Rated 3.85 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Good buy I would not buy again
This mascara is great but it's honestly no different than any other Loreal mascara which are all really good. I normally use the Loreal Telescopic mascara but thought I'd try this one. They're really not much different in my opinion but I feel like the Telescopic gives me slightly longer lashes. This one is still great though! It doesn't clump or flake and gives me the right amount of volume. The only downside is that the tube and wand handle are very bulky and feels awkward to hold while I'm applying. I'm used to the skinny long tube from the Telescopic mascara. It's nice to try something new but I'll definitely go back to my ol' favorite.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not what I expected...
I wanted to love this mascara BUT it makes my eyes so itchy!! At first I thought it was my seasonal allergies kicking in but I tested by not using it for a couple of days and tried it again.and YUP - this is the one that makes my eyes so itchy! I also had my daughter try it out for a couple of days - and same thing happened to her. not sure the formula they used on this particular type. I use the Voluminous L'oreal mascara brand and never had any issues. Besides that I really didn't notice any huge/dramatic difference on my eyelashes - definitely not Bambi :(
Reviewed by 88 customers Love
Brianap from P
Been loving this mascara! I got so many compliments and wow it really makes my lashes look great! I will be repurchasing for sure
CeCe from Illinois
This mascara is so so good. I have the waterproof version and there is no smudging or transfer what so ever! I already have long lashes but I've never liked the clumpy look. This does such a good job of lengthening and darkening which really opens your eyes. There is no clumsiness even after a lot of coats! You can really build this formula up too. Also the name is super cute , so you can't go wrong by this!!
This was a nice surprise. It goes on sooo smooth, and easy.
Gr8 from Huntington Beach
I can't find anything to dislike. I've tried many mascaras. Many times disappointed. Not this time. I've already shared the product with family and friends.
CA from Riverside
I'm always on a search for a good mascara & so far this is the best one I have found! I love it! 💞
Slaying the game with another 🏆 mascara.....
DLC from Newport Beach, CA
Well, L'Oréal, you did it again! I already love Lash Paradise but I decided to purchase this one in the shade EXTRA NOIR and this really is a very dark black, inky, mascara! I LOVE IT! No clumps, separates the lashes, easy to remove, lashes hold a curl..... What's not to love? 💕💕💕 I have a lot of high end mascaras that this one puts to shame. WINNER 🏆💯
It's a great Mascara!
Ms. T's picks from H Town
I will buy it again
Buying this again and agai
CW from Jacksonville
Like this for curl, to super lengthening though
Z from Pasadena
The wand is difficult to work with in my opinion. I can't separate my lashes the way I would like with this mascara and also takes me much longer to put it on because of how it clumps up. This also flakes like crazy so I have raccoon eyes by mid day.
It was rare the time I felt I had a good mascara day with this one.
Jen from New Orleans
Great mascara at a great price!
Steph from Va
I love this mascara. It is my new favorite. I do think the price is a little high for a drugstore one.
Ashley from Colorado
I totally bought this for the packaging, but it actually makes my lashes look really nice and not clumpy. Didn't rate it 5 stars because it does flake a bit after a while, and it doesn't last as long as some other mascaras I've tried. Definitely a good drugstore option nonetheless!
Gigi from Ohio
We all know it. Mascara formulations don't really vary that much. It's all about the BRUSH! This mascara is the first one I've used that actually does what it claims. If you want your lashes separated, defined, lengthened, with zero clumping, this one is for you. I hope they never take it off the market but I'm stocking up just in case. Try this one! You'll love it!
Loved it more than Lash Paradise
Sarah from Thousand Oaks
This brush is really great for the lower lash line and I like how non clumpy the brush keeps my lashes overall. Its not a natural look but its very pretty. I wore this mascara for 8 hours and had no issues with flaking or smudging.
Extra Noir is amazing!
Bananawaffles from Texas
Makes my eyelashes long and fluttery. I have such a wide eyed, dramatic look when I wear this.It doesn't flake or smear. HG mascara! Thank you L'Oréal!
Love this mascara!
Vicki H. from Trophy Club, TX
Love the formula and the applicator!
Gibby from Boca raton,FL
Very cakey and doesn't brush well. Made my eyelashes look stuck together.
Warning! Made my eyelashes fall off : (
Tiffany from Los Angeles
I'm loyal to my Lash Paradise mascara and figured that I'd try something new since I was won over by their marketing. After using it a few times, it caused my lashes to continuously fall off. The product itself was very difficult to remove at the end of the day, and keep in mind it's not waterproof. I was really disappointed and threw my bottle away. I switched back over to my Lash Paradise tube.
Don't buy it at all
Russian vixen from Oregon
Awful. Stupid wand. EXTREMELY watery. And of course transfers like crazy on upper and lower lids. Gross
Not worth it.
Gera from Tx
This mascara is definitely not worth the money. It only provides color but it clumps up and doesn't add volume. Go with the maybelline ones!
I wanted to love it, however...
Fetch from Kalispell
One of the most difficult mascaras I've ever worked with. Brush is fat in the wrong way, plastic and clunky, and the formula is clumpy yet watery???
Not crazy about it
NatVega from El Paso, TX
I was a little disappointed because of all the rave reviews but I wasn't impressed. It didn't make my lashes pop like I was hoping for.
its my new favorite!
BURTY from ohio
Why isn't there more hype over this mascara? Its AWESOME! My favorite mascara is Benefit Roller lash.. and in my opinion this is a dupe for it. It separates and lengthens lashes wonderfully. Its also a more wet formula which I prefer. AND it is easily washed off with no scrubbing necessary. I'll buy it as long as its made!
Will by again
Costos from AZ
Seen alot of negative reviews but also some good obes thought id gove it a try and i have to say im glad i did. I love this mascara it doesn't flake or make my lashes stick together.
I love it!! Long beautiful lashes!!
angie from MN
I love it!! Long beautiful lashes!!
Love this mascara
KKL from Derby, KS
I love this mascara. It goes on great and washes easily off.