Zoom
CUSTOMER REVIEWS
Physicians Formula Plentiful Thickening Masacara
REVIEW SNAPSHOT®
by PowerReviewsPros
- Doesn't clump (27)
- Applies evenly (23)
- Defines & separates (15)
- Great brush (12)
- Adds volume (11)
Cons
- Dries out quickly (9)
- Sticky texture (4)
Best Uses
- Anytime (23)
- Daytime (12)
- Going out (3)
- Reviewer Profile:
- Classic style (21), Natural style (20), Trendy style (3)
Reviewed by 47 customers
Sort by
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »
Pros
- Adds Volume
- Defines & Separates
Cons
Best Uses
- Anytime
Comments about Physicians Formula PlentiFull Thickening Mascara:
I've used this mascara for over 4 years and will never change! No clumping or tears.
Pros
Cons
- Dries Out Quickly
- Sticky Texture
Best Uses
- Anytime
Comments about Physicians Formula PlentiFull Thickening Mascara:
Was disappointed in this product. Mascara does
not seem moist and does not coat the brush.
Will not order it again.
Pros
- Adds Volume
- Applies Evenly
- Defines & Separates
- Lengthens
Cons
Best Uses
- Anytime
Comments about Physicians Formula PlentiFull Thickening Mascara:
I prefer waterproof mascara. Wanted to give this brand a try.
Pros
- Applies Evenly
- Defines & Separates
- Doesn't Clump
- Natural
Cons
- Dry formula
Best Uses
- Daytime
Comments about Physicians Formula PlentiFull Thickening Mascara:
As a point of reference, I have straight, short, semi-full lashes that don't keep a curl 98 percent of the time.
This mascara is definitely good for daily use as it is a drier formula that can be brushed through the lashes once or twice for a work friendly look, or built up for a little bit of a thicker looking lash line.
I will say that the name "PlentiFULL Thickening" is misleading. This formula is so dry I would have to use 3-4 coats of mascara to achieve an eye with so-so drama. I'm afraid that the tube might dry out before the week ends.
With that being said, I do like the natural look it gives me. It actually can help hold the curl in my lashes (if I don't use too much!) and it really separates the hairs. It never looks clumpy and doesn't smudge or flake on me.
Overall, If you like the natural look, go for this mascara. If you'd rather have sexy, smoldering eyes, this is not the one for you.
Pros
Cons
- Applicator Brush Bad
- Does not go on easily
- Dries Out Quickly
Best Uses
- Anytime
Comments about Physicians Formula PlentiFull Thickening Mascara:
I will only use this product because I purchased it and don't want my money to go to waste. I have purchased this product in the past and loved it, however they have changed the brush and the bristols are too far apart and it is very difficult to apply to my lashes. Again I will never purchase this product again.
Pros
- Applies Evenly
- Doesn't Clump
Cons
Best Uses
- Anytime
Comments about Physicians Formula PlentiFull Thickening Mascara:
good value. I just needed something basic that wouldn't flake since I'm a contact lens wearer, nor would cause an allergic reaction (I'm very sensitive to allergens). This was a mild, basic, and all-purpose use mascara.
Pros
- Applies Evenly
- Defines & Separates
- Doesn't Clump
- Washes easily
Cons
- Not The Most Voluminizing
- Only Slightly Defines
Best Uses
- Daytime
Comments about Physicians Formula PlentiFull Thickening Mascara:
I've been using this product because I'm tired of greasy make-up removers and looking raccoon-eyed by the end of the day due to smeary, clumpy "waterproof" mascaras. The look with this product is more subtle, but I think it is gentler and leaves my lashes in better condtion.
Pros
- Adds Volume
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Physicians Formula PlentiFull Thickening Mascara:
the price is definitely right and it definitely adds voloume without irritation to the eyes. A+
Pros
- Doesn't Clump
Cons
- Thin
Best Uses
- Daytime
Comments about Physicians Formula PlentiFull Thickening Mascara:
I use this product everyday for work and its just ok. It isn't really anything like the name implies. Kind of disapointing on everything but price...I guess you get what you pay for.
Pros
- Applies Evenly
- Defines & Separates
- Doesn't Clump
- Great Brush
Cons
Best Uses
- Anytime
- Daytime
- Going Out
Comments about Physicians Formula PlentiFull Thickening Mascara:
i like the mascara but i dont think it is bold enough.....you have to put on like 5 coats to really see it. it also doesnt add as much volume as i would like or lengthen. overall...it's ok
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »

