Rated 3.75 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review not enough product
I love the packaging, I love the high coverage, it applied wonderfully, the finish is beautifully matte, it lasted all day for me and I experienced minimal creasing. It looked great under the eyes and it's ideal for spot concealing. It blended pretty easily, which usually I'll have a harder time blending high coverage concealers that are so matte. I think I also could've gone without setting it and I found a great color match for me. This would be great for more oily skin, this stayed matte longer than my other matte concealers for me and I have combo oily skin. I do think that those with normal skin could also like the matte finish, maybe those with dry skin would like it depending on what they prefer. I recommend swatching shades in stores if you can, the color range is a bit strange. Medium Light Warm was like two shades darker than Medium Neutral? It does dry down about half a shade darker once applied. My main complaint is the amount of product is so little for the price. You get almost triple this amount of product in the tarte shape tape. It's about half the product of the too faced born this way concealer, both of these a couple dollars less for one tube. I know it says there's more pigment so you have to use less, but I still found myself using pretty close to the same amount as any other concealer (excluding shape tape), so this would probably just run out twice as fast. It's a great product, just too expensive for how much you get.
Most Helpful Critical Review Shape Tape is better
I was so excited to get this after watching a few tutorials on this. Guys, it is TERRIBLE. I have normal skin, and normal under eyes (not too dry, not a ton of discoloration, not a ton of wrinkles). This looks SO BAD. My under eyes looked so dry. It literally looked like I had aged 10 years. I tried it with a different primer, I tried it with a different foundation. I tried it with a different setting powder. I used a damp sponge, I used a brush...NOTHING made this look good. Shape Tape is infinitely better, doesn't make me look dry (a problem I do not usually have), and has much better coverage. If you are stuck between the 2, go with the Shape Tape.
Reviewed by 252 customers Goes on beautifully
anonymous from undisclosed
It goes on so smoothly, and covers everything. It is great for anywhere you want it on your face. I do wish that they had a lighter shade, because I am incredibly pale and it wasn't quite light enough for my under eye, but it looks great and sets well.
A good buy!
anonymous from Anniston,AL
Good and lasting coverage! dries a little quicker then would like but still a good buy.
anonymous from undisclosed
It's a great concealer. Its little on dry side, I have o constantly use facial mist with.
Good coverage and staying power
Jenni53 from PA
This concealer covers well and stays put better than others. I just wish there was a better color match for me. The colors are either far too light or to orange.
Gorgeous coverage that stays put!!
anonymous from Ft Lauderdale, FL
Already purchased more!!! This is the real deal! Smooth and beautiful all day, even in the brutal Caribbean humid heat!
JJ from Alabama
Light weight. Full coverage. Goes on Easy.
Samm from Killeen, TX
It's definitely waterproof! And definitely full coverage! The only thing is it dries super fast so you have to blend as soon as you lay it down so I do one eye at a time just FYI. It's right up there with Tarte's concealer!
Jackie Brown from IL
The formula of this concealer is super amazing and the coverage is the best I have ever tried!! I deal with pimples here and there and this is the best product to smooth those problem areas out and it blends so well. I use it every day on pimples and under my eyes... can't live without it. :)
Baby Cakes from Texas
I love the coverage this gives and how it hides imperfections on your face.
Best Concealer For Under-eye Rings on the Market
Tired Medical Student from Tennessee
This product stays on all day and actually covers my dark rings. I've been looking for a product for years, and now that I've found this product, I'll never buy another. I blend it with a light foundation and also use it to cover occasional zits (which it covers flawlessly).
LaurenT from North Carolina
I love this concealer! It is my go-to. It gives a perfect finish and stays on all day.
Tabol Parker from NC
I got this because I have the foundation, primer, setting spray in ALL NIGHTER. I'm not sure it does what it's supposed to; no matter what I do it doesn't conceal much of anything.
Tori from Columbus Ohio
I use this as concealer under the eyes and it does not blend well. It leaves a yellow tint under my eyes and make it look like I have thick, caked in make up.
JessJayy from San Antonio, Texas.
This worked better than Shape Tape for me!! Goes on lovely and distribution is great on a clean, well moisturized face. I am enjoying the staying power! Hides my hormonal acne well and lasts. I have combination skin. Oily in T zone, dry patches around the chin area.
Jen from Ohio
It truly sat right in my wrinkles/fine lines in my underwear area. It did not last at all to the "waterproof" it claims to be. My left eye got ready and sure enough the makeup was gone.
Neen from Albuquerque NM
Loved it at first but after a month or so it started to get dry and did not go on smooth at all. It creased and looked dry. Not worth the price at all.
PeachPie from OH
Medium to light coverage. Creases under eye really bad though and difficult to blend.
So disappointed-magnifies fine lines
K hawk from Iowa
Since UD is out of the weightless concealer, I tried the waterproof concealer for under eye circles. If you have any fine lines, you should skip this product. It looks like it was made to magnify lines, not hide them. Did not work at all for me.
Lisa from Santa Barbara
I bought this and the urban decay optical blurring brush. This stuff leaves streaks it looks awful! It's impossible to blend. I have also tried using a makeup sponge still looks terrible.
Janet from Redding, CA
I have extreme dark circles under my eyes and used Lancôme for years as the best coverage I could find. I think they discontinued the product I was using or at least I couldn't find it anymore. I've used a couple tubes of this and am happy that it evens the skin tone really well. I have very fair skin and use the fair neutral. It is very heavy and if you don't need a dense coverage you might want to try something else. I don't use a foundation but finish with a powder trying to avoid where I've used the concealer so as to avoid emphasizing any creases that decide to show up on my old skin. The concealer is matte and lasts prettty long so I don't need powder over it.
1/2 empty and won't blend
Ray from Ohio
Used it a few times and it was very hard to get anything out. Also would not blend with other foundations.
Amanda from Olympia
After so many years of searching for a concealer for my horribly dark under eyes, THIS is the go to product for me! I have combination skin and pink tones, this is perfect for what I need to cover up!
Holy grail of concealers
Makeup OCD from San Francisco CA
This is the best concealer I've ever used to cover pink and red blemish spots. I probably will not use under eye but maybe in the corners. Absolutely amazing. I have been using concealers for 30+ years and to me the is is the Holy Grail. I do not wear foundation, I only cover spots with concealer so it is especially important to get it right. I usually tap it on just the spot using the end of a Q-tip which most of the cotton removed. I might even use the head of a pin if I'm being a perfectionist. If needed I might finish with some powder which I tap on using an eyeshadow brush. In these photos I tested on my leg, not my face (luckily nothing to cover on my face today). I covered a horrible mosquito bite that I scratched raw and it is still scaly and healing and a small dark brown freckle/mole. If I was being a perfectionist I would have used my head of a pin trick to tap an extra layer in the center of the mole. Also, always be careful to feather and edges that may extend past the spot itself. Oh, and I ordered more than one shade because different parts of my face are different colors.
Full coverage that lasts!
Gris from Perris, CA
I'm not really a make up person and so I loved how it's full coverage where I just put a little and it goes a long a!
Lajaquee from Phoenix, AZ
I bought this thinking i'd love it but it completely creases my under eyes and its so dry, I tried doing other things to make it work but it does oxidize as well. NOT GOOD AT ALL.