Zoom
The deep carbon-black color makes for a spectacular eye look.
CUSTOMER REVIEWS
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
REVIEW SNAPSHOT®
by PowerReviewsPros
- Easy to apply (350)
- Long-lasting (342)
- Glides on smoothly (339)
- Doesn't run (311)
- Bold color (234)
Cons
- Fades throughout day (39)
- Smudges or runs (38)
- Difficult to remove (30)
- Difficult to apply (29)
- Bad color (6)
Best Uses
- Everyday (368)
- Thin defined line (302)
- Going out (274)
- Thicker line (228)
- Smoky look (90)
- Reviewer Profile:
- Classic style (224), Natural style (125), Trendy style (76)
Reviewed by 451 customers
Sort by
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »
Pros
- Bold Color
- Doesn't Run
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
- Difficult to Remove
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Going Out
- Thicker Line
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner:
Great eyeliner. Tiny tip. Goes on easily. A bit difficult to completely remove.
Pros
- Bold Color
- Doesn't Run
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Going Out
- Thicker Line
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner:
I use this eyeliner on my top lids everyday. I don't wash my face everyday so when I sleep with it, I can either swipe it off easily with lotion on a cotton swab or if it's still mostly intact, just touch it up. It has the benefit of being waterproof AND easy to remove. No ripping your eyelids apart! And it WILL NOT smudge or melt, so it makes and keeps a clean line. It's also really easy to put on for those, like me, that are eyeliner drawing challenged. :)
Pros
- Doesn't Run
- Long-Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Going Out
Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner:
For someone that owns every color under the sun in eye shadows and eye liners, here is one liner that is unique. I have never seen such a beautiful matte mint green liquid liner before. This looks stunning with soft neutral colors. The only reason this doesn't get 5 lippies is because I had to do 3 layers to get an even opaque color. For best results, put the felt tip on its side and glide it across your lash line. For the second and third layer, with the felt tip still on its side, pat the color over the first layer till desired opacity. If you use the tip, it's going to end up streaky. I didn't have any issues at all with fading or smudging, it lasted me all day.
Pros
- Bold Color
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
Cons
- Smudges or Runs
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Going Out
- Smoky Look
- Thicker Line
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner:
Like the liner but is not waterproof, unless I am really greasy?!
Pros
- Bold Color
- Doesn't Run
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
Cons
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Going Out
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner:
My biggest thing is that it stays on all day and give me a nice defined line.
Pros
- Doesn't Run
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
- Fades Throughout Day
Best Uses
- Going Out
- Thicker Line
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner:
It goes on well, dries super fast, and stays on well as long as you aren't sweating or doing anything too active or outdoorsy. My only real complaint is that the formula is relatively thin, and doesn't give the same 'look' as most other liquid eyeliners.
Pros
- Accurate Lining
- Bold Color
- Doesn't Run
- Easy Removal
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Going Out
- Thicker Line
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner:
I will not use another liner. For me, I like a very defined line on my upper eyelids above and in between my lashes. This liner has a very precise end to it which enables me to accomplish this task. The added bonus is that it stays put all day until I wash it off.
Pros
- Doesn't Run
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
- Difficult to Remove
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Going Out
- Smoky Look
- Thicker Line
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner:
I like the control
Pros
- Doesn't Run
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
- Difficult to Remove
- Pricey
Best Uses
- Everyday
- Going Out
- Smoky Look
- Thicker Line
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner:
I use the side of the felt tip to get an even line and tap along my eye line. If I want a finer line I can just use the tip. It stays put, no flaking or raccoon eyes. I have tried several Stila colors over the years and keep coming back to the brand. Only drawback is that I have to buy it frequently because it either dries out or runs out.
Pros
- Bold Color
- Doesn't Run
- Easy To Apply
- Glides On Smoothly
- Long-Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
- Going Out
- Thin Defined Line
Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner:
I have never used a liquid liner before so was unsure at first. However I love this product!! I feel like it goes on so much smoother then any other pencil ever did. It also stays on and in place for the entire day! Will for sure be using this product for a very long time!!
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »
