Rated 3.29 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Most Helpful Critical Review Reviewed by 7 customers Great formula!
Samm from Killeen, TX
This eyeliner has a great formula and stays on all day but i'd recommend using your own brush the applicator is a bit harsh on my eyelids.
It burns while drying, tip is abrasive & not waterproof
Lucy from Colorado Springs, CO
Maybe I am allergic, I don't know. When I used this waterproof liquid eyeliner it burned for a minute while it dried. The applicator felt abrasive although it could have been the burning sensation causing the discomfort. It didn't burn anymore after it dried. When I went outside the windy conditions made my eyes water and this waterproof liquid eyeliner came off in flaky pieces. I had black flakes around my eyes and you could see a trail of tears where my eyes were watering from the wind.
applicator is terrible
Casey from Brookfield
product itself is good but you can't get it on with the stuff plastic applicator. waste of money
Definitely on my must have list.
Casino gal. from Laughlin
Daily use. Working in a casino, this eyeliner is a must have.
Flakier than me
Flaky Girl from Utah
The applicator tip is the thin, loose, bendy kind, so right off the bat it's a little challenging trying to build up winged liner on your eyes. The shape of the tip is weird too. It's sort of tapered but then there's a square-ish part at the end? Weird. Once it dries, it feels exactly like your eyelids do when you put adhesive on them and it hardens. After about 6-8 hours, I noticed tons of flakes all over my cheeks beneath my eyes from it flaking. This might be good in a pinch if you think you're going to be crying at work, but it'll end up on your cheeks in the end either way.
Twitchy from California
I bought this for my trip to Cancun, this didn't even smudge. The heat and humidity there hit DIFFERENT, it was like being in an oven, but my eyeliner didn't even FLINCH.
Worth the Price
danyelxnicole from Harrisburg, PA
The formula of this eyeliner is great- dries fast, it's matte and it goes on the eye well. My only complaint is the applicator- it's hard and awkward to work with. If that could be fixed this eyeliner would be my new holy grail.