Rated 2.98 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Works Well for Tightlining
I am ordering more of this eyeliner. It works really well as a tight liner, just don't expose too much of the product as it is very thin and will break off. The pencil in the liner has to be so thin to effectively tightline into the lashes. A drawback that I experience with every liner pencil is that it picks up any makeup you have on your eyelids, so the color appears to fade but it's really just that a thin coat of makeup got onto the pencil. I gently wipe it off with a tissue and the problem is solved. I'm going to try to remember to apply this liner before I put on my makeup, which should make the makeup transfer a non-issue. If I could give it 4.5 stars, I would.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not good for eyes GREAT for lips!
I had bought the gray expecting it to be really great but there was barely any payout on my waterline, and it was too stiff for my lash line. I tried it as a lipliner and it is AMAZING! So precise so I can finally line my lips well! Going to get other colors for this purpose. So 1 star for eyes but 5 stars for lips!
Reviewed by 57 customers No color on waterline
Rae from PA
Shows up well on my hand but I can't get it to apply to my waterline at all, will be returning
Tube was Empty!!
KLogs from St Joe MO
Tube was EMPTY
Good color payoff but not a smooth application
Walisa from NY
Great color payoff but it is hard to apply.
DON'T BUY IT!
Mollyolin from New York
I purchased this eyeliner a couple weeks ago as I was looking for a nude eyeliner to brighten up my eyes and idk what happened to them all but I can't find them anymore! Well I got it from then store and I first tested it on my hand as a swatch and was so excited! It was the perfect nude color for my skin tone, a fine point and SUPER waterproof (I tested it too). Weeeelllll I have tried it several times now and I cannot get it to draw on my waterline. The tip of the pencil is almost too hard, which hurts and it doesn't come off at all on my waterline. I am so disappointed!!
I love the thin line this liner makes.
Deb from IL
I use this eyeliner on my lower lash line. It's produces a thin line which I love. I do use a liquid liner on the top eyelid lash line but prefer this liner on the lower lash line.
Saff from Chicago
For something intended for tightlining, this eyeliner is very dry, not creamy, and not pigmented. No matter how many times I go over my waterline, it never gets super dark.
My top favorite
Naniki007 from Rancho Cucamonga, Ca
This is one of my all time favorite liner, it last all day, last thought a workout and the sauna after.
FrankieWww from Los Angeles
So disappointed in this product. Does not glide on easily and you have to apply heavy pressure against eyeliner just to attempt to get some on. The policy is no refunds for opened items, but, I called corporate received a check and was able to keep product.
Great for hooded eyes
AW123 from undisclosed
This product is great for drawing a thin layer of eyeliner on my hooded eye. Love it.
Use for Eyeshadow Setting
LMc from Virginia
I use a light eye liner in order to set my eyeshadow that I use as actual "eyeliner". This light color is perfect for me to get some of the lighter colors around my eyes to make them pop. It's not the best eyeliner to use every day (although there are other NYX liners I would recommend). But for what I use this for, im quite pleased.
Ally from Chicago
This product is a waste of money. It seems dry and does not glide on. The stick is so think it also easily breaks. When the product goes on, all it leaves is a faint gray residue. Disappointed, especially because other NYX products have been great!
Best tightliner ever
GA Cat Dog Girl from undisclosed
This is an excellent tight liner. The color stays all day and it didn't bother my sensitive eyes. There are so many eye liner pencils that I throw away after one use, but this is a keeper. I got navy and now I want to try more colors. I'm happy to find everything NYX here and give more of their excellent products a go.
NEVER WILL BUY THIS BRAND AGAIN!
Lani from Mount Vernon
While apply to my eye. The small part of the tip of pencil snapped of in my eye. Waa not pushing hard to every much pressure.
I would buy this again for sure.
fan for korean makeup from MA
I like this more than other brands' skinny eyeliners. This doesn't break as easy as other brands. It is easy to use. I use eye shadows to set my eyeliner anyway. It is long lasting.
The point beaks off every time I use it on my eyelid.To Dry!
Sharon from Pennsylvania
I would not recommend this product.I could only use it twice.
Returning this product
E from Illinois
Junk, returning this
EricaJamie08 from Morgantown
The regular eye liner pencil does so much more than this especially for the water line. This is hardly pigmented and tends to drag the skin
Dark Squirrel from Midwest
I'm not sure if maybe I received an old one, but it was very dry. Very little color came off onto my waterline, and the pencil kept breaking.
Tennisgal from Yadkinville
Loved the way this was easy to apply and easy to hold..
Excellent for Eyes & For Eyebrow Texture
Fancy Face from Los Angeles
I keep rebuying this item in Nude, I sometimes use it for eyeliner, sometimes to tighten my lips shape, but I mostly use it to create dimension on my eyebrows. You know, when you add color to your brows and they become a block of color? With this, I can add some light strokes to make the brows multi-dimesnional and more realistic. I just love it! The only thing is, I think it is a bit expensive, for the amount of product you get.
Very tight line
P. Burke from Madisonville
It's really small line so I have to go over a few times to get effect that I want. But I like the deep brown color
AD from Chicago
Does this weird clumping thing. I can't figure it out. I've tried it a couple of times, but I use it and then I've got clumps all over my eyelashes. Goes on creamy but somehow it clumps. Back to MJ liner.
Bex from VA
Works great, very easy to apply.
Skip on this NYX
LACF from NY
I wanted to love this after a You Tubers rave reviews. It tugs a lot when applying preventing a straight line. It does have a very small and precise stick but I think it could also break daily because of that.
Rachel from San Diego