Zoom
CUSTOMER REVIEWS
Almay Eyeliner
REVIEW SNAPSHOT®
by PowerReviewsPros
- Easy to apply (37)
- Glides on smoothly (36)
- Long-lasting (30)
- Doesn't run (28)
- Easy removal (25)
Cons
- Fades throughout day (6)
- Smudges or runs (6)
Best Uses
- Everyday (36)
- Going out (22)
- Thicker line (19)
- Thin defined line (17)
- Smoky look (8)
- Reviewer Profile:
- Classic style (19), Natural style (16), Trendy style (4)
Reviewed by 39 customers
Sort by
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »
Pros
- Bold Color
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
- Smudges or Runs
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Going Out
- Thicker Line
Comments about Almay Eyeliner:
This is my favorite pencil eyeliner. It goes on smoothly and evenly, which is the biggest problem I find in different eyeliner products I try. I use this daily. Sometimes it smudges a bit throughout the day, but not too bad. I only wish I could get it to do a bit thinner of a line.
Pros
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
Cons
- Smudges or Runs
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Almay Eyeliner:
I use this product daily. It smudges a little during the day but not as much as other brands I have used in the past.
Pros
- Doesn't Run
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Thicker Line
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Almay Eyeliner:
I use this product every single day. I carry it in my purse and at home. It's not real easy to find in stores sometimes.
Pros
- Doesn't Run
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
- Everyday
Comments about Almay Eyeliner:
Easy to use and long lasting. Doesn't smudge to your upper eye lid. Best one I've used yet!
Pros
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Almay Eyeliner:
This is awesome! I love Almay and this eyeliner is for me. You can use this anywhere, from filling in eyebrows to tightling!!
It's creamy and long lasting but isnt too creamy which makes the staying power on my waterline terrific. one stick is lasting me over a year...so i'm very happy
Pros
- Bold Color
- Doesn't Run
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Going Out
- Thicker Line
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Almay Eyeliner:
This product works well as an eyeliner and an eyebrow pencil. I use it to fill in my eyebrows and my 19 yr. old uses it as an eyeliner. Love it! Now I just have to get her to buy her own...
Pros
- Bold Color
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
Cons
- Fades Throughout Day
- Smudges or Runs
Best Uses
- Thicker Line
Comments about Almay Eyeliner:
I have this and I hate it. If it smudges so easily, how can this last 16 hours? I've tried it with eye primer and eyeshadow, hoping that the shadow would serve as a buffer or something, but it was no use! This eyeliner is just way too creamy/moist, and for the price, find something else.
Pros
- Blends Easily
- Doesn't Run
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Almay Eyeliner:
I use liner regularly and companies keep getting rid of the ones I like. Almay are the
best so I ordered this. It proved to be lighter than others I have used but it is creamy and easy to wear
Pros
- Doesn't Run
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
- Difficult to Remove
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Going Out
- Thicker Line
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Almay Eyeliner:
A friend told me about this and I've been using it ever since. It goes on really easy and stays on the whole day. I do find that you need eye makeup remover to get it off though.
Pros
- Bold Color
- Doesn't Run
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
- Fades Throughout Day
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Going Out
- Smoky Look
- Thicker Line
Comments about Almay Eyeliner:
My "can't live without" beauty item is eye liner. So I have tried DOZENS to find the best one. And this is it! I like a slightly smudged (I can use my finger with this eye liner to lightly smudge the line I drew), medium thick line on my eye lid from inner eye to just past outer corner, and on my water line from outer corner to middle. This way of applying it makes my small eyes look MUCH bigger. This eyeliner does a perfect job. It's creamy enough so it doesn't tug and pull the skin but firm enough that it doesn't get messy or draw a line that's way too thick. When I use an eye shadow primer, this liner lasts a good 4 hours. And then it's a cinch to just darken up any areas that are looking a little light. It comes off easily with Almay's eye makeup remover pads. (LOVE the oil-free ones!!) I like to try new products and rarely stock up on any one item but I just bought 5 of these pencils to have on hand. The only con I can think of is that you can't twist up the color stick too high or it may crack off. Sometimes, it cracks even when u don't do that which could mean you got a defective one or because the pencil got dropped or too dry or something. Otherwise, it's a great product that I highly recommend!!
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »

