow gel! In my opinion it's way better than Boy Brow, because it's more sheer and natural-looking. The ELF clear brow gel in this formula is also great. My hair is dark brown, so I get the darkest shade of this formula, usually.
Would not recommend 1
Erin from Mableton, GA
The wand on this is thin and long and hard to do much of anything with. The only thing this product has going for it is that it's sheer enough to not make a mess but it really doesn't show up much to begin with.
Just ok 3
Naomi from Indiana
This would probably be great for someone with thick brows, however mine are fair and sparse and it was too sheer for me. It works as a clear gel, but when they say sheer they mean SHEEEER.
Not crazy about the spooley 2
Erin from Mableton, GA
The pigmentation is sheer, as stated in the name, but the spooley is way to big to use on sparse brows. I have to fill in some places still as the formula is watery. I prefer a much smaller spooley for brow gel.
Fave for light touch 5
MonstaX from California
I wanted this for my front brow hairs and it's perfect. It doesn't give that over done crunchy feeling like the Anastasia ones.
don't waste your time 1
fm from chicago
i know this says sheer but it doesn't give ANY color at all.don't recommend.also I'm pretty sure it broke me out.
favorite eyebrow gel! 5
ham from Delaware
I love how this applies and the brush is slim. I don't need to press hard just a gentle sweep across the eye brows once I've filled them in. Keeps them and place and the price is affordable!
Okay! 4
Britt from Nc
It works fine but I don't like the brush it is too flimsy!
Don't Buy!! 3
heather432019 from Texas
I was very disappointed in this product. It was really watery. Not good at all and the wand was horrible.
Great Product 5
Sha from NY
I use this as a mascara primer. It works great. It grabs all the lashes, and dries down well. I was worried that it would be watery, but it wasn't. I was the perfect consistency, not dry.
just don't 1
fm from coppell
when this means sheer, it doesn't give any color at all.the wand is really long and skinny and it makes my brows look really slicked back and not that fluffy kinda look i wanted
Awesome formula AWFUL applicator 3
Baylee Ray from Abilene, TX
The wand on this stuff is awful. It is too long and doesn't brush through the eyebrows well. I attempted to remedy this by cutting the applicator shorter, but once I did that all the brush hairs fell off rendering it unusable. DO NOT BUY THIS!
Good Stuff 5
Brina from Ohio
I'm a simple brow gal so my experience may not be another's.
I've never had a problem with this stuff. It doesnt make my eyebrows all crusty, it blends in well. Bristles are short but I honestly use this before anything else so I'm not sure why the shortness is an issue for some women. I just use powder fills for my brows so it takes the pigment well. Holds great, and everything comes off later nice and smooth.
Not a good brush or formula 2
colleen from Detroit Michigan
Too long of a brush and the bristles are super short. The gel formula becomes flaky later. Couldn't get my brows to look textured without getting too slick.
Keeps Brows in Place! 5
Jazzmine from Texas
My brow hairs are constantly moving around and this keeps my brow hairs in place all day!
E.L.F. Does it again! 5
ClearskinGoalz@42 from Alabama
I love this brand's ability to offer a great product that always blows me away for a price that beats the rest. Don't get me wrong—I've splurged on brow pomade packed with fine essential oils, tried powdery concoctions that made me want to give up on eyebrows altogether, and overdone it on grow serums that failed. Turns out, all I need is this little skinny wand and thirty seconds later—tadda—good brows, not overdone. If you are light handed with the eyes and brows like me, you will more likely appreciate this product for its accentuating abilities. It is not capable of producing a perfect tightlined, penciled-in look. It will accentuate any browline well though, making your existing brow look fuller and keeping it in place.
My fav 5
Valpalthegal from South Carolina
I have always had a real struggle which my brows and this has amazing colors that actually match
a must for thick brows 5
keisha from alaska
my brows are thick, full, and pitch black so i'm kinda scared to use pencils or pomades to shape them. i bought the clear one, tinted gels are usually too warm and light for me, and it works like a charm. it's even better than my old ride-or-die revlon one! and cheaper! highly recommend for my fellow black haired folk
