Zoom
CUSTOMER REVIEWS
L'Oreal Extra Volume Collagen Mascara
REVIEW SNAPSHOT®
by PowerReviewsPros
- Adds volume (163)
- Lengthens (127)
- Applies evenly (125)
- Great brush (123)
- Defines & separates (109)
Cons
- Flakes (37)
- Dries out quickly (23)
- Difficult to remove (21)
- Sticky texture (19)
- Smudges or runs (16)
Best Uses
- Anytime (163)
- Daytime (56)
- Going out (48)
- Never (3)
- Reviewer Profile:
- Classic style (114), Natural style (49), Trendy style (43)
Reviewed by 275 customers
Sort by
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »
Pros
- Adds Volume
- Applies Evenly
- Defines & Separates
- Lengthens
Cons
Best Uses
- Anytime
Comments about L'Oreal Extra Volume Collagen Mascara:
I have very short thin lashes and this mascara makes them so long and adds so much volume. I normally need 2 mascaras to get the job done but this does it all! I no longer need to use fake lashes! Some people think it's clumpy but I kind of like the clump full look so I have no complaints about it. I will be buying this mascara again!
Pros
- Adds Volume
- Great Brush
- Lengthens
Cons
- Clumps easily
- Harsh For Sensitive Eyes
- Smudges or Runs
Best Uses
- Anytime
Comments about L'Oreal Extra Volume Collagen Mascara:
I purchased this product about a month ago and had never used it before. I switched from the mascara I had been using for years to try something new. Up until several days ago, I had used this L'Oreal every day since the purchase. The one thing that I absolutely loved about this mascara, is that it definitely adds amazing volume to your lashes! I did find that the application was uneven and clumped easily, but I was able to manipulate the mascara a bit to get an even finish. After 1 week of every-day use, I noticed that my eyes started to become itchy and irritated. I figured it was just my pollen allergies. However, it progressively got worse and 3 weeks later, both my eyes (tear ducts, lids, and lower lashes) were completely swollen, red, and itchy. I stopped using the mascara for a couple of days and of course, my eyes got better very quickly. While I love the volume of this mascara, I highly recommend against this mascara for anyone with sensitive eyes. I would definitely consider this to be non-hypoallergenic.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about L'Oreal Extra Volume Collagen Mascara:
Dissappointed in myself, since I did not keep the receipt or the packaging, in which to return it.
Pros
- Does Not Smudge
- Easy To Use
- Goes On Great
- Long-Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about L'Oreal Extra Volume Collagen Mascara:
I first used Voluminous (since it first came out) and then this product. I love them both, but have used Extra Volume since trying it. I have always had problems with smudging. I tried many of the expensive department store brands and they smudged by mid-day. Once I latched onto Voluminous/Extra Volume mascara I have not had to try anything else. I'm hooked.
Pros
- Easy To Use
- Gentle
- Great Color
- Long-Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
- New Look
Comments about L'Oreal Extra Volume Collagen Mascara:
My lashes are thick and long.
- Commitment To Color:
- Temporary
Pros
- Easy To Use
- Long-Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
- New Look
Comments about L'Oreal Extra Volume Collagen Mascara:
This is my go-to product for mascara.
- Commitment To Color:
- Temporary
Pros
- Adds Volume
- Applies Evenly
- Defines & Separates
- Doesn't Clump
- Great Brush
- Lengthens
Cons
Best Uses
- Anytime
Comments about L'Oreal Extra Volume Collagen Mascara:
I have searched for a long time. I have sensitive eyes and this product is awesome
Pros
Cons
- Clumps
- Sticky Texture
Best Uses
Comments about L'Oreal Extra Volume Collagen Mascara:
I use Loreal products all the time - I can't remember when I've gotten such a clumpy mascara before. after the third 'brush through' my lashes started clumping. i thought I had too much product on the wand so next time I really scraped the brush down to minimize the amount of mascara on the brush - nope - still clumpy. Very disappointed in this mascara.
Pros
- Adds Volume
- Applies Evenly
- Defines & Separates
- Great Brush
- Lengthens
Cons
Best Uses
- Anytime
- Daytime
- Going Out
Comments about L'Oreal Extra Volume Collagen Mascara:
This mascara is great. If I am in a hurry and only have time for one coat it is sufficient but if I add a second coat, WOW! Have to be precise and take a bit of time to make sure it does not clump when going on but it is well worth the extra seconds.
Pros
- Adds Volume
- Applies Evenly
- Defines & Separates
- Doesn't Clump
- Great Brush
- Lengthens
- Pretty Packaging
Cons
Best Uses
- Anytime
Comments about L'Oreal Extra Volume Collagen Mascara:
I used to spend tons of cash buying Designer products, not any more. This product is comparable.
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »

