Product Reviews Rated 4.54 out of 5 stars
63 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Perfect Length The Honest Company Extreme Length Mascara + Lash Primer has been the best thing that I have tried. I am so excited because I was not aware that there was a mascara that can lengthen my eyelashes extremely beautiful. I tend to have a problem with showing off my eyelashes with other mascaras as they clump my eyelashes. The Honest Company Extreme Length Mascara+ Lash Primer really showed off. As someone who has to wear a mask on a daily basis. I need my eyes to stand out. This mascara has made people hand out compliments in regards to my eyelashes. In my honest opinion, this brand is affordable. I would repurchase this brand as the compliments towards my eyelashes has increased my self-esteem. I would recommend this product to those who are looking for length in their eyelashes. **I received this product for free in exchange for my honest opinion.
Most Helpful Critical Review It's okay It's an okay product. The brush for the primer doesn't pick up a lot so it looks like there's nothing on my lashes and the mascara makes my lashes look like spider legs, which I personally am not a fan of. However, I also have short Asian lashes so it's hard for me to find a good mascara, but it was good to keep them curled up but not so much lengthening. I also just pop on falsies anyway because mascara alone doesn't do anything to my lashes. I wish it was better because I wanted to like it!
Reviewed by 63 customers A gift I'm super grateful for! 5
M. from 90210
I have tried SOO many mascaras, hoping one would help show my lashes a little better and this one is the best in a while!
Pretty lashes ! 5
T.J from USA
I like BIG 60's lashes and this definitely comes close! I use it for an everyday mascara and it always makes my minimum makeup days look more impressive! Best part of all! It comes off easy when I take my makeup off at night!
Not worth the price 1
Nope from Hesperia
I used once and will not use it again. The primer didn't make a difference. After sometime my eyelashes started falling off. Not for me personally.
Best Chemical-free Mascara! 4
Krissy from Vacaville, CA
I've been on the hunt for a low chemical mascara that is lengthening, volumizing and doesn't flake. So far, this one wins! My only complaint is that it there is not much product in the tube. But I guess that makes it more hygienic because it forces me to buy it more frequently. ;)
A great clean brand mascara 5
Mal from Michigan
Product works wonderful for being a clean beauty brand. I feel like other clean brand ones I've tried don't last all day and flake easily, but not this one! I usually don't like silicone wands but this one works with the help of the normal wand on the primer side. I love this. Best clean mascara I've tried!
I'm in love 5
Keek from California
Best mascara ever makes your lashes really big but the only thing is the primer does not last and don't cry or else it goes all over but this is must for sure
Great Mascara 5
Love Makeup from Georgia
I am really enjoying this mascara! It is beautiful and the primer helps it last a very long time!!!
It's okay 3
Carrie from Connecticut
It's an okay product. The brush for the primer doesn't pick up a lot so it looks like there's nothing on my lashes and the mascara makes my lashes look like spider legs, which I personally am not a fan of. However, I also have short Asian lashes so it's hard for me to find a good mascara, but it was good to keep them curled up but not so much lengthening. I also just pop on falsies anyway because mascara alone doesn't do anything to my lashes. I wish it was better because I wanted to like it!
Yes 5
Jen from MS
This is my new favorite!
I keep coming back 5
Nette from Drexel hill
This elongates my lashes and doesn't flake or irritate my eyes. No matter the other brands I try, I always come back to this one.
Love the result, hate the wand 4
ekatharine from Austin, TX
I love how this mascara makes my eyelashes look. It holds a curls well and the formula doesn't smudge a ton. My only complaint is the wand on the mascara side. I love the wand on the primer side with the natural bristles. The plastic wand on the mascara side is difficult to use. It makes my lashes look clumpy and does not evenly coat them. Getting a more natural, non-spidery look is quite difficult with the shape of the wand.
My Holy Grail Mascara 5
Lucy from IA
I have been exclusively using this mascara for over a year. It never flakes and keeps my super straight eyelashes curled all day. I bought this as gifts for so many friends and they have all been hooked on it. I have noticed the price has increased and it seems to dry out faster then it used to. Unfortunately, I'm hooked on this and will be buying it anyway!
Excellent Product that works! 5
Ck from Santa Cruz
This mascara is amazing, it works terrific! Great product!!
Love it! 5
Sam from Downey
It's natural & non-toxic!! It helps lashes look full!
Amazing product and value 5
An honest review from Downey
Honest beauty is amazing! They create natural (non-toxic) products that are good for you! This mascara really works and is worth it's value price point.
so good for my straight short lashes 5
cow1985 from Brooklyn NY
Love the 2-in-1 packaging. After curling I apply the primer, do some of the rest of my makeup, then go back and apply the mascara. One of the only mascaras I've tried that doesn't stain under my eyes with gray half moons by midday like a lot of other stuff! At this price too, just do it!
I already plan to buy this again. 5
Mal from Michigan
So happy this is a clean brand and it actually works great! A lot of clean brands are clumpy and smudge a lot but not this. I think the added primer helps a lot as it separates the lashes perfectly. It's a great duo!
So Good 5
ADKZ from USA
I have tried 3 to 30 dollars mascara, this one has become one of my favorites. i love it.
Wanted to love it 3
Teeehm from Ca
I wanted to love it, but it's extremely drying to my eyes. Every time I wear this my eye balls are dry.
My new favourite 5
K2kate57 from Ajax Ontario Canada (near Toronto)
I was really impressed with this product. I have bought all kinds of brands-expensive to drug store brands. Got this in a bonus addon at my beauty lux drug store. Was surprised and it's my new fav. Move over Smashbox and Clarins
Incredible 5
SSJJ from Columbus, OH
This product is so much better than I could have imagined. You do need to practice and learn how to use if you're not used to primer (you should let the primer sit for about 30 seconds before applying the mascara).
Incredible 5
SJ from Columbus, OH
The first try the mascara does not do what it's supposed to. You have to get comfortable using it especially if you don't normally use eyelash primer. But once the brush fills up with product over time with use and you learn how to use it, it's THE BEST mascara. I get compliments every single time I have it on
Great mascara! 4
Stacy from MN
Pigment payoff is very black. Though I understand it's a 2-in-1 product, I wish for a longer wand for each application. The results of the mascara is very beautiful - I have short lashes and this made them look longer.
Great BUT... 4
Mandy Prid from Elmhurst, IL
It was great at first, however it dried up so quickly. I mean, within a matter of DAYS!!! Makes me sad. Not sure if I received a bad batch or not. Might give it another shot and buy another one since my first one was so dry after I kid you not four days that I had to throw it out, but I'm scared I will have waisted my money and it will have dried out again:(.
Honest Mascara & Lash Primer 5
Mo from Georgia
This mascara and primer is AMAZING! I love that it is an all-in-one packaging. Now when I take it on the go, I'm not forgetting my primer or mascara because they are both there! I also loveeee the primer and mascara themselves. The primer is very lightweight and made a huge difference if I put it on. The mascara goes on nicely without clumps and stays for hours without melting on your face from the southern heat.
