Zoom
CUSTOMER REVIEWS
Stila Smudge Pots
REVIEW SNAPSHOT®
by PowerReviewsPros
- Long-lasting (75)
- Glides on smoothly (69)
- Blends easily (67)
- Easy to apply (64)
- Doesn't run (62)
Cons
- Difficult to apply (17)
- Clumpy (8)
- Difficult to remove (6)
- Smudges or runs (6)
- Smudges or flakes (5)
Best Uses
- Everyday (100)
- Going out (86)
- Thicker line (44)
- Thin defined line (39)
- Smoky look (29)
- Reviewer Profile:
- Classic style (57), Natural style (34), Trendy style (34)
- Skin Tone:
- Fair (25), Medium (11)
Reviewed by 130 customers
Sort by
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »
Pros
- Blends Easily
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
Cons
- Fades Throughout Day
- NO STAYING POWER
- Not Long-Lasting
- Smudges or Runs
Best Uses
- Skip It
Comments about Stila Smudge Pot:
This did not and would not stay on.
Pros
- Doesn't Run
- Long-Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
- Everyday
Comments about Stila Smudge Pot:
I use this liner in the summer because it can look like a light pencil liner, but stays in place when it gets hot. The product always dries up before I use it all, but I still only have to buy it once a year.
Pros
Cons
- Difficult To Apply
Best Uses
Comments about Stila Smudge Pot:
I found this product unsatisfactory and disappointing. It does not blend smoothly and leaves uneven and unsightly coverage of my eyelids. I used it as an eyeshadow, not liner. I plan to return it.
Pros
- Doesn't Run
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
- Everyday
Comments about Stila Smudge Pot:
I was recommended this product and want pass on the recommendation.
Pros
- Blends Easily
- Bold Color
- Doesn't Run
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
Cons
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Thicker Line
Comments about Stila Smudge Pot:
I just love the smudge pots.
Pros
Cons
- Clumpy
- Difficult To Apply
Best Uses
Comments about Stila Smudge Pot:
I bought this product a month ago, hearing all of my friends rave about their smudge pots. But this brand is extremely hard to use. Not smooth or easy to apply at all...too clumpy. I've only had this smudge pot for a few weeks and it seemed to dry out after just a few days...now it's almost impossible to apply. And yes, I do seal the lid tightly.
Pros
- Blends Easily
- Bold Color
- Doesn't Run
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
- Fades Throughout Day
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Going Out
Comments about Stila Smudge Pot:
Top eyeliner!
Pros
- Blends Easily
- Bold Color
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
- Clumpy
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Thicker Line
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Stila Smudge Pot:
It's a little clumpy but glides on really well. Good thing is you can control thickness of eyeliner. Bad thing, no eyeliner brush comes with it. At this price, you would expect it to have its own eyeliner brush.
Pros
- Bold Color
- Long-Lasting
Cons
- Difficult To Apply
- Difficult to Remove
Best Uses
- Everyday
Comments about Stila Smudge Pot:
I needed a new black gel eyeliner, one like M.A.C that I had been using and really like. I was told by an Ulta associate to try the Stila brand. However, I did not like it. I found that it was hard to put on, did not go on smoothly and it pulled at my lower lashes. I felt like it dried to quickly before I could get to my eyes so it flaked alot. Also, the pot seem to dry out to only after a few uses. I returned and exchanged it for the smashbox pot and love that one.
Pros
- Blends Easily
- Doesn't Run
- Easy Removal
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Going Out
- Smoky Look
- Thicker Line
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Stila Smudge Pot:
I believe I've tried EVERY eyeliner ever made. I keep coming back to Smudgepots. Lasts until you take it off.
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »
