Rated 3.99 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review LOVE
OMG this eyeliner is seriously so good. I bought it after I heard one of my favorite youtubers mention that it didn't run on her eyes throughout the day. I have used Maybelline gel eyeliner for years and just assumed that all eyelines would wear off throughout the day and run in the corner of my eyes. NOT THIS EYELINER. If you have problems with your eyeliner running and wearing off throughout the day you need this in your life. I wore if for over 8 hours and it lasted, didn't run, and stayed super dark. LOVE THIS PRODUCT
Most Helpful Critical Review Potentially Good Product with Awful Packaging
Decided to try this product out after some research and positive recommendation. It's a potentially great makeup find especially for the price. Easy application, beautiful color--I ordered mocha--but the packaging is difficult to handle. When I first received the product the lid was hard to remove even with careful hands. After only the second time opening it, the lid slid across the tip of the applicator getting it all over my hand and wasting a fair amount of product. Unfortunately, since this is an online item only, I'd have to wait a minimum of 10 days to get a new pencil. Even after frequent use the pencil lid still sticks and is difficult to remove. I'm not sure whether this is a singular event or if all the applicators for this product are alike, but regardless, it's very frustrating.
Reviewed by 73 customers Oozing bloodshot eyes
LB from GA
I love the black and mocha. I bought the velvet within an hour my eyes was oozing and bright red. I also tried one more time because I had also used a new mascara. This time I did not use the mascara. Within an hour the same thing.I immediately was it off. I'm on my second day of stinging bloodshot eyes. Not sure if it is just me allergic to the color in this brand or if there is a problem with the formula of this specific color. I have used other brands in this color and never had this reaction. Just wanted others to know incase something is up with this product
No longer disappointed
Marimarla75 from New York
Ok so I realized that you can sharpen the pencil with a sharpener, I do like how it easily glides and nicely lines eyes. I would definitely recommend
So good but...where's the retractor!?!
FG from NY
It's so creamy and great, but THERE'S NO RETRACTOR! Once you use the point there's no way to bring up the eyeliner when you need more, so disappointed.
Excited at first then disappointed
Maria from New York
So the eyeliner is good.. I like how it easily glides and has good pigmentation however how am I supposed to continue using it once the initial tip is used up? They need to either make it retractable or in a pencil form that can be sharpened cause if you expect me to buy another one once that tiny tip is used up then you're mistaken.. you're shortchanging your customers
Terri from Washington DC
A tiny stub sticks out of the top. As far as I can figure out there is no way to advance it or sharpen it to continue using it.
Best long-lasting eyeliner on the market
Eyeliner Queen from TN
I have tried cheap, expensive, hundreds of eyeliners that won't run and especially will stay on my water line. This does everything I want it too and I don't have to check all day. I am confident it looks good for hours, if not all day.
I would not try this product again
Tkat from Dallas, Texas
Obviously, easily damaged
Love this eyeliner
Victoria from Chicago, IL
I have a really hard time with eyeliners as skin around my eyes is oily so nothing lasts for more than a few hours before disappearing or smudging all over. I've tried everything- from drugstore to high end. Previously, I could only use a high end brand with a $26 price tag. I tried this one on a whim and can't believe how good it is! It stays put and doesn't run and smudge all over. It's still on when I go to remove my makeup at the end of the day! My only gripe is 2 out of the 3 times I've tried to buy it, it's out of stock.
Love this eyeliner, so easy to put on
Karla from Dallas, Tx
Love this eyeliner and is pretty affordable
My favorite eyeliner and the only one for the last 3 years
Logansmommaa from Poughkeepsie, new York
Only eye liner I have used for the last 3 years because I love it so much , it's only done fall is it's not waterproof
Love this eyeliner!
Lorijw16 from Milwaukee, WI
If you have problems with your eyeliner running during the day, you need to try this eyeliner! This is the best eyeliner I have found. Stays put all day long! I just wish it came in more colors.
Labra from Orlando, FL
Last brand I ever plan to buy! I got this in an ipsy bag in Mocha. I was thoroughly impressed. I line my lower waterline and it lasts all day-- doesn't run, no smudging, lasts all day. It even makes it through a full day working outside in Florida summer heat, and the 3pm rain shower. It is a kohl pencil and requires a sharpener once the point wears down. I usually need to use an eye makeup remover to fully remove it, but that's what you get with a quality waterproof eyeliner. I thought I had lost it on a vacation and was temporarily devastated that I would have to go back to the other brands I have. I have since found it and I'm much happier. I wish there were more colors and that I could get it in stores!
Best eyeliner ❤️
Lotus from MN
Best Quality with affordable price. Stays all day. I use black which is intense black and I love it. I use it everyday. ❤️
Probably the worst Liner I've ever purchased
Mishj from Texas
I purchased this liner in the Hope's that it worked well since it had hundreds of reviews. The liner arrived not only broken in the cap but after 2 days was as small as my pinky finger. The actual pencil,not the nib but the actual pencil was broken of in the cap, and after 2 days it was so small because I had to sharpen it all the way down to actual get the nib,there was barely any nib inside the pencil. Basically I paid for an almost empty pencil. I don't understand the great reviews,I'm starting to believe it's all fake reviews so ppl can waste their money on these products.
SL23 from Tennessee
I like to line my upper waterline and finding a pencil that 1) goes on smooth/opaque and 2) stays on is not easy. I loved the mocha color of this because it did those two things very well. So well that I used an entire pencil which may be a first. But it's been sold out for months so I decided to try the velvet and oh no. The color is great and it still applies and stays put well but I am definitely allergic to something in it. I thought the first time my eyes got red, gunky, and itchy it was just environmental allergies - it's happened before with no eyeliner. I waited a week and put it on again and within half an hour the exact same reaction. So if your eyes are sensitive I'd say this is not a good liner for you.
chighfill from Roberta ga
This product is great
stays on all day and night, no matter what, doesn't smear
Babs57 from Port Richey FL
i clean houses and offices, i needed an eyeliner that stays on no matter what i am doing. If i have a late work night and fall asleep before i can wash my face, the eyeliner is still on. it doesn't smear when sweating
It does not twist to get more product!
Anna from Wichita, KS
This eyeliner is very pigmented but it will transfer onto your waterline. Also, the bottom does not twist so once I am done with the initial liner tip exposed on top, I won't be able to use it anymore. Waste of money!
Good and Affordable
Future Makeup Artist < 3 from Somewhere near the city
Best eyeliner I've icee used thus far. Don't break, really creamy, and long wearing.
Very nice color last all day
Lily from Miami
Love it f
the price makes it imore attractive
The BEST EYELINER I HAVE EVER USED
Ashley h from Denver, CO
I received this in an Ipsy bag and was immediately blown away! This eyeliner applies so smoothly without tugging on our eyes! Super pigmented. And it LASTS ALL DAY! No smudging, so streaking. This stuff stays put, but washes off easily with cleanser. I had always been a black eyeliner wearer until I tried the Mocha. The Mocha color is super flattering especially for blue eyes and even makes me look more awake. I cannot believe the price. I have spent so much money looking for the best eyeliner. I am so glad I found this!
eye bombshell from San Francisco
A eyeliner that really stays on. As a bartender who works long shifts I don't have time to stop and reapply or clean smudges off. This eyeliner truly lasts.
Love but restock black please
Bri from Dalton Ga
I love it but I need y'all to restock on black ASAP
Cannot wait to try all the colors
AJ from ARIZONA
The Mocha color is my absolute favorite! One of the only eyeliners that does not transfer on my hooded eyelids and stays where I put it. Got it as a sample and will be buying a full size.
Christie from Whittier
I bought this thinking it would be long lasting but it's not. I use it because I'm trying to finish it. But I will not repurchase