Zoom
CUSTOMER REVIEWS
Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner
REVIEW SNAPSHOT®
by PowerReviewsPros
- Glides on smoothly (450)
- Easy to apply (419)
- Long-lasting (397)
- Doesn't run (337)
- Bold color (314)
Cons
- Smudges or runs (80)
- Fades throughout day (67)
- Difficult to apply (27)
- Difficult to remove (24)
- Bad color (9)
Best Uses
- Everyday (403)
- Going out (287)
- Thicker line (202)
- Thin defined line (191)
- Smoky look (173)
- Reviewer Profile:
- Classic style (281), Natural style (150), Trendy style (73)
Reviewed by 533 customers
Sort by
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »
Pros
- Nice color
Cons
- Fades Throughout Day
- Smudges or Runs
Best Uses
- Everyday
Comments about Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner:
I am very disappointed in this product the saleslady assured me that this product would last all day was waterproof smudge proof it faded and ran within two hours.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner:
Irritates my eyes. Probably will discontinue use if continues. Only used for 3 or 4 days
Pros
- Doesn't Run
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner:
I am always on the hunt for unique colors and Stila's turquoise smudge stick is definitely a one of a kind color. I searched through all of Ulta looking for an inexpensive dupe but couldn't find a single one. This color has the perfect mix of blue, green, and white to make a gorgeous matte mint color. The reason this doesn't get 5 lippies from me is because you can't roll the liner back down once you roll it up, so make sure you take up small amounts being careful not to overdo it.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner:
Goes on smooth.
Pros
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
Cons
- Difficult to Remove
- Smudges or Runs
Best Uses
Comments about Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner:
After about one hour, this was all over my eyelids!
Pros
- Blends Easily
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Smoky Look
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner:
dont like that can not turn back down
took a few times to learn how to best use it
Pros
- Blends Easily
- Doesn't Run
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
Cons
- Fades Throughout Day
Best Uses
Comments about Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner:
LOVE!
Pros
- All Positives
- Blends Easily
- Bold Color
- Doesn't Run
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
- No negatives
Best Uses
- Daily Use
- Everyday
Comments about Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner:
I am happy with the product - I should be satisfied for the price that I paid - no coupon or discount!
Pros
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
- Expensive
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Smoky Look
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner:
Applies nice and lasts all day.
Pros
- Bold Color
- Glides On Smoothly
Cons
- Fades Throughout Day
- Poor Quality Package
- Smudges or Runs
Best Uses
Comments about Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner:
I was excited to try this as it came recommended as a great pencil with easy and smooth application and all day staying power. I gave this a try. First it was almost too soft and while the application was smooth it was hard to get an even and consistant line as the color stick literally collapsed and pancaked with the slightest pressure. I have been having some allergy problems and my eyes have watered a little at work. By midday half of my bottom liner was just gone. Not smudged, gone. So much for water proof. I decided to give it one more try and went to apply the next day to find that the product would not advance or retract from the pencil. Very poor quality packaging. Not at all what I expect for the price. Returned this.
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »
