Product Reviews Rated 4.16 out of 5 stars
87 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I will be gift this The shadow blend soooooo nicely! This is a lot of kick up but I'm not bothered.
Most Helpful Critical Review Really wanted to like this I swatched this in store and loved the colors! Great pigment, soft and creamy. It seemed easy to apply....on my hand. The ingredients seemed good too, plus no talc! Grabbed one and was so excited to show it to my sister. But when I opened it up there was eyeshadow everywhere! A lot of fall out. I got it to be my new go-to travel eyeshadow, but with it already being so messy and I hadn't even swiped it once, I just couldn't do it. I had to return it. So sad! The color were beautiful though! It could defintely work for someone who isn't always on the go and doesn't mind a little fall out.
Reviewed by 87 customers Did not receive 1
RSchultz from Ohio
Never received this order and had to re oi rder at my own expense
Beautiful colors! 5
PrincessPam63 from Rapid City, SD
Love these collections - I might have to buy them all!
Gorgeous Mattes! 4
JEFSCHR from Wisconsin
Very very beautiful colors and so easy to use!
Great 5
Mia from California
Love the pigmentation of each color.
Great travel-friendly palette 5
Monica from California
Super pigmented and blendable. Great everyday shades. It does have a decent amount of kick-up in the pans, but it's easily avoided by not slamming your brushes into the shadows. The brush that comes with it isn't my absolute favorite for blending but it is def functional and I do use it. I also have the Sassy Siennas palette and I've tried the Marvelous Mauves--both are fantastic quality as well. Highly recommend.
Best everyday shadows 5
Tonias84 from Sacramento
This set gives you the best everyday wearable colors. All the shades to make any eye look that goes with browns. The quality outstanding and worth it. All mattes can't go wrong.
Pretty colors, too messy! 2
Vala from Mi
The colors of this palette are very nice, but the fall out is ridiculous. I feel like each time I use this, more than half the product ends up on my face or counter, I don't see it lasting that long.
Beautiful Browns! 5
Dalys from Arizona
This looks very sexy on the eyes! I love cherrywood it's my favorite color in the palette. It's great for everyday use!
Product from boxy charm 3
RDALG from Texas
Still on the fence with this pallete. The amount of kick back is insanely messy and makes me not want to use it.
love it!! 5
alba from Tx
love this palette!!
Gorgeous colors! 5
Beautyinfaith84 from Illinois
Received the Baked Browns in my Boxycharm subscription and I immediately fell in love! I have never used shadows that were so pigmented yet buttery and easy to blend. The colors work beautiful together. They are long lasting however do have some fall out. The packaging it sleek and luxe feeling. I highly recommend!
These shadows are amazing BUT 4
Iambriseyda from Los Angeles
There's a lot of fall out that's my only problem. Other than that it's bomb!!
Amazing staying power! 5
Florence from Ontario, Canada
I've never had an eyeshadow last so long on my lids. I put either shade in my crease, without primer, and by the end of my work day, it's still on, full colour. This beats all other pallets I own! I have blue eyes, so this mixture of brown neutrals of perfect for me! I am so glad I received it in my boxycharm box. The fact that it lasts all day make my think I have no reason to even reach for anything else! It's truly spectacular.
Takes Patience 4
Lauren from Little Rock, AR
I'm in love with how well everything blends and it doesn't require building and building to get it to show up but I have to be so careful not to bump the palette or drop it or lay it down too hard. It is dusty and crumbles very easily. It makes a mess everywhere. When I tap off my brush dust covers everything!
Beautiful colors but.....! 2
Gabygaby000 from Chicago
They. Crumble. So. Easily!
They are the most delicate eyeshadows ever they will crumble and break...not cool Dose of Colors. They're so beautiful but already 2.5 of the 5 are gone and I haven't used this palette all that much! A real bummer
Dusty! 1
Shadowqueen from Downey, Ca
These eyeshadows are literally dusty. Every time you pick up product with a brush this stuff seemed to to just fall apart everywhere. I'm sure that you will run out of this product quick because you lose almost the entire shadow that sheds everywhere. Very disappointed with the price. It was made poorly.
Worth Wait 5
Shanna P. from Vancouver, Wa
I have been eyeing this product for awhile. It spoke to me, but I couldn't ever condone the cost. However, I finally bought it as a mother's day present for myself. I ave literally used this almost every single day. I'm not big into colorful eye makeup, and pretty much wear my makeup the same way each day. So for me this was a perfect fit. I love it. There can be fallout out, but it is a soft formula so there isn't much. It is pigmented without being overly pigmented. Which makes it really easy to work with.
Good for Travel 5
Bee from Los Angeles, CA
My go to palette! Easy for travel! Literally all you need in this small palette!!
I might consider repurchasing...hmm 3
Jojo4567 from Nj
I loved the colors, size, and pigmentation from this palette. The shadows are super soft and blend easily. My true con is how soft they are. This palette fell into my sink and one of the shadows crumbled everywhere. It's super fragile. Otherwise, these are a truly beautiful matte formula. You can tell that with a brush the shadows kick up a ton of powder. Anyways, still on the fence as two of my favorite colors broke and I'm not sure if I'll replace it because I'm afraid that traveling with this palette might not work.
More powdery than Pretty Cool 3
LS from New Mexico
I love my Pretty Cool palette, and really wanted the Baked Browns. Some reviews talked about the shadows being extremely powdery, which I didn't find with the Pretty Cool palette. The Baked Browns is another story, the colors are beautiful, but it is extremely powdery. I opened it up for the first time and there was already powder on the mirror and shadow on the plastic. I barely (and I mean barely) tapped the brush in and the fallout was excessive. I'm guessing the differences in colors have something to do with the differences in formulations. Long story short, I will keep for travel, but am not happy with the amount of fallout (which has never been an issue for me in the past). Just be warned.
Love the colors 4
Rose from Sterling Heights
Beautiful colors but they are very powdery. I still do like them regardless
It falls apart 1
Beth from Minnesota
Beautiful colors but I completely falls apart after like two uses because it's so powdery. Not pleased
Really wanted to like this 2
Bambi from Temple, Ga
I swatched this in store and loved the colors! Great pigment, soft and creamy. It seemed easy to apply....on my hand. The ingredients seemed good too, plus no talc! Grabbed one and was so excited to show it to my sister. But when I opened it up there was eyeshadow everywhere! A lot of fall out. I got it to be my new go-to travel eyeshadow, but with it already being so messy and I hadn't even swiped it once, I just couldn't do it. I had to return it. So sad! The color were beautiful though! It could defintely work for someone who isn't always on the go and doesn't mind a little fall out.
A lot of Kick up 2
Mserra5 from IL
I really wanted to like this palette. The colors were perfect for daily wear and it was the perfect size for travel....but the kick up is awful. If you dip your brush in the pan, the shadow goes everywhere instantaneously. Positively, the pigmentation is good, but I am sad to say that I am not keeping this palette.
Perfect every day palette 5
Sky from Saginaw, MI
Way easier to blend than I expected. It had a bit of fall out though
