Zoom
CUSTOMER REVIEWS
Revlon Color Stay Overtime Length Waterproof Mascara
REVIEW SNAPSHOT®
by PowerReviewsPros
- Defines & separates (23)
- Applies evenly (19)
- Great brush (19)
- Lengthens (19)
- Doesn't clump (15)
Cons
- Difficult to remove (26)
- Flakes (15)
- Dries out quickly (8)
- Sticky texture (8)
- Smudges or runs (4)
Best Uses
- Anytime (27)
- Daytime (10)
- Going out (8)
- Reviewer Profile:
- Classic style (25), Natural style (21), Trendy style (5)
Reviewed by 52 customers
Sort by
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »
Pros
- Applies Evenly
- Defines & Separates
- Doesn't Clump
- Great Brush
- Lengthens
Cons
Best Uses
- Anytime
- Daytime
- Going Out
Comments about Revlon Color Stay Overtime Length Waterproof Mascara:
I have been waiting for this to come back!! The only issue I have is the brush holds too much and I wipe off extra on a paper towel. But it is great other wise, lasts all day, looks natural, not clumpy.
Pros
- Adds Volume
Cons
- Clumps
- Does not apply evenly
- Dries Out Quickly
Best Uses
- Anytime
Comments about Revlon Color Stay Overtime Length Waterproof Mascara:
This product would be great if it did not dry so quickly. I dries before I am finished applying it and as a result, it clumps.
Pros
- Applies Evenly
- Defines & Separates
- Doesn't Clump
- Doesn't irritate
Cons
Best Uses
- Anytime
- Daytime
- Going Out
Comments about Revlon Color Stay Overtime Length Waterproof Mascara:
Love it and it isn't irritating my super sensitive eyes.
Pros
- Doesnt flake
- Doesnt Smudge
- Lengthens
Cons
- A little clumpy
Best Uses
- Anytime
- Daytime
- Going Out
Comments about Revlon Color Stay Overtime Length Waterproof Mascara:
I HAVE VERY SENSITIVE EYES. THIS IS THE FIRST PRODUCT I HAVE USED THAT TRULY DOESNT FLAKE OFF OR SMUDGE WHEN I RUB MY EYESE-WHICH IS VERY FREQUENT.
Pros
- Great Brush
- Lengthens
Cons
- Difficult To Remove
Best Uses
- Anytime
Comments about Revlon Color Stay Overtime Length Waterproof Mascara:
I had Rimmed mascara that just wasn't working for me, so I bought this and I really like it. The short-bristled brush is really easy for me to control. I don't make spider tracks all over my eye shadow. My biggest complaints are that it is really hard to remove-I have to use remover AND wash twice, and it also clumps. Nothing you can't correct, but it's a bit more time consuming. But if you fall asleep and wear it overnight, you won't wake up with raccoon eyes. I will buy this again.
Pros
Cons
- Difficult To Remove
- Flakes
- Smudges or Runs
- Sticky Texture
Best Uses
Comments about Revlon Color Stay Overtime Length Waterproof Mascara:
Smudges, flakes, used once and threw out.
Pros
- Great Brush
Cons
- Clumps
- Difficult To Remove
Best Uses
Comments about Revlon Color Stay Overtime Length Waterproof Mascara:
This mascara is awful. My eyes are raw every night from trying to use remover cloths on it for 10 minutes. And, it never fully comes off. No matter how many times I wipe it, there is still black on the cloth. When I finally think its gone, I attempt to put it back on the next morning, the leftover mascara makes it clump to the point where I have like 5 eyelashes. And, when I try to curl my eyelashes they stick to the curler because it's never ever gone. I feel like if I keep using it it's just going to ruin my eyelashes.
Pros
- Lightweight
- Smudge free
Cons
Best Uses
- Daytime
Comments about Revlon Color Stay Overtime Length Waterproof Mascara:
This is the rebirth of Revlon's colorstay gel overtime 3 day mascara from quite a few years ago. While this new version still has great stay put ability, it does have the more consistency than the older version, hence it is a bit clumpy. My eyelash separator fixes that. When you have problems with every mascara smudging an hour after wearing it, including every trick in the book to prevent it, you try anything and everything. This did stay on and I had no smudges for 14 hours. I couldn't ask for more. It is hard to remove, comparative to other mascara, but a good quality one should work.
Pros
- Lengthens
Cons
- Clumpy
- Difficult To Remove
- Does not go on evenly
- Flakes
Best Uses
- None
Comments about Revlon Color Stay Overtime Length Waterproof Mascara:
I did not like this mascara at all, waste of my money, will be throwing it away and it did not go on nicely and left my eyelashes with flakes and pieces of the mascara on them. Not good.
Pros
- Doesn't Clump
Cons
- Difficult To Remove
- No lengthening
- Not Effective
- No volume
Best Uses
Comments about Revlon Color Stay Overtime Length Waterproof Mascara:
Pretty bad. Barely looks like you've put anything on, doesn't lengthen or add volume or barely add color. But almost impossible to get off, even with makeup remover.
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »

